Deja Blue II

By Kieran Moriarty

Karl Marx once famously said “History repeats itself, first as tragedy, second as a farce”. Although Marx was musing upon far grander issues than the beautiful game, you cannot help but think of this quotation when surveying the aftermath of Jose Mourinho’s second acrimonious departure from Chelsea FC.

A figure adored by his own fans as much as he is loathed by rivals, The Special One once again has been jettisoned from the club that arguably made his reputation. Despite signing a four year contract at the start of this season and earnestly discussing the establishment of a dynasty for years to come at Stamford Bridge, the Special One again finds himself in the unemployment line.

However this time, the circumstances are different for Europe’s greatest nomadic manager. Unlike his previous explosive exits from a European heavyweight club, it would appear this may be the first occasion in which Mourinho can no longer guarantee falling into another gilded managerial position, following the farce that has been Chelsea this season. Even the bullish Portuguese will now departs Stamford Bridge undoubtedly scarred by this traumatic campaign

Much like his greatest title-winning teams, the Special One has been absurdly consistent in terms of his career trajectory ever since his Porto team stormed to an incredible Champions League title in 2003, an achievement that sent Mourinho’s managerial status into supernova. In each of his subsequent managerial posts which have taken him to Chelsea, Inter, Real Madrid and back to Stamford Bridge, Mourinho has assembled dominant and impressive sides, built within his own meticulously fashioned mould and established his credentials as one of his generation’s most  outstanding club managers, winning domestic titles across three different national leagues, along with well several domestic honours and a Champions League trophy to boot.

Yet history has repeated itself. A few days ago, Jose Mourinho’s second tenure at Chelsea came to end in the same fashion as his first and his post at Real Madrid two years earlier. The baffling third season syndrome which has doggedly clung to the Special One has struck again with all of the eerily familiar characteristics of past appointments.

This season, Chelsea have demonstrated all of the symptoms of a Mourinho side plagued by third season syndrome. A jaded team of players who no longer look capable or willing to perform to the standards that their manager expects but instead have succumbed to an alarming decline in form as a collective. Several senior players who appear evidently disgruntled with the manager’s selection policies and tactical formations, who display their frustrations through poor performances and petulance on the pitch. An increasingly confrontational Jose Mourinho, picking fights with the media, his own players, referees and truly bizarre other targets (for Eve Carneiro, see UNICEF) to misguidedly try and deflect attention away from his stuttering team. This abysmal melting pot culminates to transform a team once renowned for solidity, organisation, discipline and ruthlessness, into an insipid, fragile and vulnerable side who any opponent would fancy their chances of beating.

First and foremost, I am a Chelsea fan and I will always be grateful for what Mourinho has done for the club. His first tenure will always represent a rose-tinted period on account of the success and silverware he achieved, along with breaking the Arsenal- Manchester United duopoly which had been established in the late 90s and early 2000s, to make Chelsea genuine contenders each year.

In his second spell, Mourinho was also successful. Following the achievement of his first two Premier League titles for Chelsea.  critics accused him of assembling a superpowered team that won leagues titles on the basis of their financial rather power than his managerial ability, Mourinho refuted this criticism and showed he could excel as the head of a more frugal and financially moderate Chelsea regime. In all of his transfer windows (except last summer) Mourinho recruited well in the transfer window while also squeezing out masterful performances from his veterans such as John Terry and Cesc Fabregas. He constructed another industrious and athletic team which at times were capable of playing expansive football when appropriate, as demonstrated by their scintillating first third of last season, a campaign which they went onto become champions with ease.

However this is where the praise stops and the inquest begins. Back as early as October, I highlighted the plentiful problems I saw at Chelsea. Without repeating myself too much; the squad was not accordingly refreshed and thus there has been no choice but to persevere with players that are clearly not in form or suffering from the inevitable deterioration of age, as their powers wane.

This has been evident with Terry, Ivanovic and Fabregas yet their younger counterparts have fared no better. Cahill, Oscar, Remy and surprisingly even the ever hard-working Azpilcueta have failed to make the step up required to compensate for this decline while star players such as Costa and Hazard have been well below the high standards that made them so instrumental last year. The latter two in particular have encapsulated everything that is wrong at Chelsea this season; disinterest, petulance, anonymity on the pitch. The only player that can escape with any sort of credibility thus far this season is Willian, a player who should be an example to Costa and Hazard.

In my previous article, I stated my hope that Mourinho would be able to turn it around. He has always seemed to leave when the going gets tough and I willed him to demonstrate his managerial talent in an unfamiliar way, by somehow finding a way out of this crisis, a feat that would have been far more impressive than winning a relatively poor competitive Premier League in my opinion.

The Special One has tried everything. He has rotated players, dropped big names, listened to the players and put them in positions they feel they perform best. He has experimented with formations, criticised players in the press while lavishing praise on others. He has used the carrot and the stick methods yet both have been equally ineffective. In classic Mourinho style, he has attempted to form a siege mentality in the hope that his players subscribe to this “us against the world rhetoric” and finally take up the challenge and fight back.

Alas, it has all been to no avail. I despise the modern day managerial merry go round in which sacking is seen as the immediate response to a downturn in results or failure to hit the expectations of the board. However on this occasion, even with the relative dearth of managerial candidates on the market that would be appropriate for the Chelsea job, I think it was time for Mourinho to go.

To his rare credit, Roman Abramovich and the Chelsea board have been uncharacteristically patient with Mourinho and given him every opportunity to turn this nightmare situation around. A decline from champions to fanciful relegation contenders is simply unprecedented in the Premier League era yet this is the situation which Chelsea have descended into. The Special One appeared to try everything but nothing worked. From that perspective, he had to go.

When I look back at Mourinho’s second spell at Chelsea, I will look at it with a sense of sadness, despite last season’s title win.  Like Didier Drogba’s ill advised homecoming last season, things are never as good the second time around. At times in his second tenure, I have been disappointed and quite frankly embarrassed by Mourinho’s comments and behaviour. I willed for a return to the sparkling, vibrant personality that captivated us all on when he came to England and opposed this grizzled, curmudgeonly and irritable spectre who had taken his place.

In terms of who will be the next Chelsea manager, I have no idea who it will be and it is an issue for another article.  In terms of where Mourinho goes next, I also do not have an answer for that. It is indisputable that this season has represented the nadir of Jose Mourinho’s career. How he responds and where he chooses to rebuild his career is another interesting debate that will surely be discussed in pubs all across the world for weeks to come. Yet one thing is for certain, wherever the Special One does choose to go, it will now reset him to the man whom gave that memorable press conference in 2004. For the first time in 11 years, Mourinho needs to show the world once again why he is the Special One.

Photograph: Ronnie MacDonald via Flickr