Degrees: are they worth it?

Remarkably, the answer to this blunt question is anything but blunt, requiring as it does, the consideration of what exactly a degree involves (both on paper and in between the lines). At some level, most of us were drawn to university because of its repute for enhancing job prospects and broadening the horizons of our employability. For many, however, this attractive sheen is reduced when we consider that tuition fees currently stand at £3,145 and are rising.

What’s interesting is that, in spite of this, the proportion of students undertaking further study in the form of Masters or PGCEs is at a record high. Some get professional qualifications for direct entry into careers such as business and law, though many may merely be trying to get an edge in the crowded job market.

The worrying advice for such academic enthusiasts is that this, sadly, doesn’t always work. According to a survey of 35 big graduate employers conducted by High Fliers Research Ltd., it is a “fallacy” to believe that employers are keen on postgraduate qualifications. The research claims that only 5% of employers are in fact willing to pay more for job applicants with Masters degrees. This means that unless a qualification is directly relevant to a certain post, it is unlikely to guarantee you the job you want, or even boost the first pay packet!

Today, most employers, speaking with the grandparental wisdom and experience of many years spent in the service of one career, argue that young people leave schools and universities with academic qualifications, but without the employability skills required to pick up the demands of a working life.

In recognition of this, the government’s educational reform programme, the Department for Children, Schools, and Families (DCSF), has decided to introduce a series of new qualifications called Diplomas, available at Foundation, Intermediate, and Advanced levels for learners aged 14 – 19. These diplomas are being developed in 17 broad sectors, and by 2013, learners will have an entitlement to all lines of education, with a design that is aimed at promoting a wide range of employability skills that will be delivered in a work-related context.

But let’s face it, “useful” and “relevant” though these diplomas may sound, are they actually on par, and dare we say, equivalent, to a university degree, and more importantly, the university experience? Let’s also not forget that university is more than just the work demanded by our degrees. Apart from the comforting, CV-enriching benefits such as social-networking and personal development, university also leads to a fulfilment of intellectual curiosity (for those of us seeking it), the creation of life-long friendships, and the discovery and/or development of extra-curricular interests.

Not that planning for a career comes second to the aforementioned; unfortunately for all the procrastinators amongst us, earning a living is ultimately rather necessary to the nature of life. And call it the rules of society, or simply the way the ‘system’ works, but having a university degree does open up a lot of doors.

According to the Higher Education Careers Services Unit (HECSU), young graduates aged 21-30 have average earnings of £22,300 p.a., compared to £15,950 for non-graduates in the same age bracket, a difference of £6,350 per annum.