Defending the indefensible? Horse racing in the year 2019.
By Josh Gallichan
As the British horse racing calendar moves into the peak of the national hunt season with the Cheltenham Festival and Grand National on the horizon, the sport once again enters the public consciousness. The overbearing news is the recent outbreaks of equine flu, which caused a six-day halt to all UK horse racing in early February, and reignited concerns over animal welfare in the sport.
British horse racing finds itself in an increasingly strange position. While the rest of the world is marked by an increasing social consciousness which vilifies the decadent and cruel practices of the world, horse racing seems to continue as it always has. The sport’s retained place in popular culture seems to stand in odd defiance of contemporary trends and stranger still, shows little sign of ending any time soon.
The obvious issue of horse racing is the cruelty associated with the sport. In the first half of 2018, there were 83 horses killed on British racetracks and according to one website, the number of horses killed since March 2007 currently sits at 1,861. Perhaps the steady rise of this number can be slowed, but how many deaths is too many? UK horse racing bodies have cracked down on welfare and drug use in the sport but it has not removed these issues entirely.
Nobody wants to see horses suffer, especially those involved in the sport.
As a racing fan, this is difficult to grapple with. Nobody wants to see horses suffer, especially those involved in the sport. That is the big paradox of horse racing. Death and cruelty are really not in the best interests of anybody involved, and it makes no logical sense that they would want to see it happen. The majority of owners lose money through the costs associated with training a racehorse. It is not a shrewd investment but most do it due to a love of the sport and of the animals. Trainers and jockeys spend nearly every day with their stable; there is a connection to the animals beyond a purely financial one.
This is what makes horse racing difficult to come to terms with. People in the sport do not see it as comparable to something like bull-fighting or hunting because death and cruelty are not what people flock to racetracks for. It is really a case of cognitive dissonance in those involved. They do not want to see horses get hurt but they unfortunately play a part in it. If the British racing tradition is to continue, it seems obvious that more measures should be put in place to further reduce these issues. The current problem is how this should be done and who should enforce it.
It is really a case of cognitive dissonance in those involved
A big reason why racing will not disappear anytime soon is the sheer size of the associated industry. A 2014 report showed that horse racing is the UK’s second biggest sport behind football in terms of both revenue and attendance. It is also a cornerstone of the British gambling industry which currently employs around 108,000 people. Moreover, the UK thoroughbred breeding industry (admittedly rife with its own set of issues) contributed £427 million to the British economy in 2017. While these cold hard numbers by no means excuse the welfare issues, they do raise questions about the direction of the sport if we are to justify the morality of its contribution to the economy.

Beyond this economic argument, however, there is something much more difficult to quantify or even explain. There is an intangible romance to horseracing with its penchant for the underdog story. Take Colin Tizzard, the dairy farmer turned trainer who won the prestigious Cheltenham Gold Cup with Native River in 2018. Or the fact that bookmakers predicted an unprecedented 12.9 million punters would be placing bets on last year’s Grand National, many of these from people who would not otherwise be found near a bookie.
There is perhaps something shared between Tizzard’s rise and hapless punters sticking on a hopeful bet. Anybody can become a champion in the so-called ‘sport of kings’ and that is what makes it a compelling spectacle for so many people. It is a strange and controversial meeting point of passion, cruelty, money, and ambition which while certainly not faultless, is likely here to stay.
Photograph: Roger Blake via Flickr
