Defeat for Durham on derby day
By George Dagg

Durham Women ultimately came up short of clinching their second North East derby win of the season, with a disappointing 2-1 defeat at home to Sunderland.
Given Durham’s promising start to the season, with four wins out of the first five matches, and Sunderland’s relatively slow one, with just one win to their name, the Wildcats would likely have been considered favourites by many to emerge victorious. A strong opening ten minutes indicated as much; Durham controlled the tempo of these early stages and created three excellent opportunities to open the scoring.
In the 10th minute, it was Hannah Blake who was on hand to finish off a flowing team move to put Durham 1-0 up. Neat interplay down the left-hand side led to Carly Johns laying the ball off to Blake, who calmly slotted it into the top-right corner of the net. At this point, momentum was very much with the home side; however shortly after taking the lead, Durham had captain Sarah Wilson to thank for a crucial goal-line clearance that prevented Katie Kitching from equalising for the visitors.
Following this chance, it seemed as though Sunderland had been noticeably allowed back into the game, with Durham dropping deep in an attempt not to give up another opportunity on the break. The visitors began to control the ball, but the home side were successful in seeing out this period of pressure. Following Durham’s imposing start to the game, and the success of their pressing in generating high turnovers in those first ten minutes, it was surprising to see a Sunderland side who had not had any form of foothold in the match, until that point, be allowed such time and space to maintain control and possession.
The referee’s whistle spread a wave of shock around Maiden Castle
Ultimately, as the match and the horrendous weather conditions began to settle, neither team was able to assert themselves, with a long-range shot from Johns the closest either side came to the game’s next goal. In the 33rd minute, however, momentum swung very much towards Sunderland, with a penalty being awarded out of nowhere for the most minimal of contact; Becky Salicki was deemed to have pushed Sunderland’s Eleanor Dale in the front-left corner of the box.
The referee’s whistle spread a wave of shock around Maiden Castle. One supporter could even be heard on the pitch side microphone saying, “What are we seeing here?” From the opposite end of the ground, it was hard to see what the penalty had been given for. In fact, I suggest many supporters would not view the incident differently even when watching it back on the match highlights. In any case, Dale stepped up and slotted the penalty kick into the top-left corner – making it 1-1 at half time.
If the first half was end-to-end, and an enthralling watch, the second half, unfortunately, was anything but that. Just five minutes after the restart, Mary McAteer was on hand to convert from six yards at the end of a remarkably disjointed phase of play; the visitors won a series of aerial duels on the edge of the penalty box, and then fizzed a dangerous ball low across the goalmouth. Time seemed to stand still for McAteer as the ball squirmed its way along the six-yard line, and the Welsh international made no mistake from close range.
There is rather less to be said, however, for the remaining 40 minutes of the second half. Until the 70th minute, the game really felt flat, and the previously vocal, upbeat atmosphere at Maiden Castle now felt subdued and uninspired. Despite the three second-half substitutions that were then made, Durham struggled to create any clear-cut chances or maintain any sustained periods of pressure.
Lily Crosthwaite was arguably Durham’s most dangerous player throughout, and in the second half it was the winger who looked the most likely to create an opportunity for her side to draw level. On multiple occasions, Crosthwaite got the better of her defender in the final third, however, the home side just could not muster any real threat to the Sunderland goal from these situations.
Durham could have gone top of the league table with a win
As the clock ticked over into stoppage time, it was Durham who finally had all the momentum and territory. Yet Sunderland defended resolutely and looked composed in seeing out their advantage to take the victory – clearing the long balls and set pieces that Durham rained into their box in a desperate attempt to salvage a point. Full-time score: Durham 1 – 2 Sunderland.
One win for each of Durham, Newcastle and Sunderland in their three Women’s Championship derby matches so far this season suggests that all three of the North East’s teams will finish competitively this time around, and promises much for the return fixtures. It is also promising for the growth and therefore future of the Women’s game here in the North East that the region has three such competitive teams just one level below the WSL.
Durham could have gone top of the league table with a win; however, this should not necessarily deter the optimists amongst us from believing that they could still achieve something special this season.
Lineups:
Durham (4-2-3-1): Saunders, Briggs, Salicki, S. Wilson (c), Ayre (Ryan-Doyle 88’), Lambert, Hepple, Novak (Foster 72’), Blake (Robson 72’), Crosthwaite, Johns
Unused Subs: Bradley, Holmes, King, E. Wilson
Sunderland (4-3-3): Lambourne, Ede, Stapleton, Goddard, Beer (Corbyn 79’), Dear (McInnes 72’), Kitching, Fenton (c), McAteer (Watson 90’), Dale, Scarr
Unused Subs: Blench, Dunbar, Flannery, Jones, West
Photograph by: George Dagg

