Debate: Some degree courses are a waste of time
Yes by Jamie Sherman
New courses and changes to traditional degrees at this and other universities have lead to mockery amongst the self-important medic and engineer, but beyond mere degree snobbery there are in fact courses which simply amount to a waste of time. Degree titles such as Football Studies, Beauty Therapy and Spa Management and Television and Video Technology have lead to public ridicule, but beyond the titles, particular degrees are detrimental to the student, government and public.
It is unfair to say that a university course needs a particular amount of content to make it worth studying. One could never judge this objectively and content in one area may be more useful or prolific than the same quantity of content in another. Nor would it be fair to say that seemingly over-specific courses such as Architectural Glass or Basket Weaving are not worth their salt per se, because particular careers require such specialisation; the same argument would apply to Aerospace Engineering or Midwifery. What is determinable, and significant, is that some undergraduate courses do not require the university setting; they can be taught and learnt without the facilities of an institution of higher education and that is what makes them a waste of time.
Certain courses do no good for the students on them, since coming to university as an undergraduate involves a massive sacrifice which should be justified by the eventual benefits of doing so. Despite the substantial cost of a 3 year degree, students are often pressured to move away from their families and to follow the rules of their chosen institution for years of their youth. What make this worthwhile for the student is the academic experience gained and the employability of the resultant qualification. Those used to be outcomes of unquestionable worth, but their integrity is faltering. The real question worth considering here is whether the student is getting back more than they are putting in.
The academic credentials of a university make it the perfect setting for some degrees. Others could be taught better in another context. Ludicrous as it may sound to suggest teaching a plumbers’ apprenticeship at a university, this idea can be mocked only on the basis that it is being taught in the wrong environment. This is true of a number of other courses, such as Media Studies and Events Management. They ought to be taught. They ought to be read, but not at university. Setting up this sort of degree in a university simply makes no sense for the student, since they are forced to pay through the nose for skills they could be better learning in the workplace, at a college or through an internship.
Labour’s target to reach 50% University attendance may have had noble intent, but the figure has lead to a worse outlook for current leadership. Badly put together courses with few hours and little in the way of employable skills do not get students into good jobs. Nor do they improve the skill set of our workforce, or reduce unemployment in any worthwhile sense. In terms of improving the image of the education sector, they fulfil a surface requirement, but our economy is not enhanced by poor-quality degrees, and the students who study them emerge 3 years later only to add to the unemployment statistics. As for the public in general, the result of higher taxation is that eighteen year-olds on leafy campuses are spending most of their day doing whatever they like. The generosity of our welfare state creates anger, but this is an equally deplorable use of public money. Some people just don’t need to be at university, even if their parents see it as the obvious route to success.
Given the cost of that the degrees in question to the student, it is at least simple to see why they are being established and why people are so happy to sign on to them. For the university, another name on the register means another set of tuition fees and a higher government grant. The cost for the institution is very low; new degrees generally provide around eight hours of teaching, costing a university very little for each new student. For the student, years spent frolicking on an interest-free loan in a town overrun by young people is the perfect draw.
It is not for the student to decide whether an academic area is sufficiently interesting, or whether a chosen subject justifies the university lifestyle. Instead the worth of a qualification should be judged by its demand in the economy, its requirement of a university setting, and its improvement of the life of the student, as evaluated by the public who pay the costs. Unfortunately, some degree courses are simply not living up to these standards.
No by Charlotte Deans
The slightly raised eyebrow when your reply to the quintessential Durham introduction ‘Name, College, Degree’ with ‘Sociology…’ will be familiar to the majority of students whose future career prospects do not include a company so huge that it is known only by an abbreviation. Subjects that belong to the Faculties of Arts and Social Science are often branded with the ‘waste of time’ tag, something my fellow students and I fight hard to rebuff. I find it amusing to reminisce about the time in Freshers’ Week when I was informed I was “very brave” to be reading a subject because I enjoyed it.
It is my belief that discrimination against ‘softer subjects’ is rife. The term ‘softer’ is in itself inaccurate. Do you know what a Sociology student actually studies? Rhetorical Foucauldian discourse analytics is (I think) pretty solid in anyone’s language.
I first encountered such subject prejudice when my sixth form ‘careers advisor’ (who also happened to be Head of Chemistry – go figure) urged that I do a science instead of Theatre Studies, as it would make me look “more rounded to universities”. I have no talent for equations and could anticipate the disaster that would have ensued, and politely told her where to go.
The competitive nature that permeates all aspects of Durham, be it the library, the sports hall, the Assembly Rooms or the JCR, is particularly evident during the current ‘job season’. The atmosphere at the recent Graduate Recruitment Fair could only be described as slightly overwhelming to those of us who do not have the next twenty years planned meticulously.
It is understandable that lots of students attend Durham and other such universities because of the direct link to the corporate treadmill, and to obtain this they may purposefully choose a degree subject that makes this transition more fluid. I must ask, are such subjects taken purely due to fascination and love for numbers and figures? Or is enjoyment being put on the back burner for such applicants, for three years or perhaps even for their whole future? Do they look forward to retirement already? I know that many enjoy such subjects, as well as the competitive careers and lifestyle and financial security they bring. Yet there’s only so much comfort and happiness a six figure bank balance can give you.
I accept that by not doing a subject that serves me well for the trading floor I will probably not be as comfortable in later life as my more fiscally driven peers. But shouldn’t the old adage, ‘Don’t let your degree get in the way of your education,’ ring true? Surely a degree is first and foremost about broadening your mind and self.
It is my opinion that everyone should be encouraged to study, even if they may not achieve an A*. Success does not automatically equal happiness. Although recent reports by the Association of Graduate Recruiters stated that the Labour target of getting half of all young people to university has ‘driven down standards’ and ‘devalued degrees’, a lack of opportunity in the job market has left many wanting to pursue a degree in order to become more well-rounded and intellectually stimulated citizens. In the words of NUS, it is in the long term interest of our economy that the number of skilled graduates entering the workforce continues to increase.
We as a society are in constant need of graduates from less traditional subjects. Among our greatest exports are television greats such as Strictly Come Dancing (a concept now shown in thirty countries) and The X Factor, powered by those with media degrees. Social science has never been more at the forefront of current events. The ever changing bureaucracy of the NHS, August’s civil unrest and the row over tuition fees are all explained from the learned viewpoint of social policy makers and analysts. We need to analyse factors that cause such events so that we can procure solutions. Deciphering social mechanisms and processes is vital to our understanding of the world around us.
Although in our capitalist society we will always need accountants, traders and oil executives, there are other job sectors that need to be tapped by a constant flow of degree graduates. Universities higher up the league tables may dismiss those at the lower end of the spectrum, and their graduates may well hold positions at the higher end of the job chain, but will they be happy, well rounded, members of the Big Society? When The Bubble bursts, I know who I would rather sit next to at a dinner party, and it won’t be the fat cat who supposedly got the cream.

