DEBATE: should voting be compulsory?
With the General Election just around the corner, Henry Warner and Austin Seck debate whether voting in elections should be made compulsory in the United Kingdom. It’s a model already followed by 22 countries, and enforced by 11, including Argentina, Belgium, Brazil and, most famously, Australia. But would compulsory voting make sure every adult’s vote is heard, or would it be immoral to remove every voter’s right to abstain?
By Henry Warner
It’s a well peddled fact that certain demographics don’t turn out in force to vote – young adults are the worst. After every election some bitter, bored pollster usually runs the numbers and moans that “it would all be different if X demographic voted.” Some cause advocates and party supporters certainly could expect gains if voting became compulsory. Putting political outcomes aside, what are the more meta arguments for and against compulsory voting?
Democracy must be something that people can opt out of it if they wish
The least cynical view of democracy is that it is a system of consent generation. The state is a physical and conceptual structure that enforces a set of rules, laws, onto a set of people, citizens. Usually when someone threatens you with years in a cage for disobeying them we’d say that they’re acting immorally and would be justified in fighting back. Some people believe that ‘true-democracy’ legitimizes these otherwise illegitimate actions. With this understanding of democracy, it seems to counter the fundamentals of it to force people to participate. if democracy is a consent machine then the vote, at least, must be something that people can opt out if they wish.
Slightly more cynical is the view that democracy, rather than generating consent, generates good outcomes; it is a decision machine of sorts. People talk about the wisdom of crowds: under this view, democracy takes the opinions of millions and aggregates them into policy and regime change. If it is compulsory to vote then several things happen: more people vote, less information is recorded, and the circumstances of the voting changes. The benefits of more people voting are probably out- weighed by people not having the option to opt out (reducing the incentive for parties to chase en- gagement) and distortion caused by the introduced coercion.
Democracy is a big con
Finally, comes the peak-cynicism take; democracy is a big con designed to placate a population. Governments impose rules on people that they wouldn’t voluntarily comply with. Without the threat of coercion taxes mightn’t be collected, red lights mightn’t be obeyed, and food standards might not be met. Perhaps the value of democracy is that people’s rebellious drive is channeled into campaigning rather than revolt. Removing the option of disengagement certainly doesn’t meet that end.
By Austin Seck
Democracy is a wonderful thing. Some people say this ironically, and jest, while others say this in all seriousness. Some feel there has been far too many elections in this decade, with Brenda from Bristol expressing what many citizens thought in 2017: ‘Not another one’.
It’s in the interest of the state and every citizen in the United Kingdom to go out and vote
While at times individuals might wonder if their vote would really change anything, if every single voter thought the same way, no one would go out to vote. It’s therefore in the interest of the state and every citizen in the United Kingdom to go out and vote, as their vote is one of the main ways that they can make their voice heard in Parliament. Here are four reasons why voting ought to be made compulsory.
Firstly, when countries experience a lower voter turnout, it can be argued that it is not exactly the ‘will of the people’ but rather the ‘will of those who bothered to turn up’. Compulsory voting will ensure that democ- racy wins, that the majority in the country have voted for what they want to see in Parliament.
Secondly, governments can tend to become more complacent when you have a public that are pathetic towards politics. By enforcing voting, this would ensure that the government is held to account by all its people, not just those who can comfortably go to a polling booth which usually skews elections to- wards particular socio-economic groups, notably the more highly educated and affluent classes.
Thirdly, making voting mandatory does not infringe on the free will of anyone. The minor slight of being forced to go to a polling booth would be similar to you going to a nearby supermarket or post office to run your daily errands. That time cost of less than an hour is worth the possi- ble implications on the country’s future. Voters have the choice to spoil their ballot and vote tactically even if they don’t want to vote for their preferred candidate or do not have one.
Your vote matters. Use it.
Finally, one of the rights you get as a citizen of the UK is your right to vote. It is a precious one and as overrated as it may seem sometimes, it should be seen as the responsibility of the peo- ple to choose how they want their country to be shaped. Akin to paying taxes and jury duty, we should start seeing voting as something everyone ought to do, because only as citizens can we decide whether we truly want something, and if we’re going to complain about it any- way (which we will), we might as well participate in it by voting. Your vote matters. Use it.
Image by secretlondon123 via Flickr
