Debate: Should Shamima Begum be allowed to return to the UK?
Lydia Buckroyd and Jacob Whitehead debate whether ISIS bride Shamima Begum should be allowed to return to the UK having fled for Syria at the age of 15.
Lydia Buckroyd
Shamina Begum has become the poster-girl for ISIS brides. A representation of Britain’s attitude towards former fighters. Yet, her case is unique. Begum was a minor when she travelled to Syria, a 15-year-old London schoolgirl, and now has a new-born baby with a right to British citizenship. It’s this fact among many that we seem to be forgetting when we proclaim that Britain should wipe its hands of her.
Begum is a British national whether we like it or not
Begum is a British national whether we like it or not. She is a home-grown threat – a minor who has been encouraged to believe the only way forward is to travel to an active battleground and marry a foreign fighter. Making her stateless and leaving her in a Syrian refugee camp doesn’t make any of these facts less true. Some country will have to house her, have to decide what to do with her. Are we expecting that to be Syria, where a civil war is raging? Or maybe its neighbours, Turkey or Jordan, neither of which have ever been expected to take British citizens that we don’t want.
Bringing Begum back to the UK is not the same as waving away all wrongdoings that she has committed. Quite the contrary, it is only in the UK that she can be tried for her crimes, questioned on what she knows and rehabilitated from the grooming that she has undergone. It’s only in doing this that we can begin to tackle the home-grown extremism that Britain faces.
The alternative is far worse. If we leave Begum and her new-born child in Syria, we only allow this radicalisation to escalate. There are around 39,000 people in the Al Hol refugee camp in Syria, many of whom are ISIS brides and their children. It is a ‘mini caliphate’, a centre of extremism. Allowing Begum and other British nationals to fade back into this crowd only allows their children to become radicalised themselves. Begum’s baby is an innocent and vulnerable child with a right to British citizenship. Since when did we allow children to be harmed by the crimes of their parents?
With the gradual collapse of ISIS, more and more British nationals will come out of the woodwork with a desire to go home. This problem will not disappear by itself. We need to have the confidence in our judicial system and acknowledgement of our country’s values to let that happen on our terms, instead of burying our heads in the blood-soaked Syrian sand.
Jacob Whitehead
Across issues ranging from Brexit to Thatcher’s legacy, a hallmark of British political discourse is moral absolutism. ‘Of course we should.’ ‘What a ridiculous idea.’
Inevitably the debate over whether Shamima Begum, the ISIS bride, should return to the UK is no different. Opinions are split between equally alarming levels of sentimentality and bigotry, with seemingly little common ground. The elephant in the room simply has not been addressed; that this incredibly sensitive issue needs a level of tact, expertise and situational knowledge that staunch declarations cannot encompass.
Would it not considerably diminish the severity of joining Islamic State?
Consider a legal argument. How would Britain ban her from returning? It is illegal to willingly make a person stateless, and Bangladesh have said they want to play no part in repatriation. Yet the inverse, to welcome her back with open arms, seems to fly counter to common sense and instinct. For example, would it not considerably diminish the severity of joining Islamic State?
Certain arguments appeal towards compassion. Rehabilitation should be prioritised over all else. Yet often the same circles argue that defence spending should be cut, and the budget of the social sector increased. It seems necessary that Begum would require surveillance if back in the UK, at a cost of many thousands of pounds, invariably adding to a defence bill. It’s a sad fact that these are the sorts of decisions which need to be confronted as a daily reality.
Then there is her child to consider. Weeks old, the baby was born to a British mother, and as such has a right to British citizenship. If not Britain, where? Is it not shirking a certain responsibility to allow them to grow up in a warzone or refugee camp when they have a legal entitlement to settle in Britain? Yet to do such an act is to split up mother and child, is this something we should promote?
What about the fact that she was 15 when she left for Syria? Groomed in Britain at a vulnerable age, still a child for the vast majority of her time in Syria. Should this play a role? After all, shouldn’t the country where she was radicalised bear some of the cost? It merely opens another can of worms.
A read over the last few paragraphs reveals that every attempted answer only leads to more questions. I’m not pretending I have all the answers. But neither should you.
Image by John O’Nolan via Flickr.
