Debate: Should interns be paid?
The term ‘internship’ seems to dominate student life. Internships have become the norm, with many students applying for such schemes. As the workplace becomes an approaching reality, it is not hard to understand why. When applying for a job, you are unlikely to stand out above the average 2:1 student without some form of work experience. Internships are imperative to success in the recruitment process, demonstrating a commitment to, and knowledge of, that chosen career path. The benefits of internships are undeniable, yet it is worrying to note that the majority of such schemes remain unpaid, a fact which has very significant repercussions.
Lack of financial support limits access to such internships. The most notable companies operate their placements in cities, putting interns at the heart of the action, but putting a dent in their bank balance. Living costs are undeniably high in business centres throughout the country, making internships a very expensive affair. Evidently, candidates from some social backgrounds may be unable to support themselves whilst completing a placement, preventing them from even applying for such schemes. It seems unjust that such valuable experience should be reserved for those who are more financially secure: without financial backing, the internship programme is in danger of becoming elitist.
It is actually to the benefit of the employer to offer interns some form of pay. A business can also gain from such programmes, recruiting talented interns for later work. Provision of the minimum wage would improve access to internships, and as a consequence, widen the pool of prospective candidates. Who is to say that those who can afford to undertake internships are those most suitable for the role? Improving access to internships with financial support ensures the most gifted graduates can benefit from this experience.
For the graduate, internships are not just something to whack on a job application, but an important insight into their future career. The success of a placement rests upon structure, and it is the employer’s responsibility to ensure the intern gains the most they possibly can from their experience. If the government forced businesses to pay their interns minimum wage I am sure that the experience of interns would improve dramatically. Paying interns would be an investment into their future, and would proved greater incentive for a well-organised programme – no more photocopying or making cups of tea, but real responsibility in a designated role. The value of internships could only be heightened.
That is not to say that current internships consistently fail to meet the expectations of graduates. I believe the majority of placements do deliver and are valuable to the intern, but lack of pay can still be frustrating in successful schemes. For those entrusted with an important role during an internship, it can seem unfair that the business is profiting from their labour. Whilst a graduate can barely afford to live during a placement, a business (often of a huge net worth) is benefiting from a source of free labour. It is undoubtedly important to the value of internships that graduates are given responsibility, but to me, it seems reasonable that businesses offer some sort of pay, particularly to reward significant contributions. For many businesses offering placements, paying interns would not even make a dent in their profit.
There are some who argue that by enforcing payment of interns, businesses would have no choice but to limit the scale of their internship programmes and the number of placements available. If this was the case, it would increase the percentage of unsuccessful candidates, but at the same time, it would transform internships from the norm, to a truly exceptional piece of experience. I consider it more important to have high quality, transparent internships, which are accessible to a diverse body of graduates, than continue to attract the same-old middle-class graduates to these schemes.
Internships should not be considered as an endeavour of the wealthy. Offering pay to interns, even at minimum wage, would open up the experience to a diverse range of graduates. By undertaking a work experience placement, a candidate from a deprived background has greater access to well-paid employment, which they would otherwise not have had. It may seem hyperbolic, but I truly believe it is small steps like this which aid social mobility within our society. By making internships paid, employers are re-emphasising the importance of skill and talent over financial ability.
No by Alex Mason
When considering the ethics of unpaid internships, it is important to recognise the complex landscape of the types of placements and their purpose – be it to train new workers, give a taste of a possible career, gain experience and credibility in a CV, or build a network of contacts.
Only kidding, interns deserve nothing. Not only do I think they should never get paid, I’m willing to claim paying them will directly contribute to the fall of capitalist society and the rise of the communist industrial complex.
The argument in favour of pay presupposes what interns do has monetary value, and dues are somehow owned. This shows complete ignorance of the fact that interns, on the whole, suck. They screw up, they have no idea what they’re doing, and it usually takes full time care from another employee just to make sure they don’t blow anything up. Yes, even office interns are combustion hazards. But more than that, they’re burdens.
I know what you’re thinking (mostly because you’re a straw man I just invented). You’re thinking “Wait! I have some friends who were interns and were incredibly competent and contributed greatly to their workplaces and and…”. You’re missing the point. Interns should necessarily be burdensome. If they’re not then their ruinous selfishness deserves scorn.
What is an internship? My incredibly biased and carefully selected dictionary definition defines it as: “any official or formal program to provide practical experience for beginners in an occupation or profession”. The goal isn’t to add benefit; it’s purely about providing experience.
The logic is that businesses have no onus to hire inexperienced workers (except adult modelling agencies), so to get hired you need experience. Only you can’t get that experience without being hired: a classic catch-22. However, economically we need people to work – everyone has to start somewhere, and as the experienced retire they need to be replaced. It’s in a business’s best interest to ensure experienced workers are available, so a compromise is formed.
Businesses take on and train and offer experience and guidance to workers they’d ordinarily overlook. In exchange they get to safeguard their own future and enjoy the value-added labour provided by those workers. If you demand they be paid, then it just becomes a job. You’re then suggesting a business should for no good reason give their precious jobs to the worst possible candidates. How could you think that? HOW. Sort yourself out.
Internships are being represented as a slavery based foot-in-the-door scheme, where people unable to find a job take on one and get worked to the bone in return for some vague promise of an actual full-time paying place at the end of it all. That’s pretty despicable, but it’s really our own fault.
Businesses exist primarily to make money and if you’re a willing to help fuel the carnivorous corporate regime with your able body on the mere promise of a career, then they’d be fools not to welcome you with open fangs. This reverse Faustian bargain was never the intention; you expect businesses to do what’s in their best interest, but workers with experience being complicit to try and selfishly score a job makes them just as bad.
I can see it in your eyes, invented straw man, you’re mumbling something about it being impossible to get a job and internships being a last resort blah blah. You’re intolerable. If there are no jobs, then internships don’t factor into it. They’re not there to help with that, and we shouldn’t expect businesses to chip in and pay as some sort of sellotape solution to an ailing job market.
If what you want is a job, and you have the necessary skill and experience, then you should be able to get one. If you can’t, due to there not being any, that’s understandable; internships are not, nor should they be, a solution. If you can’t, and there are jobs, then evidently you’re the problem. The solution might be more experience, in which case why exactly should you be paid to make up your own deficiency?
Did we all have a sudden moment of clarity and realise socialism is the way forward? If there’s no good reason to pay interns, why should we? Do it on a grand scale and they’ll be handing out hammers and sickles to all new interns before you can say ‘slippery slope’.
Who do you agree with? Join the debate below or tweet us @PalatiComment

