Debate; Should galleries ban the use of mobile phones?
FOR
by Jasmine Kaler
The digital detox that has emerged in 2018, with the sale of dumb phones and the like, is easily dismissed as the grumbling of technophobes; yet ignoring the preaching that encourages us to ‘look up’ can mean important questions are ignored. The appreciation of art requires time and attention, two things we are giving to our smartphones in greater quantities at the expense of the world around us. It is necessary for galleries to prohibit the use of mobile phones to restore the once responsive and attentive audiences to our galleries.
In 2016 a photo by Gijsbert van der Wal of a group of children in front of a Rembrandt masterpiece went viral. The image of a dozen kids staring down shows how easy it is for children and adults alike to look down instead of up and miss a masterpiece right in front of them.
The energy of a gallery will invariably sound clichéd but its importance should not be underestimated. The presence of art (this can apply to other forms of expression) and engaged, contemplative people creates an atmosphere in which the art can achieve its full potential. In many ways, it is unfair to deprive artists of this audience (and placing the responsibility to recapture this on the doorsteps of galleries seems reasonable). Marina Abramovic banned the use of phones during her performance piece at the Serpentine saying “We want people to come as they are, with nothing, as I am… From that energy, every day is different”. If we compare this to the approach of Yayoi Kusama, whose dots created an Instagram rage and undoubtedly benefited from the publicity, it seems that the artist may be the best authority on this matter.
It will be called archaic and patronising to impose such a restriction, but it is time for galleries to confront the impact of phones head on. The idea that technology reigns free and unregulated is not an unfamiliar concern. It is becoming increasingly common for artists to ban the use of phones at concerts. Jack White recently banned them from his upcoming tour, his manager saying in a statement “we think you’ll enjoy looking up from your gadgets for a little while and experiencing music and our shared love of it in person.”
Is it better for selfie enthusiasts to be in the gallery and look, however briefly, at the art that surrounds them? The answer is no. It is one thing filling an Opera house with people but if the sounds of the orchestra are reduced to background music or become a snapchat video the value of the art is impacted.
AGAINST
by Stella Botes
Before writing this, I had been distracted by approximately 4:43 minutes worth of Tasty videos. However I was also able to get the low-down on Frieze London in my email inbox, and to listen to a podcast discussing Banksy’s recent auction-shredding stunt (covered below). When we disparage technology for all its new-age distractions and pollutions, we overlook vast and valuable caches of information.
This approach is perpetrated when galleries and museums ban phones from their exhibitions. Notoriously reluctant to change, these institutions cultivate a cultural lethargy towards the integration of technology and culture; an integration ever more important in our modern era. Rather than sweeping the issue out of mind with blanket bans, galleries should be grasping the opportunities offered by phones with the excitement they accord; Smartify lets users scan works via their phone camera for more information, galleries can offer sitemaps to save users losing themselves in their labyrinthine complexes, audio guides could be transferred to phones to save money and material.
Not only technological permission but technological integration and innovation are of paramount importance to the art industry. Accusations of inaccessibility and elitism have consistently plagued the art world – if institutions are to be truly public-serving, then they must serve the full spectrum of the public. For those who find visiting galleries difficult, digitised collections are a cultural oasis and source of comfort. Audio description could help blind people to engage with work, with similar mediums being used for learning-disabled children and adults.
Furthermore, as noted in the government’s Culture Is Digital report published earlier this year, audiences are ‘no longer passive receivers of culture’. Much contemporary art requires or is enhanced by the use of mobile phones as young artists recognise the power of their work across various mediums. Taking a photo is no longer simply an act of personal preservation, nor commodification or commercialisation; it is an artistic practice and dialogue between artist and consumer.
Without acknowledging and celebrating the potential of phone use, our galleries and cultural institutions will be left floundering in an antiquated and out of touch ether of our culture, consistently trailing at the heels of technology. This is not a palatable vision for the galleries of 2018.
Image from Google via Creative Commons
