Death of the period drama?
When idly flicking through a copy of the Radio Times a few weeks ago, I was immediately horror-struck to spot an article entitled ‘Farewell to the Bonnet’, which predicted the demise of costume drama due to the enormous financial costs involved, a general decrease in the number of viewers, and an increasing demand for contemporary drama.
However, after persevering through BBC1’s latest adaptation of Emma, adapted by Sandy Welch, I began to think that maybe I wouldn’t find life so utterly meaningless if period drama is indeed on its last legs. Although I am immediately filled with excitement every time I hear talk of a new adaptation, nine times out of ten I find myself disappointed.
And the ‘cult of Jane Austen’ particularly bothers me: both film and television seem determined to suffocate us with Austen adaptations. Over the past few years, every Austen novel has received at least one airing, whilst to have had a go at ‘donning the bonnet’ has become something of a fashion among many of the big-name female actresses – Keira Knightley and Billie Piper in particular have been at the forefront of the trend.
Nonetheless, each new adaptation still insists it is somehow ‘fresh’ and groundbreaking, yet on the whole this seems unconvincing; rather, screen writers desperately flounder about to ensure their particular adaptation won’t, six months after being shown, find itself forgotten, gathering dust in the ever-growing pile of adaptations.
Emma’s particular ‘new’ approach was to emphasise a kind of connection between Emma, Frank Churchill and Jane Fairfax, as well as to pick up on the notion of travel and Emma’s limited world existence.
Although this all felt somewhat contrived, it was less of a concern than the shockingly wooden state of the acting itself overall. Scenes of social intercourse, particularly among the Woodhouse family, lacked the humour and wit essential to Austen, instead displaying a sense of awkwardness and even friction. The characters themselves seemed either bland and lifeless, like Mrs Weston, or just plain ridiculous, as in the case of Mr Elton.
And like many other period dramas, the series fell foul to the ‘wolf-in-sheep’s-clothing syndrome’ as distinctly modern-day modes of speech and behaviour – Emma’s assertion of “we’re just friends”, and worse still, Frank actually lying in Emma’s lap – grated against the period setting.
However, this is not to say that Emma did not have its moments too; the series definitely improved as it progressed, and I was pleasantly surprised by some truly sensitive and feeling performances from Romola Garai as Emma, demonstrating the dilemmas of discovering oneself caught in love. That said, for me, Emma will unfortunately be another one of those period adaptations which is indeed left to gather dust; I for one won’t be queuing up to buy the DVD.
Although there are aspects of Lost in Austen, that, as Amanda Price herself says, would have “Jane Austen spinning in her grave like a cat in a tumble dryer”, in its originality it captured the sense of vitality, tempered with passion and intensity, that Emma never really managed to obtain.
For me, the one case out of ten when period drama doesn’t disappoint, is when it achieves such innovation, or as with the superb adaptation of Charles Dickens’ Little Dorrit, when television condescends to occasionally adapt a relatively lesser known work.
Unfortunately, this seems destined to become an even more infrequent occurrence, with the BBC increasingly adopting what adaptation legend Andrew Davies describes as a “we’ll only do the big popular warhorses” approach. I guess it means we’ll just have to appreciate those few truly ‘fresh’ adaptations all the more when they do come along.
