Cuth’s Rugby social draws national attention
SCSRFC sparked a major debate in the local and national media for the second year in a row after they played a controversial game at a social. Palatinate investigates to give you the full story.
St. Cuthbert’s Society Rugby Football Club has come under fire for playing a controversial game entitled “It’s not rape if…” whilst on a social on 17 October.
The game, which is intended to be humorous, asks participants to suggest a scenario in which a sexual attack would not count as rape, such as, “It’s not rape if you shout surprise.”
The club has come under strong criticism from individuals and groups across the University, including the Durham University Feminism Society (DUFemSoc), for trivialising sexual assault.
The incident has also appeared in several national newspapers, following similar press attention received by the club this time last year after a social in which the team dressed up as Jimmy Savile and his victims generated widespread criticism.
Members of DUFemSoc were also attending a social on the same night the incident occurred, leading to the issue being raised with the University by one of its members.
The captain of SCSRFC has since apologised for the club’s actions in an email to Durham DUFemSoc, stating:
“The ‘It’s not rape if…’ game is neither funny nor is it permissible and it is for this reason that I wholeheartedly apologise.
“In spite of the game having been played, SCSRFC do in no way condone rape nor wish to belittle its victims. It was a slip of judgment on behalf of several of the club’s members and that there is no genuine belief in the comments made during the game.
“It is with great regret that I am even having to enter into this correspondence with you. By consequence I’d like to propose some means of assisting DUFemSoc in their cause by initiating a relationship between our two societies.”
On Saturday, members of the DUFemSoc executive committee were invited to attend SCSRFC’s match against Castle in view of the two societies creating a more amicable relationship.
Professor Elizabeth Archibald, as well as Cuth’s JCR President Serge Chapman were in attendance to discuss the issue with DUFemSoc members.
After the match, SCSRFC players agreed to pose for photographs with FemSoc members before holding up a whiteboard reading, ‘It’s not rape if it’s between two consenting adults.’
Rachel Piper, equal opportunities officer at FemSoc, watched the match and expressed her wish for a greater understanding of feminist concerns amongst male rugby players, telling Palatinate:
“We really want to open up a fruitful conversation between our societies, as opposed to merely chastising the rugby players for their behaviour.
“As negative as the incident was for our cause, it can actually be seen as an opportunity to give greater voice to feminist issues in Durham. It is very important to challenge this ‘rugby lad’ culture wherever it is proving detrimental to gender equality.
“Since the incident we have received plenty of messages of support and encouragement from people across Durham, which is a really positive thing. Now we need to build on this and get our message out there to a wider audience.”
Meanwhile, publicity officer Flo Perry said: “We suspect that some of the rugby players who took part in the game wouldn’t have been happy with its message and might have been influenced by the peer pressure of the group.”
“We encourage any of the SCSRFC members who felt uncomfortable with these attitudes to help us in expanding our cause and fighting against prejudice wherever it is found.”
DUFemSoc are said to be planning a series of reconciliation events with SCSRFC in order to further strengthen the relationship between the two societies.
Earlier this year, an NUS report explicitly named Durham in a survey about university ‘lad culture,’ which exposed the fact that one in seven female students in the UK reported to have experienced physical or sexual assault.
The report also highlighted socials as a place where sexist attitudes are encouraged.
Chapman expressed the need for both the rugby club and college in general to tackle the ‘lad culture’ issue, telling Palatinate:
“We are going to participate in the university wide lad culture campaign alongside the other JCRs later on in the year, but for the meantime I am happy to tell you the club themselves are doing their utmost to combat it themselves.
“The most effective change will be from the bottom up. They are working with DuFemSoc which I think has really changed their attitude already and I am confident they are sincere in their desire to make the club a more welcoming and respectful group.
“I have begun writing a commitment for all our sportsmen and women which they can choose to sign up to, which makes a statement that they wish their sport to be welcoming, respectful and open to all, and have further plans to organise talks in college where our JCR members can learn more about the difficulties of lad culture and the impact it has on college sport.”
After last year’s Jimmy Savile social, the club was banned from playing rugby for the remainder of Michaelmas term, and were also fined £50 each, with the club captain and social secretary facing twenty hours of community service. The club also met with a child rape expert.
However, the latest incident has led many to question the effectiveness of last year’s disciplinary action, as many of the members of the rugby club who participated in last year’s scandalous social remain on the team.
Cuth’s JCR President, however, is keen to highlight efforts at a real change in culture at the college, telling Palatinate:
“The individuals in this team this year are making a very genuine and concerted effort to be good members of the Cuth’s community and have taken on board a lot of the criticism that has been leveled at them.
“I can see and I believe that these individuals are doing all they can to challenge the worst parts of any damaging culture and behaviour. They wish to make the Men’s Rugby Club a club that Cuth’s can be proud of and reflects the diverse, welcoming character of the college.”
Professor Archibald, who is taking part in the disciplinary proceedings, added: “We are aware of the alleged incident in St Cuthbert’s and we will be speaking to the students concerned.
“The college has a diverse and international student body and students are well aware of the need to act appropriately and respectfully towards others.”
The club must now wait to see what disciplinary action they will face, which is to be decided in accordance with the college’s rules on inappropriate behaviour.
Photograph: .FuturePresent. via Flickr

