Council seek solution to environmental disasters

Floodedriver600x400

by Joanna Thom

Following the recent disruptions to students at Durham caused by flooding and poor weather, the council are looking at how they can take steps to combat the environmental issues.

Severe flooding resulted in the closure of Elvet riverside during the winter term, causing many class locations to be changed. Additionally it disrupted many residents and students, with some using sandbags as flood defenses because of a fear that their properties would be damaged.

The high levels of the river during exam term caused many students to worry about whether their exams would be able to continue in their current locations.

Additionally the flooding and extreme weather conditions have resulted in the erosion of bits of riverbank as well as the mounting of debris in the river.

Last Friday Andrew Foster, the head of the Environment Agency Operations Delivery Team in Durham, spoke to the Elvet Residents association about the erosion of riverbanks of the river Wear and the river Skerne in Darlington.

The landslides that have occurred along the river Wear have resulted in the closing of parts of the river paths, preventing students from accessing locations such as Maiden Castle via the river.

“I used to enjoy cycling and running along the towpath but the constant disruptions from landslides and falling trees have meant that it’s impossible to even walk their now.”

It has also caused problems for students rowing along that stretch as spotters who are needed to watch boats along the bank in order to avoid any collisions, have been unable to access parts of the bank.

Adrian White, the council’s head of transport and contract services, said: “We have been working to keep these paths open in the face of some challenging conditions.

“However, we have now reached the stage where it has become necessary to close the paths for safety reasons.” Work on the paths is expected to last several months and includes working on the foundations of some of the paths, which have been weakened by the water damage.

In addition to the work that is taking place, an investigation into why the banks continue to erode, is being ordered. Experts will conduct monitoring and a full geotechnical assessment, to discover why the hillside is continuing to move and what long-term solutions are possible.

Each year testing is carried out to check the flood defenses and responses to the possibility of flooding.

Additionally the increase of debris in the river as a result of the weather has caused damage to some boat clubs’ fleet. Van Mildert College were left annoyed when their boat was damaged as a result of a large log left in the river.

“A series of steps has been taken to reinforce the physical integrity of the area, which is vulnerable to flooding, and to relocate equipment at a higher level, wherever possible.”

Earlier this term a spring clean of the river was carried out to remove the debris and litter that has incremented from the high river levels. Andrew Foster was pleased with the fact that this task would be carried out.

He said: “The Environment Agency normally only removes debris that could cause an obstruction, and a flood risk. So this is another great opportunity to pool resources with the councils to clear all litter and debris we find in the rivers and have a thorough spring clean.

Students have expressed their anger at the constant disruptions to teaching caused by the flooding to Elvet Riverside, through a Facebook group set up.

The group description reads: ‘We have been moved around the city; sat in freezing lectures where we can see our own breath; classes disrupted by power cuts. What will it be next?’

This indicates the annoyance that many students have felt towards the building work that have resulted from the flooding.

The group also questioned why such incidences were allowed to occur at a University which prides itself on its’ top level facilities.

The University has responded to students’ concerns, claiming that they are attempting to prevent any future disruption.

They said: “This year’s disruption was the result of flood water entering a plant room. A series of steps has been taken to reinforce the physical integrity of the area, which is vulnerable to flooding, and to relocate equipment at a higher level, wherever possible.

In addition, CCTV is being installed within the plant room itself which will be used to monitor the situation during future flood alerts so that remedial action (for example emergency pumping out) can be taken in the unlikely event that flood defenses are breached in future.”

Students have also been outraged by reports that the Palatine centre’s roof was leaking, despite the fact that it was only opened this academic year.

Rob Torch said: “They spent millions of pounds on that building and yet it still has problems. What was the point?”

A university spokesperson responded: “There are currently no roof leaks in the Palatine Centre.

There have been one or two minor leaks since the building opened which have been repaired. It is not unusual to experience ‘snagging issues’ when a new building is commissioned and the Palatine Centre has a complex roof geometry.”

Additionally the environmental effects of the severe weather and flooding have resulted in disruptions to students as they walk around Durham.

Emma Graham said: “I used to enjoy cycling and running along the towpath but the constant disruptions from landslides and falling trees have meant that it’s impossible to even walk their now.

It also prevents me from getting to places like Maiden Castle quickly.”

One sports participant also revealed that they have encountered difficulties because Maiden Castle is situated near the river and so risks flooding.

They said that they have previously had to shift sandbags in order to protect the building and fixtures have been postponed as a result.

“They spent millions of pounds on that building and yet it still has problems. What was the point?”

The University responded to the claim that Maiden Castle was built in an inappropriate position given the risk of flooding by saying:

“The University would not build on a site which is known to be prone to flooding. In recent years flood risks have been re-assessed owing to changes in weather patterns and increased density of development.

This means that areas, which were once not thought to be at risk of flooding, now experience floods.

We are taking this into account in our future estates planning.”

A report prepared by the Environmental Agency will be discussed on the 26th of June. This was commissioned after flash floods in 2009 caused severe erosion to the riverbank and affected the bowling green and the surrounding vennels. This should give an indication of ways in which future damage as a result of the environment can be prevented.
Photograph: A. Haynes