Could Hillary’s health cost her the election?
By Paul Miller
It’s been a bad week for Hillary Clinton. Having seen her lead narrow in the polls despite massively outspending her opponent, on Sunday she was forced to leave a 9/11 memorial event early due to “overheating”. Multiple videos of her departure to her daughter Chelsea’s apartment subsequently surfaced online, appearing to show her collapsing and being bundled into a van. With the revelation that she had been diagnosed with pneumonia two days earlier, questions are being asked about why this was not made public sooner.
Qualms about the health of presidents and presidential candidates are nothing new. Franklin D. Roosevelt was partially paralysed and frequently confined to a wheelchair, John F. Kennedy took a wide assortment of drugs for his long-running health problems, and Ronald Reagan underwent multiple surgical operations during his time in office.
The effect the Presidency has on those elected to office is also well known – photographs of Barack Obama, Bill Clinton, and George W. Bush before and after their terms show the stressful nature of life in the Oval Office. But with two of the oldest candidates in history on the ballot this November – Hillary Clinton is 68, while Donald Trump turned 70 in June – the health of the two candidates is indisputably a core issue of this election.
Rumours of Clinton’s poor health have been circulating the boards and forums frequented by Trump supporters for some time. Her hospitalisation following a concussion and blood clot in 2012 is widely documented – however, her opponents believe she suffered lasting damage from this, citing various video clips that appear to show her seizing up, having a coughing fit, and struggling to climb stairs.
Previously, the Clinton campaign could dismiss this as the ravings of conspiracy theorists – but with the pneumonia revelation, combined with Clinton’s perceived lack of honesty (68% see her as untrustworthy, compared with 43% for Trump), these rumours may well be given more attention in the coming weeks.
Worse, the incident comes right after a gaffe where she described half of Trump’s supporters as a “basket of deplorables” – a remark seized upon by the Trump campaign, who immediately spent millions of dollars on a new attack ad citing the phrase in crucial key states.
Some are suggesting that Clinton may be forced to withdraw from the presidential race, but the DNC cannot replace Hillary Clinton (despite the rumoured “emergency meeting”) unless she voluntarily steps down – and, to the chagrin of Bernie Sanders’ fervent supporters, she shows no signs of planning to do so. Some, including former UKIP leader and vocal supporter of Donald Trump Nigel Farage, have described her as entitled, pointing out how Clinton seems to view her presidential campaign as the logical apex of a lengthy and varied political career that has seen her at various times First Lady, Secretary of State, and United States Senator.
In the unlikely event she does decide to relinquish the nomination, it seems likely that current Vice-President Joe Biden would step up, while Clinton’s VP pick Tim Kaine would retain his current position. This would be fraught with issues, however – with the Clinton-Kaine team already submitted to each state, the replacement would need to happen on a legally complex state-by-state basis. Furthermore, the image of a DNC in chaos and an unelected nominee would be potent ammunition for Donald Trump.
Trump himself has shown restraint when commenting on Clinton’s health – displaying a measured response that shows he may be beginning to bring a softer, more presidential tone to the final stretch of the election. He expressed a wish that she “gets well and gets back on the trail”, but his campaign managers must be well aware that this is a golden opportunity. Trump has previously described Clinton as “unfit” and lacking the “mental and physical stamina” required for the Presidency.
Although he may not go on the offensive on this front again until the presidential debates, Trump can now attack Clinton on her health as well has what many see as her dishonesty and ties to Wall Street. By contrast, Clinton has largely been levelling the same accusations of bigotry, racism, sexism, and Islamophobia that she has for the entire election cycle – and undecided voters who haven’t been swayed by this rhetoric before are unlikely to be won over by it now.
The health saga will continue as both candidates have vowed to release more detailed medical records. Although questions are inevitably being raised about Trump’s health, the contrast between the two candidates is clear as the Republican bounces around the campaign trail, sometimes holding multiple energetic rallies in one day.
It won’t be clear how much damage Clinton’s health has done to her chances until new polls come out and the candidates go head to head at the debates – but with current polls tight and less than two months until the election, the events of this week could well prove the first concrete harbinger of a Trump victory on November 8th.
Picture by Medill DC via Flickr
