Could businesswomen be the saviour of the economy?

Women have been campaigning for equality for too long. They suffered for the basic right to vote at the start of the 20th Century, struggled for equality throughout the sixties and seventies and have been fighting an ongoing battle for equal pay and status in business since the early nineties, apparently to no avail. The average working woman in the US still earns only 80 cents for every dollar her male counterpart makes, and only 37% of the 2008 graduating class of MBA students were female. However, the most troubling figure by far is the proportion of officer and director level positions that women occupy in Fortune 500 companies, which is just sixteen percent. The business world is ruled by men, and we may be all the worse for it.

In his book ‘Ahead of the Curve’, Harvard graduate Philip Broughton writes, “no matter how hard it tries, business can never escape the fact that it is the practice of potentially thieving, treacherous, lying human beings”. It’s a fairly bold statement, but one which rings particularly true following the credit crunch and worldwide recession. A study published in 1998 by marketing professors Shaheen Borna and James Stearns found the ethical integrity of MBA students to be comparable to that of convicted felons. In fact, the felons actually showed greater concern for consumer safety than the business students, and more loyalty to their employer too. What’s more, the situation doesn’t appear to have changed in the last decade. A recent study here in Durham showed that business schools are only just starting to focus on ethics and sustainability, their hand forced by the guilt of having caused the largest financial disaster in 70 years – not that they’re prepared to admit it.

In fact, there are so many infamous business scandals to choose from that it’s a wonder the schools have been allowed to neglect ethics for this long. Prime examples include the Wall Street insider trading of the 1980s, the collapse of Enron – a company loaded to the hilt with MBA graduates that quickly became synonymous with fraudulent accounting – and the recent financial meltdown, which was ultimately caused by downright greed, stupidity and lying by the people at the top of business. Clearly, the current practice isn’t working. Business as usual needs to change, and maybe that means getting more women into the top jobs. Maybe it’s about time that the sixteen percent increased.

Not too long ago, many researchers were hopeful that business ethics would improve as more women rose to positions of responsibility in the workforce. Does that reflect a common belief that women are inherently more ethical than men? According to some studies, yes. Research has found that women show stronger ethical awareness in hypothetical business situations than men, and while other studies have shown no difference between the genders, none have shown women to be less ethical. In addition, other research has shown that women are actually more likely to be whistleblowers than men too, a claim substantiated by Sherron Watkins and Cynthia Cooper, who are famous for exposing Enron and WorldCom respectively.

Another renowned female martyr is Marta Andreasen, who was fired by the European Commission in 2002 after she refused to sign off accounts that she believed to be unreliable. Whether she refused because she was bound by some accountancy code of conduct, or simply because it was in conflict with her own moral compass remains to be seen, but either way, she put her job on the line to uphold her integrity. If she was bound by the ethics of chartered accountancy, much like a doctor is bound by a Hippocratic oath, then what happened to the accountants (who were almost entirely male) that signed off the Enron accounts? They must have known of the company’s deceit, but were wilfully blind, and in some cases even conspired to hide the evidence. Was gender the only factor that affected the outcome of these two scenarios? Probably not.

There are plenty of prominent women who have behaved contemptibly too. Former DUP member and ‘Bigot of the Year’ nominee Iris Robinson was expelled from the Irish party in early January over her exploitation of the MP expenses system, as well as undeclared loans that she secured for her extramarital lover. What’s more, there are undoubtedly some women who sat back and said nothing while the credit crunch, Enron disaster and insider trades on Wall Street unfolded around them, perfectly comfortable with cashing in on their crass behaviour. One swallow doesn’t make a summer, and just because Marta Andreasen behaved honestly in 2002 doesn’t mean that women in general are more ethical than men.

The alternative, however, is far bleaker. If women aren’t more ethical than men – and let’s face it, we’re probably equal – then the explanation for our financial failures has to be something else. The Enron example was symptomatic of widespread corruption, and the current global recession was created by the greed of bankers who were recklessly vying for a quick buck. My point is that we need to start being nicer, more ethical people, and to conduct our business accordingly. We shouldn’t have to increase the number of ethics programmes in business schools, or introduce new regulations that persuade bankers to be more conscientious – if you need those kinds of incentives, maybe the business world would be better without you. Furthermore, if large, multi-national companies are more open to systemic corruption, lying and greed than smaller companies of the past, then the globalised world towards which we move ever closer is a truly daunting place. Here’s hoping women can save us all!