Contrasting fortunes for arch rivals Pakistan and India

Mahendra_Singh_Dhoni_batting

By Taha Hashim and Kishan Vaghela

It was back to business for Pakistan in the second Test match at Dubai, as they restored balance to their exceptional record in their adopted home of the UAE. While England’s tail fought valiantly on the last day, providing flashbacks of the Ashes Test in Cardiff in 2009, it ended more on the side of Headingley 2014, when James Anderson sunk to his knees as Sri Lanka celebrated a remarkable overseas series victory.

However, a draw would have covered up England’s poor showing with the bat on day three, a day from which any recovery would have seemed unlikely. Most importantly though, it would have hidden a very strong performance from a Pakistan side that has continued its excellent Test form.

The return of Yasir Shah was only ever going to have a positive effect on the Pakistani side. Yet despite his eight-wicket haul, which has now seen him take seven or more wickets in his last five Test matches, it was no solo act, with the frighteningly quick Wahab Riaz, very aptly named Imran Khan, and very disciplined Zulfiqar Babar, all playing their part.

Riaz brought with him the explosive pace, reliving his exploits against Shane Watson in the World Cup seven months ago. On day five, with Stuart Broad finding his batting mojo once again, it was Riaz’s absolute brute of an inswinging yorker that found its way past Broad’s bat.

Khan brought a sense of control and discipline to the attack that complemented his fellow paceman well, keeping it simple as he found enough movement to find the outside edges of four England batsmen. The wily old Babar also made sure he joined the party, bowling an extraordinary 47 overs in the final innings, earning his match fee with the key wicket of Joe Root, whilst also claiming the scalp of Mark Wood.

Alongside an all-round bowling performance was the performance of the ever so reliable middle order. How Pakistan will cope when Misbah-ul-Haq and Younis Khan decide to call it a day will send shivers down the spine of many Pakistani fans.

There was to be no repeat of the calamity that was day five in Abu Dhabi as both Misbah and Younis added to their long tally of Test hundreds, whilst the often-overlooked Asad Shafiq continued to score heavily under the radar, cracking a pair of half-centuries, even after being stuck on the knee by a delivery from Wood.

Although unpredictability is a trait often associated with Pakistan, it is now one tagged with this young England side. How they respond in the final Test will be very interesting to see. Yet in Sharjah, an unknown territory for them, it will be hard to look past Pakistan enjoying another series win in their temporary home.

In contrast to their arch rivals, India are arguably at their lowest point since their preparation for the World Cup, particularly in limited overs cricket. South Africa may be the toughest opponents the 2011 World Cup winners may have faced since the semi-final against Australia, yet their confidence levels have plummeted beyond belief.

Shikhar Dhawan looked in fine touch in the lead-up to the limited overs matches against the Proteas, scoring a well-constructed 150 against Bangladesh A for India A. However, the 29–year-old attempted to open up the leg side too frequently and the likes of Kagiso Rabada and Chris Morris took advantage as he became susceptible to anything on a good length during both the T20I and ODI series.

Rohit Sharma and Virat Kohli were poor overall, with the latter managing his first ODI hundred since the opening game of the World Cup in Pakistan in the penultimate ODI game.

Yet the lack of form of Sharma and Kohli brings about India fans’ biggest gripe. So many of the other batsmen fail to respond if those two depart cheaply. Suresh Raina, the aforementioned Dhawan and Ajinkya Rahane are festooned when they travel across India, yet the puffery they receive is risible.

Raina got out in the same manner and the same ball in the first two ODIs, a shadow of the figure who was so composed in the semi-final of the victorious 2011 World Cup campaign against Pakistan. Rahane strikes the common viewer as a textbook strokeplayer, and therefore struggles to make up on the balls he uses up in adapting to the surface.

India’s major concern nonetheless is the bowling. 144 runs came from the last 10 overs of South Africa’s innings in the final ODI in Mumbai. Of course, facing a flourishing batsman in AB de Villiers whose pyrotechnics of 360 degree hitting have perplexed everyone would frighten even the greatest death bowler.

Nevertheless, Mumbai has never been a 438 track, but with an attack entirely comprised of fast-medium bowlers at best and lacking a high-class all-rounder, India were asking for it. Bhuvneshwar Kumar has diverged from his strength of swing bowling, whilst Mohit Sharma’s only useful variation is the slower-ball bouncer. Ultimately, they are India’s ‘safe’ options – well, usually.

Conversely, Umesh Yadav is the unfinished article, but the only Indian paceman to have clearly troubled de Villiers, that in the successful 2013 Champions Trophy campaign. Yet, after conceding a flurry of boundaries in the first ODI, he was banished from the starting XI.

Rabada is everything India fans desire from their quick bowlers: speed imbued with control. Who would’ve said that a few weeks ago? South Africa’s batsmen, Hashim Amla aside, showed their opposite numbers how to bat on their own pitches, whilst Imran Tahir was only outperformed by Ravichandran Ashwin.

Captain Mahendra Singh Dhoni must come to terms with India’s issues soon, or face another series defeat in the upcoming Test matches.

Photograph: Dee03 via Wikimedia Commons