Common Room framework not updated since 2011
By Will Hutchings
The Durham Student Organisation (DSO) framework has not been updated since its inception in 2011. This framework regulates the management of most of the University’s Common Rooms, and is therefore important to the operation of these colleges.
According to the University Communications Team, “a formal review of the DSO Framework commenced in May 2019.”
It began “in consultation with 2018/19 academic year student leaders from College Common Rooms, Experience Durham and Careers & Enterprise student organisations, as well as Professional Services staff who support our Durham Student Organisations.”
Before this review, there had been “informal” reviews of “the working practices associated with the Annexes” of the framework.
I’m sceptical of how well-enforced the regulations are
Hatfield Treasurer
The lack of a formal review of the document contradicts the terms of Article 10.1, which states that “this framework and its annexes will be reviewed at intervals of no more than every 5 years.”
The University did not give reasons for the delayed review of the document, stating only that “this approach has enabled us to support our student organisations effectively.”
Any changes to the framework will not be presented until Epiphany Term, according to the Communications Team. In 2011, the framework was developed as an alternative to the colleges’ separate constitutions,and put the colleges which subscribed to it under the governance of one central document.
All of the college JCRs adopted the framework except Grey College, St Cuthbert’s Society, and Ustinov College, all of which pursued charity status instead. St Chad’s and St John’s exist as separate entities, and thus follow different guidelines.
In ‘going the charity route’ (as it is often termed), these three colleges will maintain their individual constitutions and each be registered as separate student unions.
Following the belated review of the DSO framework, Van Mildert College is in the process of transferring to charity status. The current President of the Mildert JCR, Sheehan Quirke, claims to have been “re-elected specifically to guide us out of the framework and to transition into an independent charity.”
For Quirke, the “outdated” framework was just one example of the University’s “mistreatment of Common Rooms.”
Just one example of the University’s “mistreatment of Common Rooms”
Sheehan Quirke, Van Mildert JCR President
St Aidan’s also recently voted to leave the framework and go towards the charity route.
The outdated framework has caused stress to Common Rooms in the past. Hatfield’s JCR Exec have not had assistance with their current financial situation, and the Treasurer expressed frustration that “there is no mechanism to prevent this from happening,” and it does not give an “overarching helping hand.”
According to the Treasurer, “at this point, the DSO is so outdated that it refers to positions which do not even exist anymore. I’m skeptical of how well-enforced the regulations are.”
Currently, the DSO framework’s Annex 3, which deals with financial regulations, sets out the role of the Treasurer and measures taken to prevent organisations from facing financial difficulty, but it does not contain any spending limits or budgeting guidelines.
The Students’ Union plans to set up a Student Organisations framework of its own, but it is in very early stages. Although the framework is to be updated in Epiphany Term, contact with JCR presidents has allegedly been “minimal,” and some are “not very optimistic” about its future.
Image by Tom Parnell via Flickr
