Comment Debate: Was the dismissal of Dr Stephen Pax Leonard justified?
In light of online comments made by Dr Stephen Pax Leonard’s, a Research Fellow at St Chad’s College, his fellowship has been revoked. Comment debate whether this was the right outcome.
Chad’s was wrong to remove him
Oliver Griffiths
I suspect that there are many people like myself who don’t hold strong political views and rarely feel obligated to say what they think. I’m afraid that in light of recent events, I feel duty-bound to express my disagreement to the removal of Dr Stephen Pax Leonard’s fellowship at St Chad’s College. Moreover, I hold in greater contempt the assassination of his character by people who are completely ignorant of his work or those that have never had a discussion with him.
Already this week I have heard students throw around words and phrases such as ‘racist’, ‘fascist’ and ‘alt right’ who upon me asking why they thought that, appeared dumb-founded that I didn’t agree. I have taken the time to read Stephen’s work that I reject these unfair and slanderous characterisations especially as he states explicitly that he abhors identity politics and does not accept the alt right.
It is much easier to just agree with the safely moral majority rather than enquiring into the matter and thinking for oneself, but isn’t the point of being at an academic institution to inquire independently? Those who decided to form their opinions on one article without reading his work demonstrate themselves to be incapable of being independent learners.
There is no doubt in my mind that the College’s potentially damaged reputation was a large factor in the decision to remove Stephen’s fellowship but what comes first; the reputation of the college, or the duty of an academic institution to not reprimand an academic for speaking their mind and to defend freedom of expression? It is clear to me that the integrity of an academic institution is best maintained by not trying to distance itself from members that hold a controversial viewpoint.

Chad’s was right to remove him
Lucy Hull
I think that it is right that Stephen Pax Leonard has been removed from his position at St Chad’s. It is not appropriate for a member of St Chad’s to be making the comments that he did and for this to go unchallenged, especially when Chad’s claim to pride themselves on their diversity.
By not removing him it would have seemed as though Chad’s were condoning the messages in the comments of Dr Pax Leonard. I feel that this is especially poignant at Durham, where we should be trying to encourage a more diverse range of students to apply, and comments like Dr Pax Leonard’s are doing little to encourage that and if anything, working against that goal.
Dr Masson also mentioned the issue of free speech in her email. Obviously, while this is again something that St Chad’s should be promoting, I do not think removing Dr Pax Leonard is necessarily in breach of this. There is a difference between freedom of speech and hate speech; preserving the right to free speech does not mean that anything can be said without any consequence.
Students of every gender, race and belief should feel completely safe and at Durham, but this cannot happen when hatred and racism are allowed to go unchecked.
We should be debating his opinions
Tamara Celeste Herrington
In terms of personal morality, I agree with the actions of St Chad’s College. Pax Leonard made disgusting comments that are completely divergent from the ethos of St Chad’s. However, I wouldn’t have made such a decision if I had the power. I hoped for the college to invite Pax Leonard for a question and answer forum on his latest book, not because I agree with his views but instead to rebuke them. I fear that silencing him could embolden him or his base followers.
Silencing doesn’t stop the problem but moves it to another area. It gives these people a sense that they are right and others are afraid that such ideas will ‘hurt our feelings’.
Pax Leonard especially tweets about ‘PC culture’ and the so-called suppression of free speech on university campuses. I’d hazard a guess that the removal of his fellowship will make him feel more valid in his views.
I say we should bring Pax Leonard to speak to us. We should listen to what he says, and then strip his arguments of all validity. The best way for us to silence him is to academically decimate his views. Disgusting ideas like antisemitism and Islamophobia are best dealt with by making such believers see how wrong their prejudices are.
So, I detest what Pax Leonard has said, but I would rather debate him. I fear the college may have given more fuel to his fire.
Photographs: Stephen Craven via Google Images via Creative Commons and Illustration by Kelcey Swain via Google Images via Creative Commons.
