Come Dine With Me: the first encounter

For all recipes go to palatinate.org.uk, and follow the “Lifestyle” tab to get to the Food & Drink section.
By Charlotte Allen
Photographer: Alice Gwynne
The first host: Francesca Henbest, 3rd year Theology, President of Josephine Butler Cookery Club
The guests: Greg Carter, PhD in Psychology, President of Castle Middle Common Room
Alison Moulds, 3rd year English, Features editor for Indigo
Charlotte Allen, 3rd year English, food and drink editor for Indigo
The Menu:
Cocktail reception and Spanish snacks
Creamy Butternut squash and chorizo soup with Foccacia bread
Mixed Paella with Mediterranean salad
Assiette of Lemon Desserts
Chocolate Truffles
After a week of trials and tribulations, the first dinner date approached. In a last minute twist of fate, I was drafted in to take part in the competition, having previously stipulated that I was to observe only. I greeted this news with a mixture of tiredness and frustration; considering the days I had spent trying to cajole several applicants that their summatives would most definitely be done in time for them to enjoy the first evening, it seemed that against all the odds I was to participate.
Not to mention how a certain (nameless) guest threw a wobbly at going first. I may be blowing it out of proportion, but a panicky 9 o’clock text message doesn’t put one in the best frame of mind. Jibes aside, however, they did have a valid reason, and as shall soon be clear, our first host completely excelled herself.
When I eventually found Francesca’s house (after circling her road several times), I found her kitchen to be a picture of organisation: her desserts were prepared and chilling in the fridge, her paella was bubbling happily away on the stove, her starter was ready to re heat and her canapés were poised for action under the grill. Even her vegetarian options were prepared, and met all of the correct criteria. Most impressively, she was up in the early hours of the morning to get her ingredients from Tesco, the Indoor Market, and the new deli on Claypath, which she highly recommends.
She had also made a considerable effort to get her table and dining room ready for the occasion, with fairy lights and Spanish music quietly setting the scene in the corner. She proudly told me that she had managed to get matching plates, cutlery and placemats; no small feat in a student house. I can almost see my chances of winning slipping away, amidst the mire of disorganisation and untidiness that is my own kitchen.
Francesca cheerfully chats away about her housemates and her cookery club, a college run affair that sets freshers up for their year of self-catering. Despite their busy schedules, she and her five housemates eat together each night, taking turns to cook. She tells me that she doesn’t really use recipes, she learns as she goes. She cooks so naturally, and I find myself envying her confidence hugely.
Disappointingly for fellow competitors, it seems that Francesca has sourced all her ingredients, prepared all her food and set her table all in time, and without undue stress or faff. I struggle to balance out my jealousy with admiration for her efficiency skills.
We are interrupted from details of Cesca’s preparations by a knock at the door – our first contestant. I hover awkwardly in the corner whilst she greets Greg Carter, who comes bearing a beautiful bunch of lilies and some red wine, Spanish of course. I glance self-consciously at my nod to the Spanish theme, two oversized sombreros snaffled from my housemates room, one of which is sitting awkwardly on my head, whilst I was intending to present the other to the next guest. I quickly remove both to the sofa.
Greg is exceedingly gentlemanly, much as one would expect from a President of Castle. His manners falter slightly at my sombreros, with distaste flickering fleetingly across his face, but in good spirits (and with a bit of encouraging) he dons a sombrero, and I feel slightly less silly.
Alison, the final guest appears next, apologising for being late after some confusion over the address. She introduces herself as the token vegetarian, although she does not elaborate too far on her reasons for being so. She watches Greg curiously, looking for the first sign of racism, sexism, or another –ism that will break the polite persona.
Meanwhile, Francesca serves her Spanish snacks, olives and roasted peppers, alongside dates wrapped in parma ham and grilled gently. These dates are sumptuous; salty but sweet, with a warm, soft texture that melts in the mouth. She also serves her intoxicating and deceptively alcoholic cocktail, the Highgate, a mixture of strawberries, ginger beer and gin. The crushed strawberries disappear instantly, and it is not until I have greedily consumed the entire thing that I realise just how strong it was. I even eat the strawberries poised on the edge of the glass.
Amongst all the eating, conversation is flowing easily. Even when we move to the table for the starter it is easy to let things run their course.
It is here, however, that Alison finds Greg’s weakness: obesity. He soliloquises eloquently upon the subject, whilst the rest of us look on, realising the humour beneath his words, but remaining in silence at the vehemence with which he puts it. When he finishes, we all look mutely on, until Francesca quickly steers the discussion towards films.
Nevertheless, although Francesca admits she was worried that her dinner party would be plagued with awkward silences, and we assure her to the contrary. We also have Greg filling up our glasses at every opportunity, and I have to doubly make sure I am not slurring my words.
The food itself was excellent. For me, the highlight was the soup, a creamy, smoky combination of flavours that I would never have put together. The bitesize hunks of chorizo nestle in the middle of the bowl, and give a lovely warmth to the soup. My only complaint is that the bread is not homemade; bread is one of my favourite things to make, something I believe becomes a whole new entity when made from scratch. Nevertheless, this delicious soup makes up for it.
Francesca presents the paella in a traditional paella dish, something she has borrowed from a friend specially. As she brings it to the table the smell wafts enticingly across the room. It is sticky without being stodgy, not too salty, and the accompanying salad is a refreshing contrast. I wolf mine down a little too hastily.
When I return to my glass, I realise it is full again. I find I am beginning to lose track of exactly how much I have had, and notice that my laugh is getting louder and bolder. I am very glad I have left the sombrero on the sofa, or I would be starting to look rather undignified.
The presentation of Francesca’s lemon desserts just invites you in. A lemon pot is the main feature, accompanied by a moist square of lemon loaf cake and a lemon biscuit. All the components are sharp, and not too cloyingly sweet, as I feel lemon desserts should be, and clean the palate after the rich and smoky main and starter. As we all retreat to give our final comments (slightly inebriated, and with full glasses yet again) I feel comfortably full.
Once in the (albeit filmed) privacy of the next room, the guests give their opinions on the night.
Greg enjoyed the soup, considering it “well balanced” and not overly seasoned. He went back two or three times for more paella, which he felt expressed just how nice it was. When asked about his fellow competitors, Greg comments that Alison seems quiet, although she gives just as good banter as she gets, and that Francesca is a good hostess, “radiating warmth”. He felt that I was “verbally dextrous”. Suprising, considering the amount of wine I had consumed.
Alison also enjoyed her meal, as she felt that she wasn’t singled out too much as the vegetarian. She did comment that her knife was a bit dirty at the start of the meal, but that she didn’t complain, as she felt the food was excellent When asked for her impressions of people, she comments on Greg’s fat-ist remarks, worrying about eating whilst he watched. She also mentions her belief that people with brightly coloured hair have loud or scary personalities; but apparently my bright red hair and I were not too bad.
Francesca, in her unbelievably still tidy kitchen, thought the evening went well. She enjoyed the company of her guests and left the evening on a high.
Although I must admit that I had to be careful of my ever full wine glass, I had an excellent evening, with wholesome food and good company – and I cannot wait to get a look around Castle before our next meal.

