Cold Head, Warm Heart
Soldiers in the British Army used to joke amongst themselves that when Kate Adie arrived, they knew they were in trouble.
Looking at the cover of Into Danger – the book she has just published about risking your life for work that was very much inspired by her own experiences as a journalist on the front-line – I can see why her arrival might be forboding.
Standing against the backdrop of a darkening storm, hands in the pockets of her customary flak-jacket, the radio presenter and twice-named Reporter of the Year certainly makes for rather an imposing figure; and it is with no small amount of trepidation that I approach the backstage of the Gala in order to interview her before her Book Festival speech.
Despite being widely recognised as the nation’s most popular war correspondent, Kate describes herself as having rather fallen into journalism, arriving at the doors of the recently launched Radio Durham with no money, no journalism experience and some vague misgivings over what a degree in Scandinavian Studies could qualify her for.
A fortuitous combination of right time, right place and – although she might not be the first to admit – an ample amount of raw talent – saw her rise from contributing to the daily farmers show (‘there isn’t anything I can’t tell you about sheep disease’) to holding one of the most sought after posts in the media industry: the BBC’s Chief News Correspondent.
She went on to cover some of the most memorable and moving conflicts in recent history; the Gulf War, Bosnia, the Troubles and the Balkans to name a few. Her publicists describe her as the most famous woman in a flak jacket, yet Kate is no celebrity. Throughout her near-stratospheric career, she has neither sought fame, nor has she courted it. To this day she has been one of the few journalists to remain remarkably closed about her personal life, and it is probably true to say her face and her voice are better known than her name.
This reticence, whilst undoubtedly the key to her professional success, makes her rather a daunting interviewee. Recent press interviews read like a ‘What Not to Ask’ guide to Kate Adie, with unwelcome questions prompting ‘nine second silences’ and frosty looks. Her personal life is strictly off-limits; so, too, are her thoughts and opinions on the BBC, and on other journalists. Ask, and you will be told quite firmly that Kate Adie ‘has an absolute rule, and [she’s] never broken it’.
‘I never comment on colleagues, and I neither praise nor denigrate.’
Later Kate concludes her speech to the Gala by describing what she sees as the defining attribute of a good journalist; ‘A cold head, and a warm heart’. It is this paradoxical aspiration which, more than anything else, provides the key to her character. When we meet she is warm and effusive, full of happy memories of her childhood in Sunderland, returning my own questions with a zest that clearly betrays her familiarity with both sides of the Dictaphone.
Yet throughout the full ninety minutes in which I am privileged to hear her speak, she only once loses that degree of professional cool that brought her international repute as a war correspondent, and that is to convey the sheer horror of being witness to a massacre so ruthless, and so unjust, it refuses to be described dispassionately. It is almost ten years since Kate reported on the vicious suppression of student protesters in Tiananmen Square, but the memories of “literally wading through blood” still haunt her.
“The danger to us was enormous – we were surrounded by gunfire all the time – but the reason we stayed in that danger was because we saw only one other camera out there, and I thought we need the evidence, because the Chinese would deny everything and lie”.
Even today her almost exclusive coverage of the tragedy remains a not insignificant thorn in the side of Chinese authorities who, as Kate predicted, have done their utmost to cover up the full extent of the catastrophe.
Needless to say, the coverage that could have killed her turned out to be the making of her, and for the majority of television viewers in our parents’ generation, the name Kate Adie is practically synonymous with that fateful day.
Sadly, the historical significance of June 1989 looks set to be rather short-lived. Talking to my peers in the weeks running up to our interview, I find that many of students struggle to recall the events at Tiananmen Square, far less the woman who reported them. For Kate, this difference is generational; times have changed, and the extraordinary horror and the vividness with which Kate’s viewers will recall the massacre was largely shaped by memories of their own student days in the sixties, when even the most anarchic demonstrations were ‘more or less tolerated’ by the authorities and the police.
Nevertheless, it does seem a rather sad reflection on our own times that the event that ten years ago was accredited with demonstrating the universal importance of human rights holds such little sway with the student population today.
The days of waving placards every Wednesday, and throwing eggs at the prime minster (‘Lovely man… it just seemed like the right thing to do at the time’) are long gone. Nowadays we treat people with causes with suspicion – remember the much-maligned clipboard carriers on Framwell Gate Bridge? – and the fact that even pertinent controversies like climate change and top-up fees struggle to move us off our comfortable seat on the fence, and into the streets, suggests our reluctance to protest has more to do with lack of inclination than inspiration.
The contrast between political fervour that pervaded Kate’s days at Newcastle University, and the almost parochial indifference that has given rise to such terms as ‘the Bubble’ , can no longer be overlooked. Bracing myself for a stern lecture on ‘the youth of today’, I ask Kate why she thinks there is such a marked increase in apathy in the past decade.
Yet Kate is too wise to idealise the past. Brushing aside concerns about my own political naivety with an affable laugh, she proceeded to dismantle some of the romantic notions that have accumulated around that now iconic figure, the 60s student.
The generation of students of which Kate Adie was a part were neither dazzlingly stylish – “nobody wore fashionable clothes. We couldn’t afford to” – nor politically enlightened. In fact, she is more than happy to admit that, most of the time, they didn’t really know what it was they were protesting about.
“I do remember being handed the placard and about half an hour later turning to the boy I was with and asking “What does it say? What’s on this afternoon?”
As much as we might like to think the Durham Bubble is our own affectionate term of phrase, the student indolence it rather damningly implies is by no means confined to Durham alone. In fact, contrary to what many of our elders would have us believe, it isn’t even a 21st century phenomenon.
“Don’t get the idea we were immensely informed… I never read a newspaper, I never watched any news, I was pretty uninformed about the way of the world like most of my peer group, we took up issues and causes, we weren’t nose deep in the Guardian and FT everyday”
Much of Kate Adie’s surprisingly magnanimous attitude towards a society that many of her generation have written off as apathetic and disinterested can be put down to her unseasonable appreciation of the ways in which challenges and pressures facing students have evolved over the past fifty years.
“For us, university was the time when you were free to have fun. There was not much talk of jobs, the money, the future, and I think that affects your outlook. Rather than condemn today’s students by saying their apathetic I would say they now have different priorities.”
It is this same discerning realism that prevents her from glorifying the actions of her own generation. Listening to Kate describe “being filled up with excitement at being this kind of student animal, who went out and made a noise about something” one cannot help get the impression that the extraordinary turnout at political demonstrations often boiled down to little more than glorified group mentality. Rather than being an act of personal politics, I venture to suggest that waving a banner simply ‘the thing to do’ back in the 1960s?
“It was. People used to scour the university on Wednesday afternoons, finding indolent students who were not out on the streets and push them out there; the only excuse was if you were playing sport”.
I rack my brains to think of a what our own equivalent might be – of what, twenty years down the line, we will be describing as the defining characteristic of our generation – but Kate Adie gets there first. If there’s one notion she is keen to counter more than anything else, it is the belief , most commonly found amongst media and in people over the age of 35, that the drinking culture prevalent in even the country’s most prestigious universities, has never been so bad. Recollections of Kate’s life at university are littered with references to drinking, from her financial advice on how to “live off cheese rolls and beer”, to her unashamed pride in the fact she went to a university that had a direct pipeline from the brewery.
“We spent our life out there drinking – all this take of ‘binge drinking these days‘- why, we’d drink for England!”
Kate’s progressive honesty stems in part from her experiences of objective reporting, and in part to what, given her extensive experience of man’s inhumanity to man, can only be described as her remarkable confidence in the idea of ‘human nature’; something she will later come to define as the belief that “when faced with a real challenge people find resources within themselves that are absolutely staggering, and that you did not realise you had”.
My first glimpse of this comes when we turn to discussing the changing face of the media; in particular, the movement of news channels away from objective, hard-nosed reporting, towards what Kate has been known to describe as ‘the celebrity area of culture’, with its corresponding values of sensationalism, sentiment and glamour.
Initially, Adie was reluctant to talk about the views that only a few months ago were ruffling the feathers of her former bosses at the BBC. For the first time in the course of our conversation there was a note of impatience in her voice as she warded off my enquiries about the future of the media with the assertion that it’s a ‘huge subject’ and she ‘doesn’t really go into it that much’.
Nevertheless, when I suggest the blurring lines between ‘news’ and ‘entertainment’ have much to do with society’s current preoccupation with the personal and the emotional, she is swift to defend us.
“Come on, come on there’s nothing new in this – don’t you remember those ‘delicate’ poets of the eighteenth century? It’s just a different emphasis and it comes around at a certain times in society; we haven’t changed as people… You always think change is permanent, but actually human nature doesn’t change a lot.”
Standing in defiance of what she calls the prevailing notion, that “human beings turn into a jelly heap when their canary falls of their perch”, Kate draws upon her peerless experience of humanity to assert that “absolutely nearly everyone will have determination and courage when and if you really have to pull out the stops”.
We concluded the interview in the same way that Adie, when interviewing people for Into Danger, concludes hers, by turning to those men and woman who risk their lives for work and asking “you do this in the name of what?”
It’s a good question. Kate’s answer?
“To bring information to people. To open up that window on the world which is possible through journalism, to find things out and bring it back and tell everyone about it. It’s thrilling. That’s why I do it”.
