Clegg-mania to Coalition blues
In the build up to the 2010 general election, “I agree with Nick” was the motto of a generation; swathes of young voters had been won over by the Lib Dem leader’s performances in the series of televised debates and his party looked set for a historic return of votes. Not only did the Lib Dems only win 9% of the seats in the House of Commons in 2010, but they have since dropped below UKIP in some polls to hold the undesirable title of Britain’s fourth political party. The latter can largely be ascribed to the curse of coalition government, whereas the former is more illusive.
Hindsight is a wonderful thing, and it seems that what was perceived as a surge in popularity for the Lib Dems in early 2010 was rather a surge in Clegg’s personal popularity, and thus did not translate into votes for his party’s candidates nationwide. The millions who watched the debates and were persuaded of the virtues of a man who many of them had never previously heard of did not, on the whole, go out in force to cast their votes in favour of the Liberal Democrats. Part of this was because they weren’t allowed to; as “Clegg-mania” took off, particularly on social networking sights such as Facebook and Twitter, many of those most taken by the Lib Dem leader were politically aware sixth formers who were too young to vote. To them, like many others, he seemed like a breath of fresh air by comparison to the dour and gaffe-prone Brown, or Cameron, who, as a conservative, may not have been the default choice of a rebellious teenager. This was all very well for those of voting age, but not enough of a pro-Clegg lobby formed to create any significant swing towards the Lib Dems; it was a movement capable of plenty of talk, but little action.
The other factor that most dissuaded much of the population from voting Lib Dem in 2010 was the predicted tightness of the election. Many commentators rightly forecasted the first hung parliament since the 1970s, which considerably detracted from the Lib Dem vote as many of the party’s potential supporters chose to vote for a party that they saw as having a better chance of forming a majority government.
That the Liberal Democrats reached such a low in 2010 came as a surprise to many, but their sinking further since entering coalition was much more predictable. The most obvious example of this has come in the shape of perceived broken promises, most notably in the case of tuition fees. This has reflected badly on Clegg himself, in part due to his previously high levels of personal popularity; he is now seen as a hate figure by many of those who were once such keen Cleggites. This is very bad luck. No party can be expected to uphold the promises they make on the Campaign trail if they do not win the election, and, having won so few seats, being in government at all is a coup for the party. The minority partner of a coalition must fight hard to force any of its policies through, let alone controversial and expensive policies such as freezing tuition fees in a time of austerity.
The other important factor that has contributed to post-electoral unpopularity for the Lib Dems has also been brought about by their role in government: they are no longer outsiders in the clash of Labour vs Conservative. Thus, as was clear in the infamous by-election in Bradford West, they are not the recipients of protest votes against the two biggest parties, as they are no longer seen as an alternative, but as a part of the problem. Although Bradford West is most obviously seen as an embarrassment for the Labour Party, who lost a ‘safe’ seat to a man more famous for his appearance on Celebrity Big Brother than his politics, many anti-Labour votes (as opposed to pro-Respect votes) would normally have been expected to go to the Lib Dems, but they are now seen as soiled by their role in government, and so their unpopularity grows greater still.
In the same way that the Liberal Party certainly wasn’t dead when George Dangerfield dramatically pronounced it so in 1935, it is a long way from demise now, but its woeful approval ratings must be a real cause for concern for the party’s leadership and activists alike.

