‘Christmas unwrapped: Is A Christmas Carol really one of the best festive tales or do we say ‘Bah Humbug!’ to it?

By Nikita Bangar

As the festive season approaches we wave a slow goodbye to autumnal ambience, and extend a frosty hello to the cold grasps of winter. With recent temperatures dropping as low as 2°C here in Durham, it is fair to say that yes, Winter Is Coming. But which books will get us in the mood for the upcoming season?

Though wonderfully vivacious, Christmas spirit is fleeting and, as we near the end of Michaelmas term, many will agree that leisurely reading has become an indulgence of the past. So, at 150 pages, A Christmas Carol becomes the perfect choice, it couldn’t be more efficiently Christmassy if it tried. Or could it?

In fact, A Christmas Carol is not overtly festive. The tale of Ebenezer Scrooge is everything but, that’s the point. Written in 1843, it is thought Dickens wrote the carol as a social criticism, highlighting the bleak situation of England’s poor. It is believed that the novella attempts to illustrate the true meaning of Christmas, if we assume that this is to spread happiness and love during the cold and previously hard-lived months. By placing a character such as the epithetical Scrooge within festive literature, and making his reversal central to the plot, Dickens juxtaposes a niggling gloom with vibrant elation, rekindling an aurora of festivity and goodwill by the last stave.

Besides the name, at a first reading it can be hard to agree that A Christmas Carol could be the most cheerful song around. Most of the competition don’t so openly flirt with the theme of death, as does Dickens in portending Tiny Tim’s passing and Scrooge’s funeral.

Dr Seuss’ Grinch and Valentine Davies’ Miracle (on 34th Street) appear joyful and light-hearted, adorned with vibrant descriptions of festive splendour. Comparatively, this novella seems a tale which ‘no warmth could warm’. Yet, all novels accommodate a subliminal social satire which is hauntingly candid.

Perhaps a covertly didactic nature in festive literature is the edge, allowing young and old readers alike to find befitting Christmas comforts or morals to ponder. But what of those morals? What tales of wealth, sharing, and comfort are to be learned?

The pondering modern-day reader might as well say ‘Bah Humbug!’ to it all. For this novella lacks any trace of female/ minority representation. It asserts no power, gives no voice, to female or minority populations. Yet, it is a classic, a time old tale relayed between generations. Like so much that is celebrated within our culture, our universal problems, values, and moral imperatives are ascribed to a white man who learns to see the truth. Frustrated again, we reach the concept of a literary canon.

The Western Canon, as presented to us by Bloom in 1994, is made up of ‘dead white males’, and nakedly exclusive in an era of inclusion. How can we know that these are the best festive tales when they constitute the only ones we’ve heard? We believe that these are exemplary of accomplished (classic) literature, simply because this is what we have been told. Such novels have been given exclusivity by an elitist voice; they have been ruled worthy and thus preserved as key examples of what Arnold claimed to be ‘the best which has been thought and said in the world’.

Should this haunt us much? While the western canon is often defended it still invariably lacks what W. E. B Du Bois coins a ‘double consciousness’, thus lacking consciousness of the minority in any substantial form. While you watch TV adaptions or flip through the pages of Christmas “classics” this year, maybe lend a thought to the value of the literary canon. Look beyond the western to find tales of the orient or minority. Give yourself a lasting gift this Christmas and redefine your literary canon.

 

Here’s some to start:

A Thousand Spendid Suns, Khaled Hosseini

The Forty Rules of Love, Elif Shafak

Americanah, Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie

I Am Malala, Malala Yousafzai

The Alchemist, Paulo Coelho

Things Fall Apart, Chinua Achebe

 

Image Credit: John Stratford via Flickr