Christmas: created, commercial, Christian?
By Emily Hurst
The idea that there is some untainted ‘true meaning’ to Christmas is probably false. Christmas is by nature an amalgamation of convenience and celebration: a seasonally adjusted commemoration of the incarnation. As advent begins, I want to take the opportunity to consider the inherent tensions of the festive season, and what can be learnt from them.
I have often thought, on some level, that the ‘version’ we have of Christmas is utterly commercialised, made meaningless and meaningful by money. And that this is a distraction from the real Christmas. Friends have said that they celebrate Christmas, but not the religious one. A colleague said he hates Christmas, living alone. He was surprised that my dad is not the biggest fan either; well, he likes the religious side of it, I said.
Now, I am beginning to question how helpful this distinction is, between commercialised ‘secular’ Christmas and its religious twin. It’s as if there is one naughty Christmas which I greedily indulge, and another nice Christmas which I struggle to honour. One where I sample every mince pie, drink mulled wine, watch The Holiday and tolerate Michael Bublé. And another where I go to churches and pray for my colleague who is lonely and hear the Bible and think worthy things.
The ‘version’ we have of Christmas is utterly commercialised
And so, for this advent, I am trying to bring the two together. Or rather, I am trying to disengage with the binary which has stopped me from finding the divine in the ‘secular’ Christmas, which is also Christmas. Being a Christian, I believe there’s a sacred quality to ordinary things, a loving Creator behind the messy mundane. Maybe the divine mystery can be noticed in the contradictory nature of Christmas. Maybe by pushing into something uncomfortable, I will remember that the incarnation story was never comfortable. A grubby, bizarre miracle.
The question remains, for me at least, what this religious belief has to do with the 25th December. This led me to do a bit of a Britannica deep-dive (probably motivated a great deal by all the reading I could’ve, would’ve, should’ve been doing for my course). Turns out Christianity has nothing and everything to do with Christmas. To some extent, I’d been raised with the idea that Christians were simply piggybacking on pagan festivals, like the Saturnalia and the Winter Solstice. Pretty accurate. Both involved elaborate feasting, to celebrate the end of a long dark winter. In Medieval Britain, we called this Yule. However, three elements were combined with these existing feasts to form Christmas as we know it today: the day, the tree, the (jolly old) man.
Turns out Christianity has nothing and everything to do with Christmas
The decision to celebrate Christmas on 25th was likely made by Constantine, in a bid to move 4th century Rome from worshipping the pantheon to celebrating the mass of Christ. Something that struck me was that the Romans were supposed to celebrate the return of the Unconquered Sun on this day, with the return of longer hours of daylight. As a metaphor for the incarnation, the return of the unconquered Son brings a wry smile to this theology student, but this has nothing to do with the history, of course. Whilst 4th-century Rome celebrated Christ’s Mass on 25th December, it was not made an official Christian feast day until the 9th century.
On its way to becoming such a feast, Christmas in Germany became characterised by unusual traditions. The most notable of these is having a dead evergreen tree in the house. What I did not know was that the tradition stems from St Boniface, who chopped down a tree to prove that it did not belong to Thor (I can only picture Chris Hemsworth here, thanks Marvel). Most interesting, perhaps, is that evergreens were decorated and displayed in German homes on the 24th December, during the Middle Ages. They were referred to as ‘paradise trees,’ since the 24th was the feast day for Adam and Eve. Over the following centuries, the trees became associated with Christmas instead, and the tradition spread. I did not realise that trees had a particularly religious association, nor that they were part of Christmas because of a feast for Adam and Eve. To give a very quick summary, the incarnation is often presented as a response to the Garden of Eden, since Jesus represents a new creation, and a new hope. I think I will look at Christmas trees differently now.
Through human connection and stories, we find a way to commemorate something beyond our understanding
Finally, Father Christmas. Sinterklaas was the Dutch name for St Nicholas, who was believed to be a bishop from the town Myra (now in Turkey) during the 4th century. His importance in the Eastern church bled into the Western tradition when his relics were stolen by some Italians in the 11th century. His legend was taken – intertwined with Dutch folklore about giving good children presents – into 17th-century America where his name was pronounced Santa Claus. Kind of a weird and troubling story. But I suppose I find it to be, yet again, an instance of non-Christian and Christian narratives becoming intertwined and inseparable.
Finding a hidden depth to Christmas, then, is silly when its meaning sits right here, on the surface. Through human connection and stories, we find a way to commemorate something beyond our understanding. That is, in my mind, God become human. There is wonder to be found in what seems trivial, and it would be trivialising to imagine that the only place to find God is by stripping away layers of history and tradition, missing out on everything that these might have to offer.
Image: Steve Burke via Wikimedia Commons

