China’s economic challenge
Lao Tzu, an ancient Chinese philosopher, once stated that it is best to “anticipate the difficult by managing the easy”. Unfortunately for China this advice is as archaic as the sage himself. There is nothing simple about the country’s path towards development.
December marked the 30th anniversary of China’s ‘opening up’ to the world. This decision initiated an incremental move towards a market economy for the world’s most populous country. The subsequent impact has engulfed the globe, touching its tentacles on issues ranging from food security to the genocide in Darfur.
Whilst the sheer scope of this influence is startling, it is no reason to fear the emerging proud and confident modern China.
Yet many do, citing reports of environmental degradation and the repression of human rights within the country. In a year underscored by more sensitive anniversaries – the 20th anniversary of the June 4 Tiananmen incident, 50 years since the exile of the Dalai Lama and the 60th anniversary of the People’s Republic – these are issues which must be addressed.
However, they risk underestimating the country’s achievements and the fragility underlying its success.
Since 1978 the standard of living across China has significantly improved. The UN estimates that over 635 million Chinese citizens have been raised above the poverty line.
Although there is a well-documented economic disparity between the burgeoning Eastern coastal regions and rural inland areas, the poor have better provisions than at any time in recent history.
Within two years, for example, the central government hopes to supply basic healthcare to 90 per cent of the population in a move which it hopes will precipitate universal coverage by 2020. Access to education has improved. Fewer people carry the burden of having to worry about whether they will have food to eat each day.
Moreover, China’s public sphere is thriving. Fuelled by a young generation of internet users who spend an approximated two billion hours online each week, the access and distribution of information has proliferated.
Party line is no longer mantra as bureaucrats are increasingly held into account by ‘Netizens’ who publicise cases of local official abuses. The Chinese government might be notorious for its internet censorship, but one should not overlook how expanding internet accessibility has been part of their development strategy. As outlined in the first ‘Golden Project’ launched in 1993, there was a justified belief that an expansive internet infrastructure would accentuate modernisation.
China is also undergoing the largest-scale urbanisation in human history. Since reforms began, the number of official cities has soared from 193 to over 650. Some are globalised metropolises, such as Shanghai, which by some accounts has a population of 18.5 million excluding migrant workers – who may add another million to the tally.
Similarly, McKinsey, a consultancy firm, reckon that by 2030 China’s urban population will total over 1 billion. This is not incidental. The latest World Development Report by the World Bank stresses that cities must continue to grow if economic development is going to continue. Thus, China’s future prosperity is contingent upon further urbanisation.
Amongst these accomplishments lie arrays of problems which ought to be critiqued. The urban to rural income gap has widened from a ratio of 1.8 to over 3, with women and minorities being particularly disadvantaged. Furthermore, what is known as the ‘hukou’ system of household registration prevents migrant labourers from gaining access to urban housing allocations, educational institutions and other public goods, therefore exacerbating their social stratification.
This system, which has produced a ‘floating population’ numbering over 100 million, may be necessary for the state to control the flows of internal migration, but is still unduly repressive.
In addition to internal migrants, many of those who remain in their traditional environs have also experienced a curtailment of rights. There are over 120 minority groups in China, yet less than half of these are officially recognised.
Even amongst those who are, the influx into minority-dominated areas by Han-Chinese people who comprise 90% of the population has eroded traditional cultures and appropriated jobs from the local population. The result is simmering social strife, as witnessed in the Western provinces of Xinjiang and Tibet during the Olympic pandemonium.
China’s development also poses challenges to the population at large. The combination of a growing population with rapid industrialisation may mean that by 2030 China will be unable to produce enough food for its population; global grain supplies are not expected to bridge this gap either. What’s more, the State Council has declared that by 2030 “the drought-fighting situation will be increasingly serious”. In the meantime, rising incomes have raised expectations and Chinese people are now consuming more meat and dairy than ever before.
To top this all off, the One-Child Policy has created a demographic debacle. Between now and the middle of the century, the ratio of workers to retirees will decrease from six-to-one to two-to-one. This burden threatens to erode the economic gains made over the previous fifty years.
The Communist government still rightly labels China as a developing country. Great strides have been made over the past thirty years but this success does not denote destiny. The improvement in living standards for hundreds of millions of people should be a cause for celebration, not fear or anxiety.
Criticisms of the Chinese state are often warranted, but they should also account for the complexities and conundrums the country faces. Lao Tzu, it seems, was almost right: easier issues must be tackled if China is to have any success in solving more difficult ones. The problem is that both are coming at the same time.
