Ched Evans: the flaws of the justice system

By Andrew PooleChed_Evans

 

I have been a Sheffield United fan now for 14 long years and cannot remember a period of such great media scrutiny involving my club. Perhaps only when the Carlos Tevez incident of 2007 grabbed the media’s attention did the club receive similar attention.

Yet, this week slowly pressure has been building in the form of the case of convicted rapist Ched Evans. Jailed in 2012 for five years, but to be released early on Friday the 17th October, the board of Sheffield United now face a decision that will define the rest of the season. Ched Evans, before his conviction, was a potent striker for the Blades. Despite having the 2011/2012 season end prematurely he was still able to record 35 goals in all competitions. Evans was the focal point of the Blades, a fan favourite who it was firmly believed would lead the club to promotion.

However, Sheffield United’s and the Welshman’s fortunes seemed to follow a similar course, Evans was sentenced to 5 years in prison and the Blades still languish in the third tier of English Football as the two parties seem now destined to re-join each other. Naturally the idea of a convicted rapist being able to walk back into his old life has provoked strong feelings due to the incredibly serious nature of his crime. It must be stressed that at no point has anyone condoned Evans’ actions and certainly Sheffield United nor the vast majority of its fans wish to belittle the awful crime that is rape. It is a highly convincing argument that Evans’ release just two and a half years after his conviction does not accurately reflect the severity of his crime, but this is not Evans’ fault, the responsibility lies within the Justice system.

It cannot be disputed that Ched Evans has the right to play football once again; perhaps the fundamental principal of the justice system is that of prisoner rehabilitation. Once he has served his time, Evans has the right to earn a living and plans to exercise his right to do exactly that. For some reason, his decision to do this has sparked controversy in the media as the job of a footballer is seen as too privileged a position in society for a man who has committed the crime of rape. Terms such as ‘role-model’ are often attached to footballers, but I feel this is over-stated. Sheffield United fans cheer for eleven players on a Saturday afternoon, not one. Sheffield United fans cheer for the actions of players on the pitch, not their actions off it. The fan base is currently fractured by the Ched Evans debate, it is necessary to clarify that not all Blades fans want Evans to return, a point that is sometimes overlooked by the media.

The reality is this: Evans will be playing professional football in six months, whether it is for Sheffield United or not. The risks of failure in football are too high for clubs to miss out on the chance to sign a proven goalscorer. A club, with perhaps a lower profile and smaller fanbase, will take a risk and sign him, they would be stupid not to. Therefore the debate needs to be broader. The justice system requires a fundamental overhaul; the fact that so many feel so strongly that he should not play again, yet legally he is perfectly entitled to do, suggests something is wrong. Personally I believe this debate should not even be taking place. Thirty months in jail for rape makes a mockery of the crime, Evans should be comfortably beyond the age of professional footballers once he is released from prison if he were to serve a prison term that I believe would truly reflect the nature of the crime.

Finally, it is also important to note that he does maintain his innocence, but at the moment he must be seen as a convicted rapist, as a jury of his peers have found him to be so beyond reasonable doubt. Yet the realities of the situation must be embraced. Evans will be playing football again soon. Sheffield United will most likely re-sign him embracing this logic as they want him scoring goals for them, not against them. But this case has the potential to dramatically impact the future if its lessons are acted upon. Readers should also note that this is not an easy decision for Sheffield United, arguably they cannot win. The fanbase will be splintered, some adore the striker, and some will not attend matches whilst he is with the club. Personally I believe that he should, in the current circumstances, be able to play again. But the system needs an overhaul before arguments involving ‘role-model behaviour’ can begin to influence decision-making.

When Ched Evans steps on the field again, most likely representing the Blades, it is not Sheffield United who should be attacked for this decision, but the justice system. The footballing realities of the situation almost command Sheffield United to re-sign him; the risk is too great to let him go elsewhere. But a change to the Justice system must be the answer, so that this situation is the last of its kind.

Photograph: wikipedia