Changes review: ‘musical risk-taking’

By Carrie Gaunt

Durham Festival of the Arts has already proven to be an embarrassment of theatrical riches, with Empty Shop, Durham’s favourite fringe venue, playing host to a plethora of ‘firsts’ for DST over the last week. Last night’s performance of Changes, a devised song cycle, sits alongside Durham’s first forays into clowning and spoken word performance, and matches both in innovation and excellence.

Tone Deaf Theatre Company have historically brought a more contemporary brand of musical theatre to DST. Changes is no exception – you won’t find any Rogers and Hammerstein here – indeed, many of the songs and musicals were previously unknown to me, but despite the variety of source material the narrative is conceptually coherent. Robert Green’s musical accompaniment, seamlessly knitting together so many different songs (with, I can only imagine, a fair few contrasting styles), should be greatly commended.

The only real issues that I had with the piece were structural, and therefore possibly par for the course with the song cycle medium, rather than specific to this production. I felt that whilst Changes offered a beautifully nuanced and subtle exploration of adulthood and romance, for a piece intended to explore growing up, in all its multi-facetedness, there were some quite meaty stones that were left unturned. The teenage years, for example, were all but glossed over, and the transition from childhood to marriage felt slightly perfunctory, particularly considering that musical theatre offers a wealth of material covering the ups and downs of adolescence. I also felt that the production could have benefitted from clearer ideas about the intention of the narrative. Throughout, there was a slight confusion as to whether this was intended to be a series of conceptually interconnected but ultimately disparate vignettes, or the story of four people growing up, growing old and falling in love. Both would work fantastically but as it is the production tends to segue between the two, which possibly slightly lessens the final emotional punch (although the ending is, as a sidenote, pretty devastating).

Nevertheless, minor structural niggles aside, this is a very accomplished piece of theatre. Director Shona Graham has produced incredibly well-rounded and complex performances from her four actors. All display an impressive range of emotion, communicated subtly and maturely – there is absolutely no danger of brush-stroke, ham-fisted emotion here. This is particularly commendable considering that Empty Shop is a tremendously exposed performance space, laying every gesture bare to scrutiny, and offering little or no protection from any momentary lapses out of character. It is arguably the best possible venue for this kind of performance, facilitating a delicate touch and focus on the smaller details which would be imposssible in a more traditional, proscenium arch space. All four performers are near faultless but it was Alex Mackinder who stole the show. His performance of ‘Perfect’ from Edges was a tour-de-force, by turns passionate and quiet, incredibly honest in its gut-wrenching honesty.  It’s very special to watch music be performed with such emotional intensity – it was one of many moments in Changes that left me with tears in my eyes.

By and large, the production has been styled simply but effectively – shifts in tone and age were signified by a minor change in clothing which usually worked well, although this did occasionally feel overly fussy or unnecessary. I would have really liked to see a more defined aesthetic, a more definite colour palate for example, which particularly if the intention was to follow four characters through their lives would have created a lovely sense of constancy, but I do appreciate that not every stage in a life cycle can be neatly portrayed, sartorially speaking.

Changes is performed with a great deal of heart, emotion and incredible musical and theatrical talent. The concept is clever and resonant and the execution is pretty much flawless. It’s a crying shame that this production, like much of the Empty Shop programme, was such a blink-and-you’ll-miss-it addition to Durham Festival of the Arts, but it’s a tantalising glimpse of musical risk-taking from TDTC that will hopefully flourish in the coming academic year.

Photograph: Lara Dolden