Chancellor Sir Thomas Allen’s “Five Mystical Songs”
In the lead up to Durham University Choral Society’s performance of Vaughan Williams’ “Five Mystical Songs” on 5th December, Tonya Alban speaks to Chancellor Sir Thomas Allen behind his connection with the epic.
By Tonya Alban
As you know Choral Society will be performing Ralph Vaughan Williams’ “Five Mystical Songs”. As you have some experience with them, we would love some insight. First, about the history, this period has been dubbed a renaissance in English music, do you think that is a fair assessment?
I think that’s true. There were a number of those (composers) around at the time. You know when I was a student, every day I used to meet with Herbert Howells, for example. And rather like the memories you have of your grandparents you wish you had asked them certain questions. I wish I had asked Herbert Howells about Vaughan Williams, about Holst and about all the various other people that he knew but I knew him up to a point and, you know, you didn’t go there.
Vaughan Williams was part of that regrowth of British music. I mean a lot of people contended in 1695 when Purcell died, English music died at that same time. In a way, they are just about right. There were lighter and less structured pieces. What occurred on the continent was completely different and didn’t happen in Britain. Finally, along came heavy-weight Vaughan Williams and he started writing. It’s strange to think of Vaughan Williams being the student of Ravel. The music that he wrote has a wonderful melodic surge to it and, for a singer, it’s an absolute gift.
So I’ve known these songs since I was a student, and I won’t tell you how long ago that was, it was a long time ago. I performed them for the first time as a student at the Royal College of Music and became very aware of them. Time went by, I recorded them, sang them in one or two concerts, not so many. And then I was asked by the BBC if I would do the last night of the Proms.
How was that for you?
Absolutely terrifying. You don’t sleep the night before. It’s just like before I played golf with Lee Travino and Sean Connery; I didn’t sleep the night before that either. I was supposed to be prepared for the music, but it’s a huge ask of any performer to walk out into the Albert Hall at any time.
On that evening you would think Queen Victoria was in the auditorium. All the flags were waving, and I had to sing. It was the first performance of the work at the Proms. It had never been done before. They are sadly neglected and for the life of me I don’t know why. They say wonderful things. At the end of it all it’s just a glorious evening.
So these pieces, are they quintessentially British?
Yeah. You stand up and sing them and it’s like doing big verse anthems in any grand Church of England edifice of one sort or another. There’s no escaping the fact that we understand what this is about. You know…(picking up the music)…I hear right at the beginning… (sings) “Rise heart thy Lord is risen”… and you think yes, this is English. It could be nothing but English, and none the worse for that either. We used to divide the songs at college, so that everyone got a chance (to sing them). So I got the first one and then other baritones sang the other three, the last one being the Antiphon (for choir only). And they are an absolute gift they really are but unmistakably belonging to that genre of English music that came out in the early part of the twentieth century.
Have you sung them abroad at all?
No. When you consider conductors like Simon Rattle and Colin Davis, who were taking twentieth-century English music and performing it in Germany for the first time, it would not be as easy for them to transport this work. Yet, without a standard-bearer for this work in Europe, it’s very difficult to get it performed.
We must consider that we are an island which developed differently from the arts everywhere else on the continent. When you think about the richness of central Europe, it was inherent due to Catholicism. Our music was somehow left behind. But, at the beginning of the twentieth century with Vaughan Williams arriving and succeeding, we did start to produce some considerable music, and some has remained as core repertoire ever since.
And then Vaughan Williams…
And then, well, Stainer came along, and the Crucifixion. And you know there were the Lindleys and various people that’s didn’t make their mark in that same sort of way. But the beginning of the twentieth century with Vaughan Williams arriving and going on, we did start to produce some considerable music and a lot of it has been at the core of my repertoire for a number of years.

And with this piece, if I had to say choose one of the songs to perform, which would it be?
It would be…(turning pages)…’Love bade me welcome’.
Number three, why is that?
Uh…(picking up the music)…it’s the most lyrical of them and…(reading)… “Love bade me welcome; yet my soul drew back,/Guilty of dust and sin./ But quick-eyed Love, observing me grow slack/ From my first entrance in,/ Drew nearer to me, sweetly questioning, /If I lack’d anything./ “A guest,” I answer’d”.
…And so it goes on. But, the reason why it becomes special is, in the last two pages I sing: “And know you not,” says Love, “who bore the blame?” “My dear, then I will serve.”
And then you this little play out and the chorus comes in with the ‘O Sacrum Convivium’ theme (humming). And you have to sing: “You must sit down,” says Love, “and taste my meat:” So I did sit…” That’s why I love it, because if you were Rostropovich or the present-day Kanneh-Mason, you’d just want to play a cello tune. At that point, that is the greatest cello tune you have. It gives you that opportunity. And that’s what, as a singer, one partly looks for. And you know, you sing those earlier bars and think “Ok, let’s just relax and sing this as beautifully as I can”.
And, finally, what would you say to people who are torn between going to the pub or going to a lovely concert?
Go to the pub. I’m probably not supposed to say that am I? (laughs). I would say, go to the concert, and then go to the pub. But really go to the pub, because your pint will taste so much more sweet after you’ve heard this music. You can go to the pub anytime, but listen to this music first and then go and sop your pint and then it’ll taste differently.
Thank you so much, it’s been absolutely amazing.
Pleasure!
Durham University Choral Society perform Vaughan Williams’ “Five Mystical Songs” as part of their Michaelmas Concert on 5th December, 7:30pm, at Elvet Methodist Church. Further information about the concert is available on their Facebook page and tickets are available at https://www.musicdurham.org/event/choral-society-michaelmas-concert-2/.
Image credit: Durham University
