Challenge University

By Frances Scott

Once upon a time university was free, but those fairy tale years ended when Lord Dearing scrapped state-funded education and set the ball rolling for the daunting prices we know and dread today. Yet 43% of us persist in choosing a university degree over many other types of formal qualifications. Why?

For some of us, a degree is a commercial transaction – we’ll pay for three years’ education, if society gives us a decent job at the end of it. But in today’s vastly depleted job sector this outcome is far from guaranteed. For others, university is an academic haven where students are encouraged to ‘learn for learning’s sake’. The ancients believed this too but then again, they weren’t charged £9,000 per annum for the pleasure. Is it time to step back and assess what we’re really paying for?

I came across an article in 2011 by the now award winning British playwright Anya Reiss candidly entitled “Uni? Another hoop I didn’t want to jump through”. ITN newsreader Alistair Stuart continued in a similar vein, describing the path to university as “a dangerous conveyor belt…dangerous for its automaticity”. They beg the question: are we unwittingly jumping through curriculum hoops to meet school targets, satisfy family members, or more disturbingly, pay for the Government’s mistakes?

In June 2011 Universities Minister David Willetts proposed that “the Government will reform the financing of higher education…and foster social mobility”. An admirable goal but one that the government doesn’t seem any closer to achieving; UCAS report that the overall drop in domestic applicants currently stands at -7.6% compared to last year. Does this figure represent those who have re-evaluated a degree and found it wanting?

Labour considered university education a right. Our grandparents regarded it as a privilege. Perhaps, more realistically, it should be thought of as an option. But if that’s the case, where are the alternatives and why do we persist in putting degrees on a pedestal?

The moment they were voted in, the coalition government pulled out policies that either broke the promises they made in the run up to the election or were missing from their manifestos. What can the economic and cultural future be for a country where the pursuit of knowledge has become a mere commodity? I wonder…

None of us are blind to the fact that we are witnessing critical changes to our education system. And it’s just as important to record the views of those who bang the drum at student protests as those who stand quietly on the sidelines.

I am compiling a book to be published later this year which will be a contemporary account of our opinions on these changes – whether it’s the pressure to take a degree, what you see as its worth, or your ideas for reform.

We owe it to ourselves and to future generations of students to be heard.

If you are interested in being interviewed for this publication, please contact Frances Scott on miss.frances.scott@gmail.com to arrange convenient times and dates.