Celebrating 100 years of The Great Gatsby
By Milly Evans
The year 2025 marks the 100th anniversary of the American literary masterpiece The Great Gatsby by Fitzgerald (I use this surname cautiously in consideration of evidence that F. Scott plagiarised the diaries of his wife, Zelda, and an old lover, Ginevra King, in the construction of his prose). In celebration of this work, I want to examine the reasons for its rise in popularity in the 1940s, sustained through to our current period.
From the outset, the title of Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby exudes grandeur and decadence: set in a period nicknamed The Roaring 20s, it portrays swarming scenes of evening parties filled with life, exuberance, and excess that – at first glance – appear like united occasions for social entertainment. It is only through the introspection of the narrator (Nick Carraway), more intimate scenes, and the unveiling of the eponymous Gatsby’s backstory, that the artificiality of the novel’s foreground is revealed. There is a physical and cultural hangover following Gatsby’s parties as those with New Money face prejudice and ineptitude from the perspective of the Old Money families; meanwhile, working class people work against the grindstone of capitalist society under the eyes of TJ Eckleburg.
For a text so frequently a contender for the title of ‘The Great American Novel’, Gatsby was surprisingly unsuccessful upon publication, selling slowly on the free market and fostering conflicting opinions before it was distributed by the Council on Books in Wartime to soldiers during World War Two. This poses two immediate questions: why was this book chosen, and why did a war-time readership catalyse its popularity? This can be understood through a historical focus on the events in America that may have shifted the collective mood, namely the Great Depression and the beginning of World War Two.
From the outset, Fitzgerald’s The Great Gatsby exudes grandeur and decadence
Fitzgerald’s portrayal of the nation’s excessive appetites was initially not recognised as a critique of the futility and inevitable consequences until later audiences had experienced the financial crash. In retrospect, it seems that the novel predicts the economic and political future of America, applicable to the World War period as much as a modern world. During the Great Depression, America experienced great suffering and many people turned to crime to survive; in light of this, the boot-legging history of Gatsby becomes morally justifiable, with people finding a sympathetic affinity with a man fighting to make success against the turbulent whims of capitalism. The original audience’s unreceptivity to Gatsby was fuelled by their being fed propaganda about the extent to which alcohol was to blame for America’s moral and economic instability – leading to Prohibition: a political move that was largely undermined by leaders implicated in global issues, rather than a drunk population. Furthermore, their financial struggles lead to a cultural revolution in critical thoughts of anti-Capitalism and its preposition of the ‘American Dream’ as a cornerstone of American opportunity.
Modern readers, too, share a connection to the determined, yet vain, spirit of Gatsby in chasing the American Dream, an ideal largely recognised now to be an unattainable invention. It cannot be stated plainly that ‘the American Dream is a lie,’ yet it is hard to deny that social mobility has remained stagnant due to socioeconomic and systematic barriers within America and, by placing the emphasis on the grit of individuals, the nature of the system does not change and further entrenches divide. This shapes a reading experience in which we often observe Gatsby’s plights hopefully, yet recognise the probability of his upcoming demise, as R.W. Stallman describes, this places Gatsby in the position of a “modern Icarus”.
Modern readers, too, share a connection to the determined, yet vain, spirit of Gatsby in chasing the American Dream, an ideal largely recognised now to be an unattainable invention.
In the beginning of World War Two, American life changed exponentially, creating a cultural nostalgia for a lost past echoed in Gatsby’s protestation “Can’t repeat the past? Why of course you can!” Disillusioned soldiers were re-located away from, or lost the lives of, loved ones – this increased receptivity to Gatsby’s idealistic reunion with Daisy and his chasing the symbolic green light, just as soldiers awaited the green light to return home in success. Having Gatsby grow notoriety through his war-time position creates a meta-literary relationship between the author, protagonist, and a large portion of initial readers as soldiers: it redefines the shielded past of Gatsby from a pejorative secret compromising his character to an empathetic recognition of his honour and microcosmic representation of Americans’ struggles.
Though the war ended, its devastation cast a shadow that looms large over the cultural memory of America, darkening with political instability. When Americans experience societal disappointment and frustration, Gatsby is a beacon – not of hope – but of representation for their struggles.
Despite 100 years, Gatsby’s stamp on America is as poignant as ever. The tragedy befalling him is illustrative of the historical hardships America has faced in which he becomes a symbol of America itself whilst acknowledging the gravity of the circumstances that have come to pass; or will. Nonetheless, his optimistic and unheeded approach to barriers contains a spirit that is truly befitting the American ideal.
Image: Paramount Pictures Famous Players-Lasky (Courtesy of Wikimedia Commons)

