Ceasefire: can life begin to be protected in the mist of death?

By Holly Simms

Death in exchange for death, life in exchange for life. How can the value of one human be compared to the value of another? The question of the value, or lack thereof, of human life has characterised much of the conflict between Isreal and Palestine both historically and within the period since the catalyst attack by Hamas on Israel on 7th October 2023.

During the attack in question Hamas seized captivity of 251 hostages and took the lives of 1,200 others; numbers which appear upon first read to amount to incomprehensible loss. However, Isreal’s comprehension of this loss has resulted in a 15-month military offensive which has witnessed the death of 47,460 Palestinians and the total decimation of the land each of these lost souls and their devastated families once called home. Does this Palestinian loss amount to appropriate ‘revenge’ for Isreal? How does Palestine ever process their collective grief as the passage of time, and the ever-present risk of continued violence marches forebodingly on? 

The 19th January saw a monumental step in the answering of both of these questions as a ceasefire agreement was signed. It was agreed that during the first, 42-day, phase of this agreement, Hamas would release 33 hostages, and Isreal would release about 1,900 Palestinian prisoners. Additionally, Isreal agreed their forces would begin to leave populated areas, allowing hundreds of aid lorries into Gaza each day and creating safe passage for displaced civilians to be able to return to their neighbourhoods, or the land where their neighbourhoods may have once stood. 

How does Palestine ever process its collective grief as the passage of time, and the ever-present risk of continued violence marches forebodingly on? 

Unsurprisingly, the enaction of these terms has not been without its tensions thus far as the media has loomed, omnipresent, desperate to capture a glimpse of the hostages and to photographically invade the most intimate moments of these families lives. 18 hostages have so far been returned to their families, with the latest exchange, occurring on February 1st, seeing three hostages, Ofer Kalderon, Yarden Bibas, and US-Israeli Keith Siegel, released for the return of 138 Palestinian prisoners. First to emerge holding their certificates of release were Kalderon and Bibas in Khan Younis, with Siegel’s release due to occur hours later in Gaza City. The first men’s tightly choreographed handover saw lines of heavily armed men holding off crowds as the newly released individuals were obliged to wave to crowds from a stage as officials from the International Committee of the Red Cross were sighted handling the paperwork. It is an image impossible to conjure without thoughts of disquieting dystopia. 

This theatrical dance was a deliberate response from Hamas following a differently alarming exchange a matter of days prior in which the safety of the hostages was brought into question as crowds clamoured and caterwauled among scenes of weak security. Mr Netanyahu, Isreal’s Prime mister, responded to these scenes, creating questions over whether or not hostage exchanges could continue to take places following this “shocking” scene, claiming, “this is additional proof of the inconceivable brutality of the Hamas terrorist organization.” But now, following these two, profoundly differing scenes of release, we are left wondering, what is really more ‘shocking’? A tumultuous crowing encircling the previously imprisoned or a pseudo stage show encouraging a sensationalised, Hollywood reminiscent outlook on a horrifying reality? 

Lives continue to be used as bargaining chips in this deadly game of chess

Additionally, as Mr Netanyahu has been bashing Hamas’ hostage release security, the Gaza Government media office has been levelling worrying accusations back at his state. On February 3rd it was stated, “Despite clear agreements outlined in the humanitarian protocol of the ceasefire deal, Israel has failed to meet its commitments and continues to obstruct humanitarian aid deliveries.” The commitments in question were the entry of 60,000 prefabricated shelters and 200,00 temporary tents to house displaced Palestinians, as well as 600 daily aid trucks, 50 of which would carry fuel and gas.  An alleged reneging on these commitments has caused Gaza’s government to turn to ceasefire mediator states, Qatar, the US and Egypt, asking for pressure on Isreal to comply immediately to the agreed terms.

Humanitarian concerns already emerging on both sides of the agreement, within the return of the hostages for Isreal and the provision of aid for Gaza suggests a tumultuous future for the ceasefire agreement as lives continue to be used as bargaining chips in this deadly game of chess. Within Mr Netanyahu due to meet with President Trump on Tuesday 4th to discuss the progress of the ceasefire, it is impossible not to send wishes for the President to not further hinder this already tenuous project. We can live in hope that the new President’s egoistical desire to claim responsibility for the success of the ceasefire will allow him to push Mr Netanyahu to continue to comply, preventing further bloodshed and allowing for the safe return of all imprisoned persons. 

Image: Danny W via Wikimedia Commons

https://www.justgiving.com/campaign/palatinate?utm_campaign=lc_frp_share_transaction_charity_coaching_--_page_launched_--_campaign&utm_content=463e110f-8393-4efd-8337-cb4bdccc2a99&utm_medium=email&utm_source=postoffice&utm_term=1698322587440