Catholicism should not influence Irish abortion law
“This is a catholic country.” These were the words spoken to Savita Halappanavar and her husband Praveen as the couple beseeched doctors at Galway University Hospital with requests for a medically induced abortion. Savita, an Indian national, was not a Catholic, but due to Ireland’s institutional Catholicism, the termination of her 17-week-long pregnancy was refused. Consequently Savita suffered a miscarriage, became septic and died shortly afterwards. She was 31.
Following the tragedy, Ireland’s medieval abortion laws have come under fire. There have been wide-scale protests in Ireland. Indian officials have voiced their anger at what the Indian Times referred to as her “murder”.
Of course abortion is a social issue and not solely a matter of personal preference. However, religion should not be taken as prerequisite for remaining cautious on the question of pregnancy termination. Most humanists would say that every effort should be made to ensure that the life of an unborn child is preserved. Many would also argue that an unborn foetus possesses something akin to the right to life.
The reason the debate in Ireland (and the US) has been so impassioned is that both camps have the luxury of a strong argument at their disposal. However, in Ireland the only reason for the continuation of their abortion laws is the politicisation of Catholicism. This immediately shatters any possibility for serious discussion.
Of its countless sins, arguably its most down-right wicked has been the Catholic Church’s obsessive interference with its subjects’ sex lives, most notably its rigid prohibition of contraception and abortion. There is no need to go into detail, yet again, of the historic crimes against humanity committed by the Papacy. But it does not take much research to discover that the Papacy’s endorsement of Catholic cults in many parts of Africa has led to death on a hideous scale.
On a more basic level, the evident contradictions within condemning the termination of a pregnancy and simultaneously submitting to an omnipotent God reduce the Catholic Church’s stance to absurdity. To many Irish Catholics the Pope is both a political figure as well as God’s vicar on earth and they will diligently obey him until Christ’s second coming. To others he represents danger and cruelty; no Papal declaration should ever be allowed to make its way into the arena of a state’s democratic legislative process.
The problems of basing law on divinity are highly conspicuous. In Iran, a woman who is a virgin cannot be sentenced to death, even if she has committed a ‘capital’ crime such as showing her hair too often, or perhaps her limbs. Religious law says that she can be raped by the Revolutionary Guard, and then put to death once she is no longer a virgin.
Divine permission given to people who believe that they have God on their side enables actions that a typical moral non-believer would unlikely contemplate; for instance, refusing Savita Halappanavar a likely life-saving abortion. Other examples include the compulsory circumcision of new born babies in the Jewish and Muslim faiths. Without faith, other reasons to prompt the circumcision of babies become unclear. It seems to me that religion prescribes irrational and immoral actions based on alleged divinity.
On 30th April 2008, the Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights recommended that the Irish Government clarify the circumstances in which abortions can be carried out legally.
In essence, the Irish government must now make a choice. Either they adopt the Catholic position and accept Savita Halappanavar’s death as part of God’s plan and pray for her safe passage through the gates of St. Peter; or they swallow their pride, condemn the country’s out-dated Papal laws, and follow the example of King Henry VIII of England and acknowledge that legislation should be formulated domestically and uninfluenced by the draconian and undemocratic Papacy.
As a repost to this, one might say that Ireland’s population is overwhelmingly Catholic and so the current law is domestically focused. This is not a true reflection of Ireland. The huge demonstrations of solidarity in opposition to the law, and in mourning for the avoidable death of Savita Halappanavar paint the real portrait of contemporary Irish society as a whole. I would not insult the Irish people by doubting their freedom and soundness of mind, and I will credit them with my conviction that they are, ultimately, no slaves to the Roman Catholic Church.

