Casual fans or college ultras: does the Floodlit drinking ban work?

By Caleb Tutt

When I’m down bad and trying to impress, I often try to subtly bring up the fact that I’m the Club Captain of my College Rugby Club. It smacks of arrogance and always has the opposite effect. Whilst I mistakenly think it gives me some veneer of status, it mainly just gives me a proverbial pile of emails on rules, regulations and parameters for day-to-day college sport.

In my most recent reading of the Riot Act, the issue of behaviour at Floodlit matches has appeared frequently. Rules are clear: no alcohol, no offensive chants, no public urination. Essentially, the closer the crowd can get to resembling that of Wii Sports Tennis, the better. But why do these rules exist? And do they really work?

The rules have credible foundations. Attendance bans last year for Hatfield, Van Mildert and University College were in response to some pretty colourful crowd behaviour. With a curse-laden tapestry of chants alleging paedophilia and sexual assault, it’s clear this isn’t the nicest environment for sports spectators, let alone the poor lot playing. This behaviour is nothing new. I occasionally receive emails about unsavoury fan conduct, but few are followed up seeing as all supporters seem as guilty as one another.

So is alcohol a factor? Well yes. Alcohol makes you do obnoxious things. I hardly need to spell that out to university students, let alone myself. This manifests into crowds more lively than Maiden Castle (MC) may anticipate. But a blanket ban on alcohol is reductive and showcases naiveté on behalf of the University.

Just as certain as death and taxes, so is student drinking.

the ban has precipitated a culture wherein getting drunk beforehand and stumbling down the road to MC is the done thing

Preventing drinking outright would be as effective as US prohibition (not effective at all). Instead of students drinking steadily at fixtures, the ban has precipitated a culture wherein getting drunk beforehand and stumbling down the road to MC is the done thing. For those who want a drink, this is the only option. There was an offer of buying alcohol at the MC bar. At best, this would price out students who wanted to enjoy their match with a reasonably priced pint but considering all alcohol has been seized on entry to matches, the drunken foxtrot down the A177 is all that remains.

This is not a sustainable plan from the University and points to simplistic solutions to more endemic problems. College sport receives nowhere near the attention that it should from the university. This is clear to anyone who has peeped behind the curtains into the machinery of college sport this year. With a long-winded booking crisis, as well as league structures that give some clubs very few fixtures, college sport has definitely had a difficult year.

College rivalry is more profound than people may think, and sport is undoubtably the main arena for this competition. Floodlit matches are far and few between for many college sports clubs, so students would be perfectly in place to make the most of them, often with a drink in hand. Whilst alcohol does amplify poor conduct at matches, this doesn’t shirk the fact that once a precedent of offside chat has been set by one set of supporters, it’s hard to get the cat back in the bag. This has happened even with the alcohol ban in place. 96% of students who admitted to bringing alcohol to matches also reported remaining undetected.

So, with security about as booze-tight as a sieve, what is to be done?

My solution is boringly predictable. Invest more into college sport. People love it. It provides purpose and belonging to so many at the university, whether in the thick of the action or on the touchlines.

Let the players play, let the spectators drink, and let only the wrongdoers head home early

The university is all too ready to invest speculatively in new colleges and facilities, and also sits on a bank of retained striking staff salaries. College sport is aching for some investment. Channelling this into security who could ensure floodlit drinking was done safely and provide a sufficient deterrent to drunkenness would remedy our issue.

College sport is something unique that makes this university fantastic. It ought to be given the investment and security attention it so clearly needs. Let the players play, let the spectators drink, and let only the wrongdoers head home early. An alcohol ban won’t stop poor conduct. Investing in security will. If the university genuinely cared about this, it would devise a slightly more respectful plan. It may as well gift some much-deserved respect to college sport whilst it’s at it.

Photography: CCRFC Instagram @officialccrfc