Casting in theatre: the gender divide

Lydia Feerick and Serena Gosling in Fourth Wall's 'Our Country's Good', in which many actors played two parts, with gender blind casting for many of the roles.
Lydia Feerick and Serena Gosling in Fourth Wall’s ‘Our Country’s Good’, in which many actors played two parts, with gender blind casting for many of the roles.

Simon Fearn considers whether Durham is doing enough to address the gender divide in casting, which is so vastly present in theatre as a whole.

It’s the start of a new year for Durham student theatre, and an exciting time to try out new approaches and build upon the successes of last year. As we speak, a new raft of theatrical first years are preparing to take to the stage, champing at the bit to be unleashed upon The Assembly Rooms. But for many new Durham actresses, frustrating times lie ahead. They will, rather unjustly, be forced to compete for a limited number of multi-dimensional female parts, compared with much richer pickings for their male counterparts.

The problem is a national one, recently brought to attention by actress and ex-Labour MP Glenda Jackson. In an impassioned plea, Jackson asks “where have been the remarkable new plays which have women as the driving engine?” She has called for modern playwrights to address the gender imbalance and provide actresses with complex and fulfilling roles: “it can’t be that they [playwrights] haven’t heard these cries of anguish rolling around for decades.”

Jackson’s sense of injustice is strongly supported by the figures. A 2012 report by Elizabeth Freestone in partnership with The Guardian revealed that, in the top ten subsidised theatres in the UK, only 38% of the actors employed were female. This is both deeply unfair, and baffling considering that 68% of theatregoers are women (according to a 2010 Ipsos Mori survey). How is it that this largely female audience is still presented with a world skewed towards male experience, with women relegated to the sidelines?

I spoke to three second year actresses who shared their experience of the Durham theatre scene. “There are so many good female actresses for comparatively few female roles,” explained one of the actresses, “especially leads”. Even the female roles available leave something to be desired. “What can often occur in plays and musicals is that the lead female role is reduced to just that – the female role,” lamented another second year. “The character is there only to support the male lead; to simply be the love interest, or used as a device to show another level to the male role.”

It’s easy to see why these women are frustrated. Durham Student Theatre (DST) admittedly can’t do much about the historic shortage of female characters in British theatre, but sometimes Durham theatre companies could be more sensitive in their choice of plays. For example, Death of a Salesman was a questionable choice for the Freshers’ Play. The production was meant to be showcasing the talent of first year actors, so it seems highly unfair that there were three meaty roles for men (Willy, Biff and Happy) and only one similarly complex female character (Linda). The production team even had to hold a second round of male-only auditions to fill Miller’s male-heavy supporting roles.

Then there was last year’s Durham Drama Festival, which also attracted criticism for a scarcity of female parts. One of the actresses I spoke to remarked that although the vast majority of the writers involved were women, the plays either had an equal male/female split or a male lead, overall resulting in actresses losing out to male students. Of course, this is hardly the fault of the writers involved, but saying this it would be nice to see some plays with women as the driving force in this year’s competition.

Abigail Weinstock in Ooook! Productions' 'Yes, Prime Minister'. Weinstock was cast gender blind and was critically well recieved as being very effective in her role as Bernard.
Abigail Weinstock in Ooook! Productions’ ‘Yes, Prime Minister’. Weinstock was cast gender blind and was critically well received as being very effective in her role as Bernard.

Despite all of this, it’s also important to give credit where it’s due. One of the actresses interviewed was largely positive about Durham’s efforts to correct theatre’s gender imbalance. “Durham has recognised the fact there are a greater number of females interested in acting than males,” she told me, “hence we have seen a lot of gender-blind roles, such as in Ooook!’s Yes, Prime Minister, and also plays like Lion Theatre Company’s The Children’s Hour, which was a completely female cast, bar two men”. There is also a positive outlook for the coming year, with plays such as Woman in Mind, Miss Julie and That Face offering central female roles. A lot of theatre companies in Durham are admirably sensitive about the need to counter theatre’s bias towards male roles, but there is still much that needs to be done before we can be confident that all our actors have equal opportunities.

Durham can’t do much to alter the fact that the accepted theatrical canon primarily consists of men writing about men: for example, only 13% of Shakespearean roles with 500 lines or more are female. But what we can do is to think more carefully about the plays we choose to produce, and provide new takes on established classics like Shakespeare via gender blind casting. We can also bring an awareness of the gender imbalance to our original plays in the 2016 Drama Festival, and provide opportunities for more of our extremely talented actresses to establish themselves in the Durham theatre scene.

Durham can’t do much to alter the fact that the accepted theatrical canon primarily consists of men writing about men: for example, only 13% of Shakespearean roles with 500 lines or more are female. But what we can do is to think more carefully about the plays we choose to produce, and provide new takes on established classics like Shakespeare via gender blind casting. We can also bring an awareness of the gender imbalance to our original plays in the 2016 Drama Festival, and provide opportunities for more of our extremely talented actresses to establish themselves in the Durham theatre scene.

Unless we do more to counter theatre’s widespread gender bias, we condemn ourselves to productions of a much lesser calibre. Theatre cannot create an accurate representation of all human experience if it focuses exclusively on male experience. On top of this, talented actresses forfeit the best roles to potentially less talented male contemporaries, who do not have to endure such fierce competition.

I leave the last word to actor, writer and director Stella Duffy, who wrote an impassioned blogpost condemning the treatment of women in theatre. “We have a responsibility to make the world a fairer place,” she writes, “and sometimes you have to do a little social engineering to make that happen.” This is a message Durham Student Theatre ought to take to heart.

Photographs: Samuel Kirkman