Cancer is “mainly bad luck”: why the media needs to stop misinterpreting science and get a clue

cancer_400x600

By Bryony Hockin

Let’s be honest, no one wants cancer. It’s not a fun experience.

Unfortunately, it’s quite common, and now, in our age of modern technology, everyone is convinced that we should be able to get rid of it as easily as we eradicated smallpox.

When it comes to the media’s attitudes towards the scientists working on this truly enormous problem, opinions tend to wildly vary between thinking that all scientists are magical wizards or that all scientists are idiots and we shouldn’t believe a word they say.

As a scientist myself, I’d like to say that we are somewhere in between those two ridiculous extremes. Yet this weird mixture of blind faith and utter mistrust of science by the media (and by extension the general public) gives rise to some utterly baffling headlines.

Take an example from just a few weeks ago; presumably on a slow news day, some bright spark at a popular news outlet that I shan’t name dug up a recent paper from Johns Hopkins University which suggests that most types of cancer are actually attributable to random mutations in DNA.

The media decided to top this with a headline claiming that two-thirds of cancer cases are down to “bad luck”. Not only is this an incredibly badly worded headline, it’s also crucially only based on a single, recently published paper. In the field of medical science, cancer is one of the most widely studied areas of all, and there are thousands of different conflicting theories about its causes.

As any science student knows, papers such as this one should be read with a critical eye, certainly until more evidence and other independent studies can verify the results.

Having had a quick look at the data myself, I can say with absolute certainty that the two-thirds figure was plucked from thin air, and furthermore the actual data is shaky at best.

The authors suggest that the lifetime risk of diagnosis with organ-specific cancers is not entirely down to environmental and hereditary factors; depending on the organ, some or most of the risk could be down to random genetic mutations.

The research claims that some tissue types (e.g. the intestine) are more likely to develop mutations than others (e.g. the brain), and therefore that certain cancer types are naturally more prevalent. So for example, a tissue that replicates more cells in its lifetime, such as the colorectal tissue, is more likely to develop mutations and hence has a greater lifetime risk of cancer.

This is a perfectly reasonable claim to make, and is pretty obvious to anyone with a background in medical science, but the conclusions drawn from it should be taken with a pinch of salt.

For all that newspaper headlines blare about X or Y causing cancer, the truth is that we don’t actually know all that much about it. We may think immediately of examples such as smoking causing lung cancer, but in fact carcinogens (cancer-causing agents) exist all over our planet, and in the unlikeliest of places.

Although the first carcinogenic compounds discovered were found in sites of industry such as mines and chemical plants, it is now clear that our entire lifestyle is filled with them.

Almost everything we eat contains carcinogens; meat and fish produce carcinogenic heterocyclic amines when cooked, while excess salt and fat in our diets have long been attributed to increased rates of cancer. A lot of common cosmetic ingredients have been suggested as being potentially carcinogenic; the most widely publicised being parabens, which have been rather dubiously linked to breast cancer.

Should we be worried by this? In the grand scheme of things, probably not. While cancer is an unpleasant and scary topic, it’s also mostly treatable in this day and age. So long as we try to stay relatively healthy and are aware of genetic risk factors, there isn’t too much to worry about.

As for the unfortunate headline choice picked by news-starved media outlets, it would perhaps be best if science and health journalists did their research before they crow their idiocy from the rooftops.

Photograph: Cory Doctorow on flickr