Canada votes
By Bryn Evans
For what was dubbed Canada’s “most uncertain federal election in decades” by Maclean’s Magazine during the lead-up to voting day, the results of the October 21st Canadian election were far from staggering.
Uncertainty stemmed in part from the fact that Canada’s 43rd federal election was one which all major parties entered with soaring expectations. Yet, with an unchanging 338 seats in the House of Commons, it goes without saying that at least some of these expectations would be converted to disappointment on election day.
Conservative party leader Andrew Scheer believed that a campaign based around drawing attention to a spell of recent Liberal controversies, preaching affordability for the middle class, and prioritizing economic growth over the environment would be enough to unseat Canada’s strongest majority government in 26 years.
New Democratic Party leader Jagmeet Singh steadily gained popularity throughout the campaign due to his candid demeanour, urging voters to vote on their beliefs rather than against their fears. There was hope that a platform of universal pharmacare, equality and indigenous reconciliation, and climate protection could help propel the NDP back in the direction of the official opposition status it won in 2011.
Campaigning on similar convictions as Singh, but with increased urgency placed on environmental protection, party leader Elizabeth May saw nation-wide climate protests as a sign it was finally time for Canada’s Green Party to take a step forward.
The Liberal Party leader earned the lowest popular vote percentage of any Canadian prime minister in history
Meanwhile, incumbent Prime Minister and Liberal Party leader Justin Trudeau, whose expectations for progress from the last election were likely the most tempered given his existing majority government, sought to retain his governing status based on an oft-attacked “catch-all” platform of equality, affordability, climate protection, and continued economic growth.
Interestingly, dismay came in various sizes for every leader. Scheer had his polarizing tactics firmly rejected by Canadians, failing to take advantage of a middle-left split between several candidates in the same way as his counterpart to Canada’s south. Singh could not translate popular vote to MPs and saw NDP seats nearly halved. May, although she tripled her party’s representation in Parliament, did so by gaining just two seats. In the end, it was Prime Minister Trudeau who suffered the smallest relative disappointment. Amidst recent controversies involving the resignation of Canada’s former Attorney General from the Liberal Party and leaked 2001 photographs of the then-schoolteacher wearing blackface makeup, Trudeau lost 27 MPs but was able to hang on to a minority government. The Liberal Party leader now takes office having earned the lowest popular vote percentage of any Canadian prime minister in history with just 33%.
What, then, does this mean for Canada? Trudeau will be given the go-ahead by Julie Payette, Canada’s Governor-General, to attempt to form a government. It is up to Trudeau whether he will pursue a formal coalition (a legal agreement), a confidence-and-supply agreement (the governing party agrees to a list of priorities in exchange for its partner’s support), or even a case-by-case situation (the governing party makes no agreement with any partner, instead seeking out support on an ad hoc basis).
With a Liberal-Conservative union highly unlikely due to gross disagreements on policy and leadership style, Trudeau may look to Singh’s progressive NDP to help him build a majority in the House of Commons. Although Singh explained during the campaign trail that his main focus was not preparing for a coalition, he did tell reporters that a Liberal-NDP alliance may be possible if the two parties can agree on six key subjects: climate change, pharmacare, interest-free student loans, cellphone bills, affordable housing, and taxing the ‘ultra-rich’.
Blanchet’s Bloc gained surprising support throughout the province
There is also an outside chance that Trudeau approaches Yves-François Blanchet, leader of the Québec-exclusive Bloc Québecois Party. Once a right-wing group staunchly in favour of Québec’s secession from Canada, Blanchet’s Bloc gained surprising support throughout the province on a more moderate platform of simply supporting Québec’s best interests. Blanchet was clear in his campaign that he would not formally associate the Bloc with any minority government, however a confidence-and-supply agreement may still be possible.
Both the NDP and the Bloc hold enough seats in the House of Commons to boost the Liberal Party past the magic 170; whether Trudeau seeks to appeal to a younger, more progressive crowd by siding with Singh or attempts to win back support in his father’s native province by teaming up with Blanchet will likely be at the core of any coalition decision.
Trudeau has told reporters he has no intentions of building a formal coalition
Yet with both of the above options on the table, in his first news conference at the National Press Theatre since being elected, Trudeau told reporters he has no intentions of building a formal coalition. He explained the Liberals instead plan to work closely with other party leaders to advance shared aims. Having won no seats in Tory-ruled Alberta and Saskatchewan and lost key seats to the Conservatives in British Columbia, Trudeau has been clear that he will do more to address the concerns of Canadians living in the country’s West.
A desire to not further alienate western Canadians is likely behind the Prime Minister’s hesitancy to form any coalition with a party not named the Conservatives. As of the present moment, he appears set on continuing with the highly disputed Trans Mountain expansion pipeline project—a controversial choice given that it will serve both to appease Albertan and Saskatchewanian Tories but also to frustrate the more progressive British Columbian population.
With Trudeau having already chosen a similar path to his previous term, it looks unlikely that any significant or immediate political shift occurs from pre-election. While there is greater Conservative Party representation in Parliament, the Canadian Prime Minister is also increasingly likely to be forced to consider the more leftist views of the NDP due to his minority. For now, however, Prime Minister Trudeau can be content that from the spread of losing parties, his party seems to have lost the least.
Image by Maxime Vermeil (@max.vrm) via Unsplash
