Can Sunderland banish their play-off heartache?
By Jack Lawrence
If only Sunderland would play by the book for once. Regarded as perhaps the biggest underachievers in English football at present, no amount of promise or preparation seems to produce the eagerly expected rewards. Eight fixtures into the current League One campaign and the story looks to be the same as last year, which ended in play-off heartache.
The season opened with a couple of pitiful draws before a three-match winning streak was ruptured by a heavy defeat at Peterborough. It was classic Sunderland, laughably predictable in their volatile unpredictability. Of course, Will Grigg has yet to score a league goal, and the team seems entirely incapable of keeping a clean sheet.
The potential for a repeat of last season was certainly there after an off-season which made few waves. This summer’s transfer window should have been defined less by big losses and bulk replacement than simple consolidation and acute improvement of the current crop. In the event, however, first-team regulars Lee Cattermole, Bryan Oviedo and captain George Honeyman all departed and had to be hastily replaced.
In spite of this, there are glimmers of promise in some of the new additions. Bringing in Marc McNulty on loan from Reading certainly didn’t set off any fireworks, but he has managed three goals from seven starts, which may owe something to the total lack of expectation on his shoulders.
Jordan Willis from Coventry seems a shrewd acquisition too, adding much-needed pace to what was an agonisingly slow backline last season. Likewise, George Dobson is cast much in the same mould as last year’s star youngster Luke O’Nien: an impressive lower-league prodigy whose hunger and tenacity will hopefully stand him in good stead.
The 3-1 win against Burnley in the EFL Cup proved Jack Ross’ side have the ability to play well above the expected without external pressures on them
Manager Jack Ross seemed keen to throw the new boys straight in during pre-season, seeking to accommodate them in a new 3-4-3 formation which had worked for him during his title-winning final season at St Mirren two years ago. The idea behind this tactical rethink was that it would make the team more ruthless in numbers up front, deploying star men Aiden McGeady and Chris Maguire as roaming inside forwards. In theory, it would also strengthen the defence through the ability to shift to a flat back four when on the back foot.
Two games into the season proper and Jack Ross reneged on the system. The team looked unthreatening up front, weak in midfield, and all over the place at the back, and Ross quickly lost confidence in its abilities. The plan after this was to revert back to the 4-2-3-1 setup used for much of last year, which seemed to get McGeady and Maguire firing, before the drubbing by Peterborough prompted another change of heart. Since then, Ross’ tactics have been hard to pin down.
An unsatisfying draw at home to Rotherham forced him to explain his thinking in what was an unorthodox performance from the Black Cats. “We wanted to play a bit differently tonight,” he said, drawing on the fact that the players had booted the ball long all game in a bid to catch the opposition off guard. This may have worked in producing a first minute route one goal, but the element of surprise tends to wear off if you carry on the same way for 90 minutes, hence Rotherham’s gradual shoring up and subsequent equaliser.
However, the blame must not sit wholly on Ross’ shoulders. The Scot is under immense pressure with the failure of last season hanging over every performance. The imminent arrival of new billionaire owners doesn’t help his cause either; Sam Allardyce is reportedly waiting in the wings if a change of management is desired.
What does work in Jack Ross’ favour is the 3-1 victory over Premier League outfit Burnley in the EFL Cup which commentators have inexplicably underplayed. The game demonstrated that Sunderland have the ability to play well above the expected when all outside pressures are shed. This was the first time the team had faced Premier League opposition since their relegation from the top division in 2017, and so there was nothing to lose as they made short work of a decent Burnley side.
In the league, with those external pressures back on, Sunderland’s best hope is to find some form of stability. Perhaps Ross is being a little bit too clever at this point. Sunderland would probably have a better chance of clinching the League One title by ditching possession stats, setting up in a 4-4-2 formation, and playing counterattacking football. They certainly have the personnel for that; whether the players Ross has at his disposal are good enough to execute what he currently wants is less certain.
What is certain is that the reactionary tactical policy needs to be abandoned for a set formula that can be relied upon every week, and improved upon as the campaign progresses. Just keeping the team the same for a number of weeks may well be the making of Sunderland’s season. Perhaps then they can set Will Grigg on fire again.
Photograph by Ronnie Macdonald via Flickr
