Can Republicans topple Trump?

By Edward Goodger

The battle over the political future of the United States is once again heating up. The Democrats now have twelve major presidential contenders. Among them are six Senators, two Representatives and a former cabinet member. This quixotic bunch, ranging from moderate to radical, have begun receiving substantial media attention and attracted the hopes and donations of many anti-Trump Americans.

With this focus on the Democrats, seemingly forgotten is the Republican nomination battle. No incumbent President has been beaten for their party’s nomination since Chester Arthur in 1884. In all likelihood, Trump will easily be re-nominated.

After defeating a primary challenger they have often failed when seeking a second term in the White House.

But that is beside the point. History shows that once a sitting President is challenged for their party’s nomination, even having defeated these challenges they remain critically weakened and their party divided. Subsequently, they have often failed when seeking another term in the White House.

There was Ronald Reagan’s 1976 challenge to incumbent President Gerald Ford. Reagan split the nominating convention that year, coming close to toppling Ford. Despite narrow defeat, the damage Reagan did to Ford set the President’s campaign back in a tight race with Jimmy Carter. Ford lost to Carter, meaning again a primary challenge helped scupper a president’s re-election hopes.

Another example is Ted Kennedy’s challenge to Jimmy Carter in 1980. Winning 38% of the vote, Kennedy’s campaign embarrassed the already weakened President Carter, and split the Democratic Party in their race against the resurgent Reagan in his comeback campaign. Carter was defeated by a landslide.

There are many examples of primary challenges to incumbent presidents. Having faced down their challengers, these presidents fell to defeats once pitched against the opposing party in the general election. Those wishing an end to the Trump presidency should be hoping for a major candidate to challenge ‘The Donald’ for the Republican nomination.

Weld is an out of fashion liberal in a rigidly conservative Republican Party.

Enter William Weld.

Enter William Weld

Weld is unlikely to be known to many. He was a Vice-Presidential candidate in 2016, but for the Libertarian Party. He has been a two-term Governor of Massachusetts, but in the 1990s. He’s also an out-of-fashion liberal in a rigidly conservative Republican Party. He’s pro-drug, pro-choice and pro-gay marriage. In sum, a recent Republican returnee, with liberal beliefs, and out of political office for decades. He has no realistic chance of winning the Republican nomination. Weld himself must know this.

However, the futility of this kind of campaign doesn’t matter.

Those wishing an end to the Trump Presidency should be hoping for a major candidate to challenge ‘The Donald’ for the Republican nomination.

Provided Weld puts together a semi-prominent challenge, could he damage Trump’s re-election hopes? In fact, Weld may just be the first of several Republicans to challenge Trump for the nomination. At least three other Republicans who may join Weld in challenging Trump.

Larry Hogan, the popular Governor of Maryland decried the ‘debilitating politics’ of Washington in his re-inauguration speech last month. Appeals to break partisan lines to oppose the embattled President were also made in that speech. As a Republican governor, with high approval ratings, in a state that has voted for Democratic candidate in every presidential election since 1992, Hogan could be a formidable opponent for Trump should he start campaigning. 

As a Republican governor with high approval ratings, Hogan could be a formidable opponent for Trump should he start campaigning.

Former Senator Bob Corker has explicitly not ruled out challenging Trump for the Republican nomination. Appearing as a foil to Trump while serving as Senator for Tennessee, Corker could reignite old battles against Trump with a Presidential campaign. Characterised by President Trump as ‘Little Bob Corker’ just last year, the idea of challenging the President for the Republican nomination must seem like a tantalising prospect for Corker.

Former Ohio Governor, John Kasich, has also been raised as a potential Republican challenger to Trump. Having run against Trump in the 2016 Republican Primaries, Kasich may wish for a second attempt at the party’s nomination. When asked whether he would run for President in 2020, Kasich replied that he was seriously considering another campaign.

With the potential for a wider field of Republican challengers to Trump in 2020, perhaps it would be wrong to ignore the Republican Primaries and focus solely on the Democrats. These challengers may even end up threatening President Trump’s chance of a second term. As the records show, challenges to the President for their party’s nomination can leave the incumbent critically weakened, and ultimately herald their defeat. A weakened Trump, distracted by Republican challengers, may all but guarantee the Democrats retake the Presidency in 2020.

Republican National Convention Image: PBS NewsHour via Flickr
William Weld Image: Gage Skidmore via Flickr
Trump Image: Shealah Craighead via Wikimedia Commons