Can art ever truly be separated from the artist?
Content warning: this article contains discussion of sexual assault.
By Hannah Thompson
It is a question that resurfaces every time the behaviour or opinions of a much-beloved celebrity, whether they be a singer, an author or actor, is revealed to be controversial…if not unacceptable. It is a question that has once again become relevant in the wake of the sexual assault allegations faced by singer Alexander O’Connor, better known under the moniker Rex Orange County.
After having cancelled the remainder of his tour in July of this year due to “unforeseen personal circumstances” — something which left many of his adoring fans bereft — it has now emerged exactly what these circumstances were, with the ‘Loving is Easy’ singer recently having been charged with six counts of sexual assault dating back to 2021. O’Connor denies the allegations and is awaiting trial, which has been provisionally scheduled for January 2023.
I considered myself to be a fan of Rex Orange County’s music, with his songs previously making regular appearances in my monthly-curated playlists. However, since the emergence of these allegations, the first thing I did, without giving it a second thought, was to remove these songs from my Spotify playlists.
since the emergence of these allegations, the first thing I did, without giving it a second thought, was to remove these songs from my Spotify playlists
For me, this decision was easy and, not as many would think, a consequence of so-called ‘cancel culture’; I know I will never be able to listen to his songs again without these allegations being at the forefront of my mind. In my eyes, his music will forever be sullied. Not only that, but I find it distasteful to continue to line the pockets of an alleged abuser by actively streaming his songs.
Nevertheless, it is not so black and white for some, and I am not one to tell others what music they can consume. Ultimately, it is an individual choice as to whether you are able to successfully separate the art from the artist and to continue listening to hits such as ‘It’s Not The Same Anymore’ and ‘Corduroy Dreams’.
Perhaps, it is the time to move away from the almost hero worship that many celebrities receive?
Of course, the charges faced by O’Connor do not mean his music is no longer good with everyone, as evidenced by the outpouring of reactions on Twitter as people credited his music with helping them through tough times in their lives. It is understandable therefore why these people would have a difficulty in reconciling the idea of an artist they idolised as an abuser. Perhaps, it is the time to move away from the almost hero worship that many celebrities receive? At the end of the day, we are not privy to the real person behind the celebrity façade, no matter how well we fancy ourselves to know our favourite artists.
No doubt people are reading this and thinking that I should await next year’s trial before striking Rex Orange County from all my playlists — after all is it not of the utmost importance to adhere to the idea of ‘innocent until proven guilty’? To this I would say that to believe this is to have too much faith in our justice system. It is well evidenced that of the disproportionately low number of sexual assault and rape cases brought to court, even fewer result in criminal charges, especially in cases such as these where the alleged perpetrator holds a position of influence. Even if the trial were to result in O’Connor successfully clearing his name, it would be naïve of me to be able to return to listening to his music as before.
At the end of the day, it is a personal choice whether you are going to continue to listen to Rex Orange County despite these allegations, however, it is obvious that it is high time to start holding abusers, particularly men in a position of power, accountable for their actions. One way to help us on our way to achieve this goal is to stop hiding behind the excuse of separating art from the artist as justification for a few catchy songs on a Spotify Wrapped playlist.
Image: Kelli Rothwell via Flickr

