Bycatch by Caroline Smith: Forward Poetry Prize review
By Andreea Goian
In ‘Bycatch’, Caroline Smith depicts the tender and heartbreaking onset of dementia in those you hold most dear to you. In the ensuing poems, Smith uses the sea to illuminate the thrashing waves of pain, grief, and memory that come and go day by day for her father. This is a touching series of poems which reaches deep into your soul to pull on your heartstrings.
The opening poem, entitled ‘Noah’, sets the open water theme which ties all the poems together.
“I chart my parents’ decline
Bycatch by Caroline Smith
by how far the answering machine gets
before one of them reaches the phone.”
As it begins, the image of the speaker — Smith herself — as a sailor charting the waters and exploring unknown territory brings the reader immediately into the fold of the perilous waters. The poem concludes on a melancholy note, yet one dares to hope alongside the speaker that there are better days to come. Just like in the biblical story, Noah survives with his Ark, bearing the weight of all that he has had to leave behind.
“The distances they could walk
Bycatch by Caroline Smith
just a few months ago,
are now an ocean for them to cross.
And I am Noah, waiting for their call back.
I’ve sent out a dove to find land.
One day it won’t return.”
There is an inevitability to these poems, yet Smith inspires some hope in the reader that the good memories will last forever. Indeed, in ‘White Out’, the speaker’s mother talks about ‘normal’ in the same way that the snow will lift and reveal the same old grass. The longing for normalcy in this anthology is offset by the unpredictable and chaotic nature of the ocean imagery Smith’s family seems to be at odds with. Nothing is truly capable of combatting the unstoppable force of nature, just as there permeates a sense of helplessness in the speaker’s actions towards her father’s declining memory.
The continuous dehumanisation of the speaker’s parents highlights the utterly ableist society we live in today. Smith’s father is treated with no agency, as her mother’s declining health means nothing but an inconvenience to the carers that see her daily.
In ‘Printer’, her father is compared to the printer that randomly starts up during the day only to settle back down again – the same way her father starts to grapple out of bed throughout the day only to lose energy and lay back down. The comparison of a living, breathing human being to an inanimate object which not only has no agency but is portrayed as pointless (its lack of purpose is transferred to the speaker’s father) creates a heartbreaking image of inhuman treatment. Similarly, in Hope, Smith depicts the careless carers that look after her mother:
“Yesterday the carer left my mother’s walker out of her reach.”
Bycatch by Caroline Smith
The line break here communicates the rage and frustration at her mother’s carer, and the reader shares this with the speaker. The pause – almost like a deep breath taken or a change of tone – is viscerally felt in the reader’s bones. To treat someone so inhumanely when you are there to care for them is horrible and this is where the devastation of the speaker is really felt.
Smith comments that: “It was a challenge writing about someone so close to me… It was essential to have space and distance between the poet and the subject, to allow the poem to stand free of my own feelings. I knew the collection would only work if it resonated with others and their experience.”
In the collection this is a striking pattern where the speaker’s father is personal yet symbolic. He pointedly does not become a beacon or an anonymous martyr, but instead a vessel for the reader to fill with their own experience. Smith’s observation that the collection needed “enough detail for my father to come alive as a person prior to his dementia, but not to become a personal album” is one that perfectly exemplifies the nuance and delicacy with which this collection is handled. Caroline Smith’s beautiful poems resonate long and hard after they have been absorbed.
This truly is a collection that will make you grieve and hope alongside the speaker; it discusses questions of personhood, memory, and dignity, and opens chasms of compassion and empathy. Praised for its being “tender without sentimentality, stunning in the everyday”, this collection touches and fundamentally changes its readers.
Image Credit: Félix Vallotton

