Broad and Anderson: the beginning of the end?

By William Thurtle

“In respect of James Anderson and Stuart Broad, I want to emphasise this does not mean the end for them as England players.”

It was perhaps to be expected that players would be axed following the Ashes thrashing this winter. However, when it emerged that not one, but two of England’s most prolific seam bowlers over the past decade had been dropped for the forthcoming tour of the West Indies, the cricketing world stopped in its tracks.

Many have expressed feelings of shock and bewilderment after the announcement of interim ECB managing director Sir Andrew Strauss. Others feel that this will be a welcome opportunity for the mantle to now fall on new shoulders.

Admittedly, Broad (35) and Anderson (39) won’t go on forever, despite their ageless Benjamin Button-like characteristics. The pair are nearing an astonishing 1,200 wickets between them, and have been central to the success of numerous series since they first burst onto the scene.

They aren’t showing any signs of slowing down either: Anderson has taken a staggering 160 wickets in 44 tests since turning 35, at an average of 21.72. The ‘King of Swing’ again came back home from Down Under with the best average of any English bowler.

After being trounced Down Under, is now really the time to experiment?

Like any fine vintage, he has matured well with age. What makes Anderson, and Broad for that matter, priceless is the fact that they are the last of their kind, effectively the endangered species in the realm of Test match cricket.

In an age where white ball cricket threatens to eliminate that good old fashioned ‘line and length’ bowling, the swing merchant duo have continued to be the cornerstones of England’s attack for well over a decade.

So, after being trounced Down Under, is now really the time to experiment, when a series victory is exactly what this current England side need? It’s a bold call by Strauss to ditch the most talismanic bowlers the country has ever produced in such troublesome times.

Boarding the plane to the Caribbean as seaming options instead will be debutants Saqib Mahmood (24) and Matthew Fisher (24), Craig Overton (27), Ollie Robinson (28), Ben Stokes (30), Chris Woakes (33) and Durham speedster Mark Wood (32).

It seems as if Chris Woakes will be the leading senior bowler for the upcoming series, and he will have big shoes to fill. Woakes however averages 52.38 away from favourable home conditions, which does raise a few alarm bells.

Mark Wood meanwhile may have been one of the only positives of the recent Ashes, and has certainly earned his place on the plane. He was the most prolific English bowler during the series, taking 17 wickets which culminated with a deserved 6-fer in Hobart.

This does have a feeling of the beginning of the final chapter for Anderson and Broad

Ollie Robinson is another who impressed in 2021, and deserves a chance in the West Indies too. This comes despite controversy surrounding his fitness to play Test match cricket, with England bowling coach Jon Lewis urging Robinson to ‘improve his fitness’ during the Ashes. 

Considering that Anderson models himself as the Tom Brady of cricket, why drop him now when he has so much more to offer, and is still performing at the very highest level?

Even more perplexing is Strauss’s call for a “reset” of the Test team. Woakes, Robinson and Wood fronted the England attack for the first test in the Gabba, where Broad and Anderson were omitted from the starting XI. Why will this attack now succeed in the Caribbean?

As heart-breaking as it is for all English cricket supporters, this does have a feeling of the beginning of the final chapter for Anderson and Broad. 

To omit both from the West Indies tour profits neither the English team nor the debutant bowlers in Mahmood and Fisher, who would have benefited from touring with either of Anderson or Broad’s guile and know-how abroad.

As a long-time admirer of both bowlers, I for one hope that this is not the end for either.

It would be a reassuring sight to see unknowing batsmen bamboozled by the familiar faces of Jimmy and Stuart for a little while longer.

Image: Naparazzi via Flickr