Britain must learn from the German education system

By Alex Samuels

Often it takes going away to better understand the place you came from. I have been studying at Heidelberg University, in southern Germany, for six weeks now, and in that time I have come to admire a university that is cheaper, stronger and fairer than the one I know at home.

I am a second year English student in Durham, and in Heidelberg I’m taking German Literature and Philosophy modules through the Erasmus exchange program. What I have observed of its organisation and social function since I have been here has brought me to see critically much I had before not questioned in terms of the British educational system and Durham’s fulfilment of its duty to the public.

The most immediate difference is the cost of tuition. In Durham, my year’s intake was the first to pay tuition fees at £9000 a year. In Heidelberg, there was a raise in fees around the same time. In December 2012, tuition fees for home students went up from €213 to €253 per year. While a debate over UK tuition fees’ worth to the economy requires a separate article (and someone else to write it), it is necessary for me to approach the topic here, and simply remark how it appears that the fees have a hand in holding Durham back from Heidelberg’s model in various ways.

Foto (3)

One area in which they have an influence is the age at which people start and finish their undergraduate degree. The low cost of tuition in Heidelberg means students can study more slowly and more freely. There is less stigma attached to being older and staying longer as an undergraduate.

The length of time the department recommends for a Bachelor’s degree in Philosophy here is three years, but it is at the discretion of the student how long they want to study. One woman has allegedly been a student at the university, doing various degrees over different lengths of time, since before the fall of the Berlin wall. Obviously this is an extreme case, but it indicates a difference in attitudes.

In England, where the majority of undergraduates come directly from school, there is a pressure-cooker atmosphere that pushes young people on from one station of learning to the next, and before they are able to value it, they have reached the destination and have graduated.

Some take a gap year before university, but the belief in the necessity of a period of maturation before higher education starts, where school-leavers take a year or two to let their ambitions take shape and crucially to let them develop, change and re-form, is far less prevalent among the British people I know than it seems to be in Germany.

one woman has allegedly been a student at the university, doing various degrees over different lengths of time, since before the fall of the Berlin wall

The result is that British students make mistakes in their choices, and in the end often lose the time they saved in starting university earlier by changing course. Or, in sticking it out, they are simply unhappy. I count only very few people among my friends at Durham who have not had serious doubts over whether they were studying the right thing.

In defence, the luxury of time is simply not available to UK students anymore. Fees could rise again, and waiting before starting university does not seem financially advisable. But this aversion towards taking your time in the process of education has deeper sources in the British school system. At 16, children are required to near enough determine their entire academic path in choosing A-levels. Reducing the field of study to four (usually three) subjects at an early stage of intellectual development is damaging. There’s a mistaken order of priorities underlying the whole system: it’s not the speed of development towards specialization that should be put first; at school it should be the breadth of development across all fields, and only later – at university – the depth.

The German equivalent to A-levels, the Abitur, has a broader reach, similar to the International Baccalaureate, requiring at least one science subject, one foreign language, German itself, one humanities subject and one creative subject – Music, Art or Drama.

When it comes to the transition from school to university, the approach is again more suited to the development of the young person as a whole. Until 2011, Germany still had (although only for boys) compulsory civil or military service for school-leavers. Girls often also did a year of voluntary work in the social sphere  (Freies Soziales Jahr). Although compulsory service was stopped in 2011, the Bundesfreiwiligendienst, a national social volunteering scheme, was introduced by the government to replace it. As a result, years out before university are still the rule rather than the exception. If you then factor in that, also until 2011, children started school at age six, not five, German students are on the whole older when they start university. A picture emerges of an educational system that gives its students a better understanding of the value and necessity of time in relation to learning. It facilitates a smoother (later) entry into university, and makes for a calmer approach to study once there.

Foto (2)

There is a second major difference between Heidelberg and Durham, and that is its function as a public institution. On one of my first visits to the university library, in the evening, I found the computer room full of middle-aged and elderly men. It was visible that some of them were very poor, and having since seen the same people over several weeks it appears possible that the library is their only point of Internet access.

In the reading room similarly, most evenings the same people gather there, read the papers, talk and joke in respectful whispers. In my first lecture it was the same again, a quarter of the room was full of white haired men and women, pens at the ready, waiting for the lecturer to begin.

The university allows members of the public, of any age and with no qualifications required, to listen in on lectures, where space allows, for a small fee. The library is open to everyone. Even in my seminars, there are several retirement age students enrolled, and they are treated just like everyone else by the lecturer (who may be younger than them). Even unregistered visitors are allowed, up to a point.

A lecturer recently told the story of the time a homeless man came into his lecture half way through, sat down in the front row, warmed himself up thoroughly and applauded loudly at the end. Although it’s an unusual case, it speaks of a public perception of the university as a tolerant place.

What I’ve seen in Heidelberg builds up a picture of an institution that serves the public as a whole, and is not just the reserve of the rich or the young. Universities should not be businesses, and it is wrong to semi-privatise them, as successive governments have done. They should be funded solely by the taxpayer.

In turn, of course, the university must serve everyone, but it is clear to see that we are dealing with polar opposites here. Heidelberg University is basically free, and basically everyone’s, while Durham University is the property only of those who pay. We are detached from local people, and we don’t expect to encounter them on ‘university’ ground.

But have we not just accepted a status quo here without challenging it? Is there any reason why the public and the university should be so separate? I would argue none at all; on the contrary, it is the university’s obligation to be an open door. It is common parlance that higher education is the playground of an elite: an elite either of intelligence or of wealth, and (at Durham) frequently both. It’s always at the back of people’s minds, but it takes looking at Durham from afar to make it something impossible to ignore.

The spirit of learning must never be a miserly thing. Books are not there to be locked away behind guarded scanners; academics are not there only to serve a small number of young people, half of whom are not sure if they want to be there anyway. Let Durham take Heidelberg as an example in widening access; let the government take the German school system as a model, and if they could only scrap fees, the country’s students might be able to inherit their relaxed attitude to learning as well.

Photographs: Alex Samuels