Bright spark or flash in the pan

By Christian Seiersen

What does the future hold for 3D cinema?

With dwindling audiences and disappointing effects, doubts have been cast over the long-term prospects of revolutionary cinematic format, 3D. Cast a glance over recent box-office figures and this frank message may not come as a surprise. According to the ‘Economist’, 3D films’ share of US box-office revenue has decreased 20% from late 2010 to July this year.

The record-breaking box office hit, ‘Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows Part 2’, compounded any disappointment when it collected just 43% of its sales from 3D in the US. In comparison, 3D was responsible for over 80% of 2009 hit ‘Avatar’s’ grossing.

Is the novelty wearing off for cinema’s latest plaything? A recent survey by research firm Ipsos Mori found that people in 2010 were seven times more likely to see a 3D film over its 2D counterpart than today.

For one, directors have publically declared disillusionment with the technology. Batman rebooter Christopher Nolan has shunned the format for his highly anticipated finale ‘Dark Knight Rises’, claiming the technology might hinder the scale of the movie. At a press conference for the upcoming Tintin movie, maestro Steven Spielberg suggested 3D was used by some directors as a commercial tool without understanding its different directional requirements. (We’re looking at you, Piranha 3D).

On top of this, various discomforts have been reported by many 3D audience members. A study by the California State University found that watching the format trebled the risk of eyestrain and headache.

The killer blow has to be the audacious move of cinemas to ask audiences to wear plastic glasses. This being a public who stubbornly expect machines to run their lives and bawl at the slightest technological inconvenience, such as two or less bars of Wi-Fi. You may as well ask them to cross into Hades then concede anything to the machine.

In some cases, 3D gives directors a mandate to discard traditional elements of a movie, such as plot, to focus on delivering the ‘full 3D experience’. Which, to paraphrase, means filming a continuous explosion for 90 minutes, throwing in the occasional chunk of magnesium for dialect. The meek will not inherit the genre.

A repeat offender is Michael Bay who has approached the format with the childish glee of a pig rolling in s**t. In the ‘Transformers’ trilogy, the director sacrificed everything at the scorched altar of ‘Bayhem’. If you haven’t already seen the films, the experience is similar to being frantically shown around a playroom by a kid tanked up on Soviet energy drinks. “Here’s my robots, and here’s my helicopters… wait, what was I saying?”

Don’t start writing obituaries yet, is the message cinemas chains are eager to convey. After all investment has been heavy, with 1,065 3D-enabled screens reported in the UK at the beginning of 2011. Classic flicks such as  ‘Top Gun’, ‘The Lion King’, and ‘Titanic’ have all been signed up for 3D-remakes.

If the UK is tiring of the third dimension then the Far-East is just becoming acquainted. Technology firm RealD recently signed a deal to bring 3D to 100 Chinese cinemas. That’s not to mention the success of Hong Kong bonk buster, ‘Sex and Zen: Extreme Ecstasy’. The “world’s first 3D erotic film” smashed opening day box office records in Hong Kong. Success with emerging markets suggests 3D could still be in for a happy ending.

The consistent issue hanging over 3D films is how the technology is used. While ‘Avatar’ shot the entire film in stereoscopic 3D to acclaimed effect, some films shoot normally before converting the footage post-production into 3D. An example being whey-face Jason Momoa’s take on ‘Conan the Barbarian’. We all know what happened there.

If directors tack 3D onto their film as a gimmick to increase its commercial appeal then the 3D effects will appear unnatural and ill-suited. Real success in 3D comes from a director who understands the technology and builds the film around its technical offerings. Spielberg’s upcoming ‘Adventures of Tintin’, which was shot entirely in 3D, will be the best post-Avatar indicator of 3D’s cinematic value. Eventually it is hoped the industry becomes more acquainted with the technology. Directional techniques will be developed and finally, in a purging act of self-flagellation, ‘Shark Night 3D’ will be criminalized.