BRIC growth now myth, not reality

BRIC leaders 2014

By Isabella Allen

Brazil, Russia, India and China were on course to reshape and transform the global economy. That was when the acronym BRIC was coined in 2001 by Jim O’Neill, former chairman of Goldman Sachs, and now a key figure in the UK treasury. Even as recently as three years ago, as the developed world continued to struggle through the recession of 2008, these emerging markets were supposed to be the world’s new engines of growth.

But over the last few months, years even, the BRIC hype has been forced to face hard truths. Could the once solid-sounding acronym now stand for flaking and vulnerable economies?

The situation in Brazil is particularly bad. The country, whose economy is heavily reliant on commodity exports, officially went into recession at the end of August. Lowering commodity prices has meant that Brazil’s GDP is forecast to shrink by 3% this year.  The effects are rippling through society, with unemployment at a five-year high and wages being squeezed.

Brazil is also in trouble politically. President Dilma Rousseff is not only dealing with a crashing economy, but also corruption within the state-owned oil giant, Petrobas. She has recently been labelled as the least popular president since democracy was restored in Brazil in the 1980s. According to Forbes, under Rousseff’s leadership, the country has gone “from booming to gloomy”, with her popularity ratings in single figures, and thousands taking to the streets demanding her impeachment.

Other BRIC nations are not faring any better. Russia has suffered from collapsing oil prices, a devaluation in currency and western sanctions restricting its trade, meaning that the country is experiencing its worst recession in six years. China, the world’s second largest economy, grew at its slowest pace in 24 years in 2014, at a rate of 7.4%. Growth in GDP for the third quarter of 2015 is likely to have slowed further to 6.8%. Not to mention the Chinese stock market crash this summer, which wiped off five trillion US dollars in value, as investors sold shares over fears about the slowing economy. In comparison, India’s economy is holding up fairly well, and it’s just about bouncing back from a rocky period in 2013. It helps that, unlike Brazil or Russia, it’s not dependent on China for trade. Nevertheless, India’s recovery is far from robust, as there remains a relatively high level of unemployment, and poverty is still a key issue.

The outlook for the BRICS doesn’t look promising; even O’Neill has said the term may need to be abbreviated to IC by the end of the decade. It appears that even IC could be in danger. The term is hugely outdated and many would argue that it was a rather frivolous grouping in the first place.

The only thing that likened the BRIC nations to each other was that, in 2001, they were all experiencing substantial growth. They are still the four largest emerging markets in their regions; China and India dominate in Asia, Russia in emerging Europe, and Brazil in Latin America. Yet other than their size and economic potential, they had, and still have, little in common. The structures of the economies are very different: Brazil specialises in agriculture, Russia in commodities, India in services, and China in manufacturing. Compared to the much sounder grouping of the ‘Asian Tigers’, a reference to the economies of Taiwan, South Korea, Hong Kong and Singapore, all four of which have high-income economies specialising in areas of competitive advantage, the BRIC group holds little substantial worth.

The BRIC acronym came into further contention in 2010 because it included no African country. Overlooking Africa implied that the continent was economically irrelevant and raised doubts over the group’s legitimacy to represent the emerging world. Nigeria and South Africa were both candidates, but as only one could keep the acronym intact, the BRICs became BRICS, and South Africa joined. This went against the trend that BRICs were the largest economy in their region, as Nigeria currently holds that title in Africa. Nigeria has nonetheless been included in a new acronym. Last year O’Neill coined the term MINT, referring to Mexico, Indonesia, Nigeria and Turkey, which are all set to be the next economic powerhouses.

Certainly the shine of the BRICS has been tarnished; the countries, which were bound together by their economic prosperity, are now bound together in struggle. What remains to be seen is whether MINT will follow in the footsteps of its predecessor.

Photograph: Roberto Stuckert Filho via Wikimedia Commons