“Both sides of the story”: Sir John Coles on working under PM Margaret Thatcher

By Lizzie Follows

’Millions of people have written stuff about Margaret Thatcher who frankly didn’t know what they were talking about. There were a few of us who, because we spent every day with her for two or three years, really knew her. Don’t think I worship her as some divine goddess; she had her faults. It’s just important to hear both sides of the story.’’

Sir John Coles was Private Secretary for Foreign and Defence Affairs to Margaret Thatcher during the period 1981-84; a period which saw the late former Prime Minister rise from low opinion polls, through the Falkland’s War and into extraordinary international recognition. I was keen to speak to someone who had known this divisive political figure so personally, and during such a tense period of modern British politics.

Though that seems a world away from the house in rural Cambridgeshire I pay a visit for tea and cake, Sir John remembers his time in the Foreign and Cabinet Offices vividly. He now gives local talks titled: ‘The Real Margaret Thatcher’ and is keen to share another side to the ‘Iron Lady’.

Sir John shows me through to his living room and offers me an armchair by the window. The room is full of books about the Middle East, and I see one is written by his wife, Anne Coles. He seems a fairly quiet and serious man at first, and I am glad that Anne quickly follows us in with a tray of coffee, biscuits and cake and starts asking about Durham, where she used to be a Geography Lecturer. The two proceed to test my knowledge of the history of the newspaper and the origin of the word ‘palatinate’ itself.

Looking it up on his phone, Coles tells Anne as she comes back into the room: ‘’It is both a colour and a sort of territory.’’

Sir John describes his pathway to becoming personal private secretary to the prime minister as ‘unorthodox’. A large part of his career has been spent living and working in the Middle East, which attracted his interest when the 1956 Suez Crisis occurred in his final year studying history at Oxford University.

His gravitation towards diplomatic service was also helped by convenience. ‘’There I was in college, and 200 yards down the High Street was the school where the examinations for people going into the civil service took place. You had to just turn up and write the papers.’’

After spending two ‘’absolutely delightful’’ years studying Arabic in Lebanon – as it was custom then to learn, what was defined as, a ‘hard language’ upon admission to the Foreign Office – Sir John held his first international placement as Third Secretary in Khartoum, Sudan.

I imagine this was quite the contrast to his rural Oxfordshire upbringing, but he doesn’t remember feeling concerned by it.

“Of course, moving so far away was a brand-new experience, and I suppose it was more unsettling then than I remember it now, but I wouldn’t say it was a shock. It was absolutely delightful. Sudan is enormous, and I got to travel the length and breadth of it.”

‘’I grew up in a little village, we never went on holiday abroad and my parents wouldn’t go to London – they thought it was too far away!”

It was also in Khartoum that he met his wife Anne, who was studying for her postgraduate research there.

Sir John’s subsequent diplomatic career took him from Dubai, to Cairo, to Brussels, until, to his surprise, he was called to Downing Street in 1981 to be interviewed for the position of Private Secretary for Foreign and Defence Affairs; a role, in those days, traditionally filled by a Foreign Office nominee.

“The day came when I was going to be interviewed by the Prime Minister, and it was very strange experience indeed. I had met Margaret Thatcher once or twice before, but not for any length of time. She was very nervous, which seemed very odd – that wasn’t my image of this lady, and she spent most of the interview criticising the Foreign Office. She was sort of goading me all the time and, after about 45 minutes, she said: ‘Well I suppose you better come then’. I went out and I asked the principal private secretary if that was a decision, and he said: ‘Yeah that’s a decision.’ And that was that really.”

‘’Apparently it was always like that. She hated new appointments because she got very used to and loyal to the people who she worked with. She wasn’t certain that she was very good at summing up people straight away and she didn’t want to make a wrong decision.”

‘’She wasn’t certain that she was very good at summing up people straight away and she didn’t want to make a wrong decision

The period working in Number 10 was certainly the most intense of Coles’ career.

“I don’t think I used the word stressed back then. It was just a place you had to work very very hard, and time was not your own.”

The working day on Downing Street began by 8am and had no defined end, though it never finished before 8pm. “Sometimes we’d sleep in the place and resume the next morning. I hated that; it is an awful place to sleep because it was very claustrophobic, but if you opened the windows all the clocks of London ring bells at 3-minute intervals.”

Despite long days, and sometimes seven-day working weeks, Sir John found the work, and company, immensely stimulating.

“[Thatcher] was an extremely stimulating person to work for; very active, very challenging. She just didn’t accept conventional wisdom – she really wanted to get to the root of things, and I found that a good process.”

‘’And [he draws her into contrast with some recent prime ministers], she believed she had a duty to work every day. She worked hard, she wasn’t sloppy, and she was highly intelligent. I can see very clearly some Prime Ministers actually don’t understand what they’re dealing with.”

Coles also reflects on the more ‘human’ side of the Iron Lady that the public didn’t get to see.

“No politician would want to be caught weeping on television, but that’s not to say we didn’t see it.”

“No politician would want to be caught weeping on television, but that’s not to say we didn’t see it

“And she cared immensely for us, her private staff. She got to know Anne quite well and was often checking in on the family. I remember one time I let on that my son, Peter, had a bad cold. That was a mistake! Later, during a cabinet meeting, she suddenly cut over whoever was speaking and said: ‘John! How long has Peter had that cold?’” Coles still cringes telling this story 40-years on.

Sir John is keen to stress this element of her character, not, he re-affirms, in a rose-tinted or worshipping way, rather he felt he had a duty to share his experience of ‘the real Margaret Thatcher’.

“I trained as a historian – that’s what I did at Oxford – so I just had that view of history that, somehow, you need you to create objective accounts of what actually happened in the past.”

After his time as Private Secretary came to an end, he went off to Scotland for some time and wrote out a long appreciation of her.

“I had no intention whatsoever of publishing it, at least until she died. Public servants simply didn’t write confidential stuff about the people they were working for – that would have absolutely wrecked relations. My purpose was to keep it for future historians, so they would be able to draw on somebody who was actually there at the time.”

When she died, Coles deposited his appreciation into the Churchill College Cambridge archive. “From there, it becomes public property, and it has been used by historians since.”

After his stint in Downing Street, Sir John continued his diplomatic career for another decade. This took him to Jordan and Australia. It was as Ambassador to Jordan (1984-88) that he formed a close friendship with the late King Hussein.

“I was keeping London aware of Hussein’s thinking on developments in the Arab-Israel context. He certainly made me very welcome, and a lot of cultivation went into that relationship… [he goes on to allude to tennis matches and private lunches]”.

Coles maintained a close relationship with Thatcher; a relationship which helped strengthen British relations with both Jordan and Australia, countries he succeeded in encouraging the Prime Minister to visit in 1985 and 1988, respectively.

Looking at the current state of the world, I ask Sir John what he sees as the biggest challenges facing UK-international relations today.

“That’s a big question. We’re facing a more disturbed world than at any time during my diplomatic service. One of my biggest worries, and I’m sure it worries the present Prime Minister and his cabinet ministers, is the declining relationship with America, which has been so strong throughout all my life and has been a kind of guarantee of British security.”

“I also think Britain should be looking to develop the closest possible relations with the countries of Europe. You’ve got a very insecure situation and little Britain, by itself, can’t handle this. It needs friends, and the obvious friends of those on your doorstep. I think Brexit was a disaster; it will take time to reverse it, but I think it will happen one day.”

Image: Sir John Coles