Boaty McBoatface: an unfair, belittling name
By Stuart Goldie
So, Boaty McBoatface is the public’s runaway choice of name for the Natural Environment Research Council’s new £200 million artic exploration vessel. The media seems broadly happy about this and everyone is talking an awful lot about the British sense of humour. Whilst I enthusiastically agree with mocking oneself at every possible opportunity, I am less happy with Boaty McBoatface.
It’s an utterly stupid name. I think we all agree with that, the issue is whether that stupidity is humorous or whether it is trivialising vital research into the long term, irreversible affect our species is having on the planet. Many say no and in fact argue that the viral media presence the campaign has had will boost public engagement with the research. Now this may be true but it’s a pretty damning reflection of our society when permanent damage to global ecosystems and the possibility of 100s of millions of climate refugees has to compete with an American’s backside for public attention. Shall we also vote to name the camp in which the entire population of the Maldives may have to take shelter; or cheerfully report on ‘Fearsome Frank’ the storm that may overcome European flood defences and leave the Netherlands underwater?
Of course not, and I’m being unfair. No one is suggesting that we treat climate change with frivolity and degrade its victims with crass jokes, but are we honestly saying that we, as a people, are incapable of paying attention to fundamental research into species threatening climate change and our planets history without a media storm built around a ridiculous name picked by the public?
Scientists, engineers, explorers and pioneers work bloody hard; and since pre-history there have been people asking the big questions, attempting the impossible and risking their lives, following dreams of the unknown, to get society to where it is today. These people deserve recognition. Most are driven by the desire to learn, the joy of pure discovery with little regard for their own legacy. Galileo was persecuted for his ideas; Alan Turing worked in secrecy at Bletchley Park; a personal favourite, Agnes Pockels persevered with her research into surface science at home despite relying on men to publish the work. And in contrast, Einstein’s most famous photograph was a result of him trying to mock the photographers waiting outside his birthday celebration by poking his tongue out.
My point is that science is a fantastic story, too rarely told and that those involved deserve genuine recognition for their work. Having something named after you is a great honour, and for that to be taken away for the sake of 10 seconds of quiet amusement hardly seems fair. Personally my vote would be for RSS Lovelock, named after James Lovelock, the inventor of a gas chromatograph used for atmospheric analysis by its inventor on board the current artic exploration vessel RSS Shackleton to measure CFCs. In fact, the work was completed unfunded because there was so little faith in his device and yet it would go on to reveal the damage we were doing to the ozone layer. This informed the Montreal Protocol, which banned CFCs and has allowed the hole to slowly repair itself. This is seen as one of the landmark achievements of environmental science and Lovelock, best known for the Gaia Theory, has become a ‘household name’ in environmental groups the world over.
And for those still worried about public engagement, we did not resort to naming a revolutionary new space vehicle ‘Uncle Sam’s rocket thing’, or a high resolution space telescope ‘twinkle twinkle’. We named the Space Shuttle Columbus in honour of the voyage of discovery to the new world and the Hubble Space Telescope after a brilliant astronomer, and they got plenty of attention around the world. And whilst a new artic research vessel may not be as glamorous or impressive as space exploration, I don’t believe we should degrade the journey of discovery to gain a few seconds of air time. Let’s not belittle the achievements of those that came before in an attempt to compete with popular culture. The history of human achievement is better than that; it’s an epic tale worthy of our attention.
This probably all seems like a huge overreaction to what is essentially a non-story; the name of one ship that is set to replace another ship that nobody knew much about anyway. But for those who have dedicated their lives to the betterment of humanity – the people who have genuinely spent decades working on ideas that change the world it’s far more than that…It’s about the trivialisation of what they do and by implication who they are. It’s not a new idea, honouring the achievements on which the modern world is built, but it’s certainly a worthy one.
“If I have seen further, it is by standing on the shoulders of giants.” – Isaac Newton, 1676
Let’s not forget the giants.
Photograph: Wikipedia via Creative Commons
