Black Friday in lockdown: a welcome boost to retail or a consumerist demon?

By Henry Kilding

Black Friday: the foundation to my loathing of the hysteric consumerism that has gripped the U.K. in the last decade. Having worked numerous retail jobs I have always been sceptical of this Americanism, knowing full well that better deals can be found earlier in the year. Yet, in these economically trying times, the onslaught of buying that Black Friday illicits may prove a saving grace, or a double-edged sword.

Originally born in 1950s Philidelphia, Black Friday denoted frantic buying in the post-Thanksgiving week, with heightened profits being marked in black in retailers’ books. By the 1980s it was a codified American phenomenon that gripped the nation annually. Yet, Black Friday only appeared in the U.K. in 2013 when Asda, owned by the Walmart group, held its own version. Ever since it has grown into a behemoth of a celebration of consumerism.  Sales reached £7.5 billion in 2019 with Barclaycard recording a peak of 1,184 transactions a second.

Black Friday this year raises some alarming questions for both the consumer and businesses

After two lockdowns that have brought highstreets to their knees and lacking consumer demand, Black Friday spending should appear a welcome saviour. Lloyds Bank predicts that there will be a spending increase of £750 million for 2020. Notably many giants of the market have evolved their campaigns into ‘Black November’ or ‘Black Fiveday’, with Curry’s PC World, John Lewis and Amazon all having extended deals from mid-November. Online retail for the month is already up by 61%. Moreover, by encouraging pre-Christmas shopping online there is the hope of avoiding a high street meltdown once restrictions are lifted.

“Great!” you may say, thankful that you won’t have to see news footage of two middle-aged men slogging it out in the aisles of Tesco for that reduced 50” TV. Yet, Black Friday this year raises some alarming questions for both the consumer and businesses. According to the Centre for Retail Research whilst online sales are expected to be £2 billion higher, the high street is expected to lose £3 billion. The plight of the physical store has been abundantly noticed this year, and without this major sales event in person, the fate of many more shops may be sealed, particularly those without a strong online presence.

Black Friday has brought out some of the worst in us

More alarmingly, I ask the consumer to beware. In a study by Which?, nine out of ten products being sold in the major Black Friday events could have been found at the same price or cheaper at other times this year. From experience in clothes retail I can recall many deals being consistently better in Boxing Day sales, only a month later. Black Friday is in many respects superficial, especially with the ‘exclusivity’ of deals being somewhat diminished when applied to the whole month. The event merely panders to consumer insecurities about getting gifts cheaper and before the Christmas rush, thus to some extent exploiting its participants.   

On a deeper level, we should perhaps be questioning whether to indulge in the spending that the big retailers are propagating in light of struggling small businesses. Yes, a general boost to the economy may be welcome but does Jeff Bezos really need more pocket lining? More broadly Black Friday has brought out some of the worst in us, often buying simply on the pretense of ‘a bargain’. Perhaps that spending could be better applied to sustainable local outfits or charitable causes. As much as some may want a scrap over the last Playstation 5 or De Longhi Coffee machine, it really is a sad reality to witness the blind materialism that takes hold in the name of Black Friday.

Image: Markus Spiske via Unsplash.