Bishop of Durham talks student faith

A FEW WEEKS AGO, there was growing expectation that the Church of England could be looking for a new a leader. “Bash the Bishop” and “Is the Archbishop bonkers?” were two of the kinder headlines that greeted the Archbishop of Canterbury the morning after the night before, when he had dared to suggest that the adoption of Sharia law in the UK “seems unavoidable”.

When Palatinate spoke to the Bishop of Durham, Dr Tom Wright, in Hild Bede on Sunday 17 February, the media circus had long since died down and Dr Rowan Williams was probably resting a little more comfortably in Lambeth Palace. The Bishop, fresh from General Synod, was in Durham to preach at Bede Chapel, and took time to talk to Palatinate about, amongst other things, the interface between state and religion, modern-day Christian crusaders, and the Christian Union.

The Church has continued relevance in the student community, he said, “because the questions about God and the world are not going to go away, and student life has always been a time when people can explore and take positions and see where they lead.“ In recent weeks, the Christian Union in Durham has come under attack from people who consider its ethos and members to be fundamentalist. Referring to it as the “‘f’ word”, Dr Wright said that he is worried about the way in which people are using ‘fundamentalist’. He is not convinced that there is much that corresponds to such a description in this country compared with nations like the United States.

He singled out Richard Dawkins’ work for picking on “ridiculous rightwing fundamentalists”, and neglecting to acknowledge that “most serious Christians of whatever stripe would not be a million miles near the people who he is attacking”. The Bishop believes
that instead of creating this divide, we should be engaging in “wise discourse, and listening and sharing with people’s arguments”. As a former president of the Oxford Inter-Collegiate Christian Union, he believes that this is what a university should be about.

Dr Wright strongly believes that the Archbishop of Canterbury was right to raise the issue of Sharia law. However, with the West’s less than complementary view of Sharia law and its association with fundamentalism, was it wise of the Archbishop to venture onto such controversial ground? The Bishop questioned the media judgment of Dr Rowan Williams and his media advisors. “One thing that concerns me is the strategy of doing an interview on the World at One, before the lecture at the Royal Courts of Justice.” The result was an interview which did not give time for him to include all “the caveats and cautions” which were careful and measured in the lecture.

The Bishop also raised his concerns about the apparent restrictions being placed on individuals with a faith. Referring to the banning of Muslim women wearing headscarves in France and the English woman ired from British Airways for wearing a cross to work, Dr Wright praised the Archbishop for having dared to spark a debate. “These things would not have been thinkable ten or twenty years ago, and it’s a perfectly sensible question to say how have we moved to a situation where societies can pass laws that people who are actually following quite apparently harmless religious customs ind restricting? To raise those issues is extremely important. I’m not going to apologise for that.”

Recently, a magistrate in Shefield lost his appeal at the High Court after being told that he was required to authorise gay partners to adopt a couple, something which in conscience he said he could not do. “Whatever your view on the gay issue”, said the Bishop, “you may well feel the state does not have the right to impose laws and say you have to do it even if it hurts your conscience”. He recognised that the interface between state and religion is one that should be closely monitored, and cited the encroaching secularism which wants to drive religion out altogether in defending the need for religious representation in the House of Lords in any constitutional reform.

The Bishop has not been shy to speak out on political matters. The subject of Iraq drew his strongest criticism. When asked if George Bush and Tony Blair have damaged the image of Christianity, Dr Wright said: “Enormously, enormously. I had this horrible sense of ‘I told you so’.” He spoke out in opposition to the war in 2002 and 2003, and “was horriied at the vacuousness of the arguments which were advanced for our going to war”.

He referred to a debate on 24 January this year, when not one speaker mentioned the religious reasons behind the American drive towards war, which was massive in terms of pushing the Americans towards it. “The double tragedy is that then Tony Blair without any of that motivation went along with the American agenda, including being prepared to play fast and loose, or at least some of the other staff was, with intelligence reports.” He is clearly dismayed and frustrated that two would-be Christian leaders went to war which he described
as “a scandal and a disaster”.