Bird Box review
By Anton Blaubach
Directed by Susanne Bier, Bird Box is a sci-fi drama based on the novel by Josh Malerman. The film is set in a dystopian world where an unseen force has annihilated the human population and the only thing that the survivors really know about this force is that by looking at it, you die. Despite the danger of going outside, a woman and two children risk making a hazardous trip to find a sanctuary that has been promised to them. Journeying through forest and rapids, they miraculously survive against all odds and threats.
Bier discusses in a Director’s Cut DGA podcast, that her greatest challenge in making this film was in maintaining the suspense and fear without ever seeing the actual beings.
It is certainly a tense film, and an interesting premise
None of the characters know what this evil force looks like, because if they did they would be dead. I feel though, that Bier could have induced greater fear and tension in the viewer if a few things had been done differently. The moments where the camera shows what Malorie is seeing through her translucent blindfold are too short and fail to increase a sense of fear in a way that could easily have been done with more focus on sound-scaping and longer first-person shots of the vague outlines and little light that came through the blindfold.
With sight being the primary sense that humans rely on, the concept of having to restrict one of your senses in order to survive is an interesting but certainly not a new one.
The film strongly resembles John Krasinski’s A Quiet Place
They are both the story of a family who have to be silent in order to survive creatures who hunt anyone that makes too much noise. There have been plenty of other apocalyptic sci-fi dramas in which survivors struggle to hold their families together, and Bird Box brings nothing new to the table. Ultimately it has a cliché storyline, with a cliché ending and a cliché set of characters, but it is saved by a couple of factors, which Netflix knew would make for a successful movie on their platform. The number of A-list actors and in particular, the clear typecasting of John Malkovich and Lil Rel Howery for example, are probably the greatest contributors to the success of the movie on Netflix, which had over 45 million views in the first week of it being available. Though, I doubt that this film would have been much of a box office hit at all had it been released in cinemas only. It is, however, not unenjoyable to watch at home and I don’t think it’s a film you would really get anything from by watching in a cinema given the mediocre cinematography and score, and it thus makes for an alright Netflix film.
The main issue I took with Bird Box was that the screenplay is riddled with unclear and unexplained moments
As Amy Nicholson remarks in her review, “the what, why and how of the crisis never gets answered. Bird Box only grapples with the question of when”. The film never really explains why the evil force causes some of those who see it to kill themselves, while other already insane people become bloodthirsty psychopaths. In an interview, Bier needed to clarify that those who are “dangerously or violently insane” are those who are “able to see” – something which is not communicated well in the film, and nor is it explained why they fight together against other survivors.
Another thing I felt was poorly done was how at the beginning of the film, the evil being manages to overcome some characters but not all who are looking in the exact same direction. The first victim of this wave of suicides we see is in a hospital glass corridor whilst every other passer-by is somehow immune to the same reaction. Furthermore, the way that Malorie and the children navigate along a lengthy and treacherous river virtually unscathed is another thing that made little sense to me. I would not usually comment on small things such as these, but I really felt that they detracted from my ability to feel immersed in the film or emotionally attached to any characters.
There is nothing new in this movie
It is a distinctly average apocalypse film that ticks all the boxes to get the attention that it has garnered thus far. Furthermore, for me, the fact that we could never actually see the evil force was, unfortunately, more frustrating than immersing. Though the ending is predictable, the film does at least succeed in building a last-stand mentality and, with some good performances given the characters the actors had to work with, it wasn’t all bad.
Photograph: Pixabay.com
