Big Fish, Little Fish, Cardboard Box

By Madeleine Wright

“I have read absolutely nothing”. That skulked into my head right about the same time tutorials began. Thankfully for my English degree, it’s not quite true. Nevertheless, sitting in a lecture hall filled by driven, high-achieving and well-read students, it was easy to get caught up determining my own adequacy via comparisons. With post-Meningitis-jab swollen arms I had scrolled through pre-reading lists and filled out my health centre registration forms. Friends had assured me that Freshers’ Week would be any combination of utterly bizarre, intensely fun, and absolutely terrifying. Coming from overseas, I was prepared for as much. I had not, however, pre-empted that the academic changes would need adjusting to too. In the move from school to university, some slip seamlessly into the academic side of things, but a great many are shadowed by unjustified feelings of inadequacy. We go from big fish, to very small fish, and at the same time lose the protective cardboard box too – it is easy to question your very place in this new environment.

In the move from school to university, some slip seamlessly into the academic side of things, but a great many are shadowed by unjustified feelings of inadequacy

The term ‘Imposter Phenomenon’, evolving later to ‘Imposter Syndrome’, was first presented in the late 70s by Dr Pauline R. Clance and Dr Suzanne A. Imes. The phenomenon describes feeling inadequate, undeserving of success; as if so far what you have achieved has been down to luck and any moment now that luck will run out. University students are ripe for picking when it comes to this. Not only are we part of a sea of high achievers, but we no longer have the relationships and structures of school that gave us constant validation. Previously, with every correct answer and eloquent response in class, you grew in your teachers’ and classmates’ estimation. Now, I’m ashamed to say that first year passed without me retaining half the names in my tutor groups. Here, you can do well in an essay, but at school, to show that you tried hard was worth a pat on the back too. Without frequent personal feedback and validation, it becomes easier to think that you’re just not good enough.

At school, to show that you tried hard was worth a pat on the back too

At the start of second term, my friend from school called me in tears. Exams were ahead, and it was all too much. She’d been working more effectively than ever before. Still, she was convinced that she hadn’t done enough, couldn’t do enough, and she was terrified. One point broke through the sobs as I asked, “Who is this stress for?”. What followed was a conversation (much less ground-breaking than we allowed ourselves to think at the time) revolving around that simple question of, you know what, who are we proving ourselves to? In the anonymity of university, surely it is now safe to focus your effort on doing yourself justice. For you, not anyone else. For me, that was the key. School’s familiar cardboard box has dissolved from around us – now we need to learn, above all, to value our own achievements ourselves. For anyone experiencing uncertainty in the school-to-university transition, the two things I’ve taken from first-year are: 1) the need to stop relying on external validation, and 2) learning to feel content with being a work in progress: a little fish.

In the anonymity of university, surely it is now safe to focus your effort on doing yourself justice

Undoubtedly easier said than done – being satisfied with less than outstanding in every walk of life does not always come naturally. But wow: it’s liberating. By finding ways to acknowledge your own abilities and personal successes, you can pull away from constantly judging yourself comparatively, and the resulting dissatisfaction.

I haven’t read the entirety of The Canon, but I’ll work on that. When someone mentions a poet I have never heard of I can learn from them without feeling inferior. Safe in the knowledge that with what I have encountered, and what I’ve learnt thanks to my international upbringing and the IB course, I can offer completely different, interesting angles. And when my resolutions lose strength, Elizabeth Day’s How to Fail podcast always seems to work a charm.

I can learn from people without feeling inferior

Image by Rawpixel via Pixaby