Beyond the book: the age of fanfiction.

By Aimee Dickinson

Ah yes, the literature that is globally recognised as garbage, written for suppressed 15-year-old girls, a horrific tradition enabled by the internet, spawning the likes of My Immortal and 50 Shades of Grey.

Fanfiction. The concept is simple: people read a book, they get to the end, they are not satisfied. They are convinced they know the characters better than the authors who wrote them. Harry Potter was meant to be evil. It was Sherlock Holmes’ destiny to fall wildly in love with John Watson. So they write the characters into various hilarious, compromising or weird situations with varying levels of success. This being said, published works such as Neil Gaiman’s A Study in Emerald, and the wildly funny Pride and Prejudice and Zombies all started out with a writer picking up a pre-existing book and thinking, ‘hey, wouldn’t it be weird if I were to make that character do this?’

They are convinced they know the characters better than the authors who wrote them.

No matter how poorly written, fanfiction demonstrates a unique engagement with literature that has been around since long before the invention of the internet. Works that form major tenants of the literary canon can be identified as what we would now call fanfiction. In Renaissance England, taking the premise of characters from pre-existing sources, be those classical myths, the Bible or works by foreign authors, was both expected and accepted as the status quo.

Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet is an adaptation of Ovid’s account of Pyramus and Thisbe. John Milton’s Paradise Lost took the characters of Adam, Eve, and Satan and gave them psychological and historical backgrounds which far exceeded the Biblical text. Western literature has always relied on what came before and it could be argued that the new generation is turning to writing which already exists, as a spark for their creative writing interests.

Works that form major tenants of the literary canon can be identified as what we would now call fanfiction.

There are several factors which can be attested to its growing popularity. Fanfiction websites provide platforms which allow writers to practise their skills and receive feedback from a reading public without having to find actual publishers. As all these sites are usually free, meaning there are no profits to be gained, writers simply write for the love of writing. This does mean some of the writing is questionable, but there are a surprising number of brilliant, engaging and emotional works to be found on online platforms.

Another reason for fanfiction’s recent popularity is that it allows readers to explore representation, which is often so lacking in published books, particularly in terms of making their favourite characters LGBT+. A perfect example of this is Madeline Miller’s 2011 book The Song of Achilles, a novel based on the Iliad, which explores the possibility of a love story between Achilles and Patroclus. Not only does this novel develop suggestions from the original work, but it also appeals to a young audience of readers in a market which still struggles with issues of representation.

it allows readers to explore representation

This is not to say there aren’t problems to be found within fanfiction writing. On a personal note, there are certain genres such as self-insert fanfictions which I will always loathe with a passion; they are poorly written, clichéd and just downright creepy. However, there are more serious issues at play, particularly in regards to fanfiction written about real people, from film and music stars to Youtubers.

For example, After, a Wattpad fanfiction by Anna Todd and original character/Harry Styles story, is being made into a movie to be released in April of this year. It follows the life of an American college student who, in the eloquent words of Capital FM, ’falls for a tattooed bad boy’ inspired by Harry Styles. There has been extensive opposition to this film due to arguments it encourages toxic relationships and outdated gender stereotypes. Harry Styles has yet to comment on how he feels, and honestly, I doubt he cares. But is a film like this evidence of an increasingly toxic fan culture, where fans feel like they are privileged to every part of these stars’ lives? Is this not an appropriation of their identity and invasion of their private lives, even if it is only a fictional one?

Photograph: Nick Morrison via Unsplash