Beyond record-breaking summers: which statistics are a more representative measure of climate change?
By Ava Farnsworth
Each year we open our news apps to yet another “record breaking summer” where “temperatures have never been higher!” Even well-established news outlets such as the BBC report on climate change with a focus on attention-grabbing statistics such as these. This begs the question however — are these compelling statistics a representative portrayal of climate change?
If we focus our attention heavily on the oft-mentioned five hottest summers on record when trying to depict the trends in anthropogenic climate change, one could argue that temperature simply fluctuates throughout the years, rather than the global average increase 97% of scientists agree upon according to the International Panel on Climate. In order to accurately portray global warming, the scientific community prefer to use rates of change of temperature.
Our World in Data report average sea surface temperatures since 1850 in graphical formats, where even without the presence of numerical values, a visible increase in rate is seen. Individual temperatures themselves fluctuate within this period, however rates of change bring one’s attention to longer term changes.
Studies by the Met Office reveal that UK winters are progressively getting warmer and wetter, leading to increased extreme weather events
Statistics often rely on large data sets to reach suitable confidence levels to be deemed ‘statistically significant’ — it is believed in the scientific community that it is important that data presented for public consumption should be no different. For example, a list of ‘hottest summers on record’ can limit the data we are considering to as few as 5 data points in a set, which would not satisfy the ‘rule of thumb’, by which a data set must exceed the 30 data points necessary to satisfy the Central Limit Theorem: a theory widely used by statisticians to ensure representative statistics. The more data points, the more statistically significant the resulting trend. Therefore, organisations like NASA prefer to use data sets reaching further back in time when analysing climate change, through periods of glacial-interglacial cycles.
Is it only our summers that are ‘record breaking?’ The warming UK summers are a breath of fresh air for the British public as we spend the majority of our year plunged into the grey misery of winter. However, it’s been a while since we’ve had a ‘Beast from the East’ or have been confined to our houses by walls of snow during ‘The Big Freeze.’ Studies by the Met Office reveal that UK winters are progressively getting warmer and wetter, leading to increased extreme weather events. In a 2021 issue, they outline that last decade, there were 14% fewer days of ground frost compared to the average for 1981-2010. And whilst I’m sure no one will miss having to cover their crops with a garish tarpaulin each winter, this statistic and ones of a similar nature perhaps indicate the severity of modern-day climate change to a greater degree than simply one hot summer.
News outlets like the BBC remain on the right side of history with respects to their reports on climate change — reporting what they see, and what they see is a warming world. However, perhaps the general coverage in science journalism could focus on more robust and long-term statistics, ones that display to the British public an accurate picture of the trajectory of what is happening, rather than presenting ad hoc evaluations on a new summer record. After all, in the wake of climate denial or even climate apathy, it’s nice to have the right statistics on your side!
Image: Novoklimov via Wikimedia Commons

